Arthur P. Whitaker Prize of the Middle Atlantic Council of Latin American Studies CHOICE Outstanding Academic Title for 2005
The needs of a group of history undergraduates inspired Reid Andrews to design a research project that resulted in a book which is also capable of challenging doctoral students. It is characterised by admirably jargon-free language and logical argumentation, and addresses highly topical political processes. Andrews argues that by consistently struggling against enslavement and in favour of equality and inclusion, African captives and their descendants have made significant contributions towards democratisation in Latin America.
Afro-Latin America's six chapters cover the period between the late 1700s and the 2000s. They examine dynamics between structure and agency, focusing on those nations which ‘[…] were ruled from the 1500s through the 1800s by Spain or Portugal’ […] (p. 4). The author defines structure mostly in terms of large-scale agricultural and mining production, analysed both in terms of their demographics (consisting of a slave labour force ten times larger than that of the United States) and sociopolitical context of highly discriminatory systems of rule in both the Spanish Americas and Brazil. Together with Cuba and Puerto Rico, Brazil forms a subset of regimes whose laws of abolition were signed not during the years between 1820 and 1850, but in the late 1880s and 1890s. Hence, these countries kept importing African captives until the very end of the nineteenth century, thus supporting mono-crop export economies.
Andrews sees the pervasive search for freedom as the motor of agency. Besides marooning and staging armed rebellions, African captives and their descendants executed complex and contradictory maneuvers, such as self-manumission secured by purchasing grants of freedom from slave owners. Voluntary enlistment in the royalist armies is also highlighted as a route to freedom. This responded to the unwillingness of creole patriots to include full abolition in their political programmes for independence. Of course, black military enrollment was not due to any policy in favour of manumission, but rather to the limited benefits that the Bourbon reforms offered slaves.
In reference to Cuba and Brazil, Andrews describes the workings of cabildos and other mutual aid associations of people of African descent. During the 1820s and 1830s these gave rise to such Afro-American religions as Santería and Candomblé (within the Yoruba tradition), Abakuá (following beliefs held by the Igbo) and Palo Monte (recreating rituals practiced by the Congo and other Bantu speaking people). The cults multiplied the opportunities for underground gatherings of people of comparable origin. By sharing culture and language, members of these sects not only practiced solidarity, but also formed pressure groups capable of controlling stevedores, artisans and other port and urban labourers, helping to fuel the chain of rebellions that the book documents for the early 1800s. As a result of these strategies, by the beginning of the nineteenth century ‘[…] free black and brown populations […] outnumbered the slaves’ (p. 40).
In the opening pages, within each chapter and in the appendix, the author addresses the question of how people of African descent have been counted by government officials or by themselves. He emphasizes that the intricacies of self-adscription are not easily reducible to census categories, which are not well suited to assessing how many people recognise themselves as ‘blacks’ or mulattoes. Since their arrival from West and Central Africa, the Afro-Latin population has been subject to whitening, a form of nation building by racial assimilation that praised the emergence of mixed bio-types, whose darkness was effectively to be ‘laundered’ after each generation. This paradigm had become particularly strong by the 1890s and the early 1900s due to the adoption of European social Darwinism. It also built on the legacy of the colonial caste system, which prescribed racial mixing as panacea for social redemption. By the 1920s alternative nation-building proposals emerged. These still appealed to assimilation as the basis for nationhood, but also praised a degree of browning and blackening as vehicles for racial democracy. Africanisation of music, dance and other spiritual, aesthetic and festive expressions followed. However, successful marketing of Brazilian samba, Cuban son or Dominican merengue, and of different carnivals by global cultural industries, not only resulted in cultural cannibalisation of tradition, but has also hidden persistent patterns of social exclusion of black people. This fuelled the social and political movements that during the late 1980s and early 1990s struggled against assimilation and in favour of the forms of multiculturalism that shaped the constitutional reforms implemented during those years in Brazil and Colombia, and later in Ecuador and Venezuela. Yet Reid Andrews argues that actors addressing racial and ethnic issues have not been entirely successful in building strong constituencies. Not only they have faced competition from the patron-client relationships that have long characterised politics in many countries, but neoliberal economic policies have also undermined Afro-Latin American ancestral territories and hindered affirmative action measures.
In reference to the future, Reid Andrews notes that ‘accompanying the rise of neoliberal policy […] has been an expansion and deepening of electoral democracy’ (p. 197), which opens opportunities for new multiracial coalitions between palenques, quilombos and other autochthonous and autonomous forms which originated in resistance against slavery, and labour and other social movements. The author's hope is that these new alliances will contribute to consolidating democracy in such a way that attainment of full inclusion will make racial politics inapplicable and obsolete.
