In A Most Masculine State, Madawi Al-Rasheed explores the relationship between the “religious nationalism” of the Saudi state, tribalism, and Wahhabism to understand the persistent exclusion of women at the legal, social, political, and economic levels. Wahhabi, or “religious nationalism,” is defined as a politicized religious tradition that brought together a fragmented Arabian society while simultaneously constructing a pious national identity in Saudi Arabia, and served as the framework that defined gender relations and women's roles within the nation. Al-Rasheed's central argument is that Wahhabism as religious knowledge and tribalism as a mode of social organization are insufficient to explain the deeply-entrenched gender inequality in Saudi Arabia. Her unique contribution to the discourse on women in Saudi Arabia is that she considers the role of the state, and the interaction between the state, religious nationalism, and the social and cultural patriarchal systems, as critical to understanding how control over women's issues has been at the center of the national religious projects. The state, she maintains, is the critical actor by which women “seek confirmation of their role as citizens with rights, seen by many as being hijacked by others” (33), as they look to the state to resolve gender inequality.
Al-Rasheed's book provides a historical overview of the state and the context for gender relations in Saudi Arabia. She then explores how the gap between two national projects, religious nationalism and creating a modern state, is pronounced in the public discourse and ideas on girls’ formal education, which began circulating in Saudi Arabia in the late 1950s. The commentaries in the Saudi press in the 1960s to adopt girls’ education, she explains, were not meant for emancipation but for the sake of producing and raising future generations of men, and guaranteed the role of the state as benevolent educator. Perhaps the most interesting time in the relationship between the state and the ʿulamaʾ of the religious establishment is explored in chapter 3. Here the author explores the shared response to internal Islamist forces in the 1980s, when the state reaffirmed the religious scholars’ responsibility for the piety of the nation, resulting in the revival of traditional and conservative religious opinions and the creation of a strict moral order in the form of increased fatwas on women excluding them from the public sphere. “In Saudi Arabia,” Al-Rasheed writes, “women define the religious and moral character of the nation but cannot lead it” (115). This collaborative effort was challenged, however, after 9/11 when the state agenda changed.
The author uses a wide range of primary sources for her analyses including a reliance on literature, women's texts, newspapers, online documents, interviews with Saudi women writers and professionals, and conversations with bloggers, students, activists, and novelists. The range of voices throughout the book is extensive. In chapter 4, for example, she includes the voices of elite educated women, the profiles of business women, and media interviews with women in the royal family to provide an overview of how the “woman question” became a domestic concern and was emphasized in the media because of changing state policies after 9/11 when religious conservatism was blamed for the radicalization of young men and for the delayed progress of women's status in Saudi Arabia. As a result, the state restricted the influence of religious scholars on education, expanded women's higher education, allowed for more freedom to debate issues of gender in the public sphere, and loosened restrictions on the media to allow for a more comprehensive reporting of issues on Saudi society, resulting in increased visibility of Saudi women.
Al-Rasheed provides an informed analysis of literary texts while engaging with the many voices of Saudi women. The author is expressing much more than a uniform understanding of the discourse produced by women in Saudi Arabia. She thoroughly engages with the many voices of women and their critical responses to the persistent exclusion of women according to the agenda of the state and religious movements. She shares the voices of women muthaqafat (intellectuals), confrontational novelists demanding gender equality from the state, in chapter 5, and in chapter 6, of the younger generation of Muslim celebrity novelists belonging to an emerging middle class who brazenly address issues of sexuality and cosmopolitanism in their works. These include Raja al-Sani, author of Girls of Riyadh originally published in Arabic in 2004 and translated into English in 2007. The final chapter 7 explores the newly religiously educated multazimat, women who “offer Islamic solutions to everyday challenges and interpretations of current affairs,” often defending male supremacy and traditional gender roles (244). While the book focuses on urban educated women, drawing from interviews, blogs, newspaper articles, and published lectures by academics, it would have been further enriched by additional voices, particularly the voices of women in rural uneducated communities and of those who Al-Rasheed identifies as single women and divorcees on charity and welfare whose men have failed to provide for them and remain on the margins of society.
Nevertheless, this book challenges persistent stereotypes of Saudi Arabian women at every turn, moving past the Western fascination with driving laws and the abaya, by highlighting women's own voices responding to the power relations of religious leaders and the state in producing public spaces where women are central to the nation's pious image and modernization. A Most Masculine State provides readers with an important critical work that shares a nuanced understanding of Saudi women's lives over the years shaped by and responding to the project of religious nationalism. Readers interested in gender relations in Saudi Arabia or who are looking for a more comprehensive understanding of the relationship between Islam and the state in producing gender relations, will find this book to be an engaging and enlightening read.
