Although not advertised as a series, this volume is one of several biographies of 20th-century rulers of Kuwait published by Arabian Publishing. It should be noted, however, that it is far less a biography of Mubarak al-Sabah Al Sabah—sometimes known as Mubarak the Great—than it is a diplomatic history of a pivotal period in the emergence of Kuwait as a distinct political entity. The portrait sketched by B. J. Slot is that of a small shaykhdom at the mercy of complex international machinations involving the British, the Ottomans, the Germans, the Russians, the French, the Al Saʿud, and the Al Rashid. The author repeatedly ascribes Kuwait's success in steering a viable course between these powers to the astuteness and canniness of Mubarak.
Mubarak Al-Sabah is a very detailed diplomatic history and a largely European one at that. Slot, a Dutch historian and archivist who edited an earlier book on Kuwaiti history and penned a number of studies of early Dutch and other European activities in the Gulf, has scoured the available archives in the United Kingdom, France, Germany, and Turkey, as well as making use of some documents from Russian, Austrian, and Dutch archival sources. This very wide purview enables him to reconstruct incidents and events from contrasting diplomatic sources. At the same time, though, the author's approach, a largely single-minded focus on the international skirmish over Kuwait, does not provide much treatment of Kuwait's internal politics and society during the same period.
Slot is unequivocal that the story of Mubarak's reign is not coincidentally also the story of Kuwait's transformation from a claimed (if not controlled) kaza of the Ottoman Empire to a “protected” state within the Gulf residency system of the British Government of India. He demolishes the idea that Kuwait was ever really part of the Ottoman Empire and demonstrates that the Ottomans sought to claim sovereignty over Kuwait but never had any presence or influence there. At the same time, the British did not wish to acknowledge any Ottoman sovereignty but were reluctant to bring Kuwait into a British orbit despite its potential status as a terminus of the Berlin to Baghdad railway. As Slot puts it, “The irony is that it was the very measures taken by the Ottomans to prevent Kuwait falling into British hands that propelled it into becoming a de facto British protectorate. Ottoman policy had been entirely counterproductive, and in the case of the British, there is a similar irony. Britain's desire had never been to intervene in Kuwait, but in the end she had been drawn into the role of Kuwait's protecting power” (pp. 110–11). According to Slot, a major, if not the principal, factor in this switch was Mubarak's ability to play one side off against the other.
Mubarak is portrayed in a very favorable light—fully aware of the international situation, astute in how much he could accomplish, and canny in dealing with stronger powers and neighbors despite his self-characterization as “a simple Arab sitting on the edge of the desert” (p. 131). This sympathetic interpretation seems somewhat indulgent because contemporary Kuwaiti sources are nonexistent (although the author has consulted a few later traditional Kuwaiti histories). Thus, the author is unable to shed any substantive light on Mubarak's personality and thinking beyond a few surviving letters written to British or Ottoman officialdom, which frequently regarded the Kuwaiti with disdain or antagonism. Slot shies away from any conclusion regarding the controversy over Mubarak's role in the murder of his brothers that installed him as ruler. On several occasions, he chides an earlier biographer for her critical views of the shaykh (Salwa Alghanim, The Reign of Mubarak Al-Sabah: Shaikh of Kuwait, 1896–1915). His sympathetic attitude is accompanied by remarks portraying British officials in the Gulf generally as hostile when not incompetent and Ottoman officials as ineffective when not equally incompetent.
In keeping with his highly favorable opinion of his subject, Slot declares the sobriquet of Mubarak the Great justified. Yet there is no mention that many Kuwaitis today decry Mubarak as an autocrat who forever altered the partnership between the Al Sabah and other leading families and who exchanged the suzerainty over Kuwait of one foreign power for the protectorate of another. As final points, the book includes a very useful guide to archival sources, and it is a relief to be able to read a book with actual footnotes, thus obviating the tiresome need to keep fingers tucked into a variety of pages.
