Robert Leroux’s Political Economy and Liberalism in France: The Contributions of Frederic Bastiat is a book with a mission. The mission is the rehabilitation of the reputation of the nineteenth-century thinker Frederic Bastiat as a serious economist. The need to rehabilitate Bastiat’s reputation arises, as Leroux indicates in his first chapter, from repeated critiques by economists such as Schumpeter, who said, “I do not hold that Bastiat was a bad theorist. I hold that he was no theorist,” and Emile James and Gerald Jorland, who, respectively, assessed him as “a brilliant pamphleteer” and “a propagandist more than a theorist.”
Leroux thus sets himself the task of proving that Bastiat is an important original thinker as well as the brilliant literary stylist and important popularizer of political and economic theories we already know him to be. To that end, Leroux’s book devotes individual chapters to, among other topics, considerations of Bastiat’s correspondence, his writings about England, his considerations of science, and the status of history in his work, as well as the particular issues and debates upon which Bastiat’s attention was concentrated. Unhappily, while the chapters provide a useful window into Bastiat’s lively and interesting mind, they do not satisfactorily accomplish the book’s mission.
Leroux praises Bastiat’s appreciation of Malthus, for example, as an appreciation that ran counter to what Bastiat called “the violent attacks [made by] … authors of no consequence, of no standing, so uninformed that they display their ignorance on every page they write” (51–2). While this is certainly true, it is by no means revolutionary, and Leroux must consistently point towards Say as having preceded Bastiat in his mostly positive reception of Malthus. Indeed, throughout the text, Bastiat is described as Say-inspired and as following Say. Again, Leroux’s praise for Bastiat’s interpretation of Adam Smith turns on Bastiat’s critique of the labor theory of value, a theory that had already been criticized by the time Bastiat wrote. While Leroux gestures in the direction of an argument made by Jacques Garello and others that Bastiat proposes as an alternate theory of value that outdoes anything until Menger, Leroux does not give his readers that argument, nor does he point out anything, other than Garello’s commendation, that makes it exceptional.
Perhaps because of my training in literature, I am liable to see Bastiat as a French offshoot of the glorious prose tradition of writers such as Samuel Johnson and Jonathan Swift. As a result, I find the nervousness about his brilliant literary style somewhat perplexing. The idea that writing better than anyone else might be cause for criticism and dismissal is one that is entirely foreign to my discipline. As a result, comments in Leroux’s text that “Bastiat’s style clearly had something to do with the dismissal of his works by many economists” (p. 27) are confounding. And, Leroux’s assertion that “We may legitimately ask why Bastiat usually chose to express himself in a style quite foreign to most economists. Why did he employ such humour? Why did he make use of irony, sometimes to excess?” (p. 23) is quite simply answered, on my side of the disciplinary boundary, with, “Because he’s a good writer.”
For those of us who admire Bastiat, it would certainly be nice to be able to say that he is a great original thinker as well as a great stylist, but we should not feel that we have to make this assertion. We do not have to put theory on a pedestal and try to shove Bastiat up next to it in order to assert his significance. Do we really need stronger evidence for his continued importance than the consistent modern recurrence to the perfection of his takedown of the Broken Window Fallacy, or his devastating critique of protectionism in the Candlemaker’s Petition? Do we really need a better argument for the need for a revival of Bastiat scholarship than neglected gems like the negative railroad, and his arguments for blunted shovels and for the outlawing of the use of the right hand?
Bastiat’s innovations are not in the discovery of new economic theories and concepts. They are in his expression of vital economic theories and concepts in witty and unforgettable ways. His style is his content. As Deirdre McCloskey says, “The two are yoke and white in a scrambled egg” (McCloskey Reference McCloskey1998, p. 10). Or, as Pope would put it, Bastiat gives us “What oft was Thought, but ne’er so well Exprest.” This is indeed a “style quite foreign to most economists” (p. 23) and Bastiat should be praised and valued and emulated for it, regardless of his status as a theoretician.
