Localizing Islam in Europe is a study of the resilience of Islam as a transnational religion. Now home to twelve million Muslims, Europe has become a hotbed of fears about Muslim exceptionalism—the belief that Muslims are an unassimilable minority. Many non-Muslim Europeans believe that Muslims are resistant to Europeanization and that Islam is the root of this resistance. As a result, European Muslims are often expected to refashion their faith on the pattern of their host cultures, producing a Euro-Islam the adherents of which refrain from asserting themselves in public or claiming communal rights. Meanwhile, more vehement skeptics reject Muslims entirely as proper members of European civilization. Many in Europe ask whether Islam can ever be compatible with Europe and its institutions of liberal democracy.
Ahmet Yükleyen's book counters this influential current in European discourse on Islam, showing the extent to which fears about “Muslim parallel societies” are skewed and misleading. Further, it demonstrates the flexibility and inner diversity of Islam by presenting a comparative ethnography of Turkish Muslim communities in Germany and the Netherlands. Rejecting both the essentialist perspective (that Islam is inherently incompatible with Europe) and approaches that see no coherent core to Islam (instead imagining countless, open-ended “Islams”), Yükleyen depicts Islam as historical and thus not essentially fixed—a religion that settles into each new context through the agency of its situated carriers. He pays due attention to ethno-national identities, noting that in Britain, France, and Germany, Islam takes on, respectively, South Asian, North African, and Turkish characteristics (p. 11).
The main question dealt with in the book is whether Muslim difference is an exceptional (essential) or ordinary (contextual, historical) phenomenon. Ahmet Yükleyen's work provides convincing evidence for the latter view, that is, that Islam has taken its own shape in Europe through the interaction between Muslim communities and their European settings. In other words, Islam is shaped by religious communities that produce, deliver, and sustain Islamic knowledge and practice, but also by state policies toward the immigrant Muslim populations in each country (p. 181).
Through a clear, empirically grounded analysis of Muslim immigrant experience in two countries of Europe, Yükleyen offers a refined perspective that rests on “contextualization.” The diversity of Islamic knowledge and practices on display in Europe today is a result of the variety of contexts in which Islam has taken root. Yükleyen meticulously isolates the dominant agents of Islamic activism among his chosen population. He identifies “Islamic communities” as the most important units and author(itie)s in the production of Islam. The book shows not only how these communities produce themselves, work together, and even compete with each other, but also how what they produce bears the distinct stamp of state policies in the countries where they reside.
Employing a relationalist framework that draws on Bourdieu's field theory, Yükleyen paints a vivid picture of the “Turkish Muslim religious field” within which Islamic practices and institutions take shape and reshape themselves (p. 42). The three major Turkish Islamic communities studied in the book (the Milli Görüş, Süleymanlı, and Gülen communities) exemplify a sort of division of religious labor, but also compete for adherents. There is an internal pluralism in Islam because “Muslims produce, represent and supply a variety of Islamic interpretations to believers and non-believers.” They are “not just passive consumers” of religious service, but active participants in its production and interpretation (p. 76). The Islamic communities Yükleyen studies function vertically as interfaces “between the state and the Muslims” as well as horizontally by engaging in competition with one another (p. 81). According to Yukleyen, the relationship between Islamic communities such as Milli Görüş, Gülen, and Süleymanlı is one of competition over the production of Islamic authority: “their priorities are to expand their institutions and number of followers” (p. 93). Islamic communities and organizations persist, according to Yükleyen, because they continue to respond to the changing needs of their constituencies. Their Islamic identity is asserted through a negotiation that is deeply situated in time and space.
Yükleyen concludes his analysis by arguing that “European Islam is emerging only slowly through the processes of negotiation, rejection, and compromise among Islamic authorities and Muslims themselves, as well as the state and its expectations” (p. 258). Yukleyen's claim that “the experience of Muslims in Europe could give us a glimpse of what an Islamic modernity would look like” (p. 259) deserves serious consideration, especially as it relates to questions of Islam and democracy. The same issues arise in the context of American Islam, and one can argue that these cases allow us to better disentangle the experience of Islam in predominantly Muslim societies.
This well-written book is a joy to read. Neither essentializing Islam nor losing sight of the faith's constant core, Localizing Islam in Europe illustrates Islam's tenacity and flexibility as it settles itself in the seemingly unyielding context of Europe. Yükleyen's work is also a timely reminder of the importance of fieldwork in historicizing a religious culture.
