When ‘atomic state’ is entered into Google, roughly 132 million matches are found in a fraction of a second. Most of them are concerned with concepts in physics and chemistry, most notably the state of atoms undergoing transitions, while a few others are about the laboratories and journals dealing with concepts internal to science. None of them are about the important questions surrounding the establishment, transformation, maintenance and extension of nuclear physics as a research field in mid-twentieth-century India, which is what Jahnavi Phalkey examines in her monograph Atomic State: Big Science in Twentieth-Century India.
Phalkey's book is organized around seven specific features within the history of nuclear physics. First, the academic roots of India's nuclear research, focusing on the role of universities, leadership and laboratory activities pertaining to the building of particle accelerators; second, the significantly altered nature and scale of nuclear-research technologies; third, the simultaneous negotiation of political–administrative and laboratory practice; fourth, the material culture of science; fifth, the patrons of nuclear research, especially the Tata trusts and endowments; sixth, the spectre of the atomic bomb; and lastly, how the intersection of the nation state and international politics eventually transformed equipment, research agendas and expertise in three Indian laboratories in Calcutta (Palit Laboratory), Bangalore (Indian Institute of Science) and Bombay (Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, or TIFR), centering on important scientists like C.V. Raman, M.N. Saha, H.J. Bhabha and S.S. Bhatnagar.
This monograph is an important contribution on two fronts. It bridges the chasm between history of science and South Asian history, addressing the lack of dialogue between the two fields which Prakash Kumar correctly reminded us of in Indigo Plantations and Science in Colonial India (2012). Second, unlike the narrative of Gyan Prakash in Another Reason (1999), which speaks about the discourse of science in India, and a manifestly different Indian modernity, Phalkey weaves a story which asks ‘what did people actually do when they said they were doing science – as against what many think they might have been up to?’ (p. 294). Atomic State diminishes the role of Indian nationalism and nationalist politics in the making of modern science and instead historicizes the material cultures of science. This, however, is an oversimplification – especially in the case of Saha, where one sees an entanglement between nationalism and science as Phalkey herself admits when she states that ‘Saha's active involvement with the [Indian National] Congress helped secure funding for the cyclotron project, seen as a part of nation-building’ (p. 162), and notes that Saha's quest for the cyclotron ‘was embedded in his project of nation-building’ (p. 184). She also mentions that Bhabha and Taylor located nuclear research as a ‘question of national importance’ (p. 137). There has been a recent historiographic trend to decentre the nation, and especially what Prasenjit Duara calls Rescuing History from the Nation (1995); this, I feel, is powerful only on a theoretical level.
One of the main arguments of the book is that by the early 1930s the physics community in India was drawn to nuclear physics by the need to ‘participate in the most “modern” branch of the subject’ (p. 28) and ‘driven by the modernist imperative of nuclear physics’ (p. 163). This is a one-dimensional account, which simplifies the multilayered nature of science in colonial India. Examples of important Indian scientists who did not get attracted to nuclear physics, yet played a key role in the development of science in India, are Jagadish Chandra Bose, Satyendranath Bose, Pramatha Nath Bose, Prafulla Chandra Mahalanobis, Sisir Kumar Mitra and Hirendra Kumar Banerjee. Incidentally, none of these scientists were Nehruvians. A fixation on the importance of the nuclear in Indian science is a troubling historiographic trend. For example, one would get the impression after reading this book that Raman (of Raman effect fame) was a nuclear physicist, which he was not. Consequently, one of the caveats of Phalkey ‘that nuclear research began as physics research’ (p. 292) has not been fleshed out very well. The author clarifies in a note (p. 39) that the ‘modernist imperative’ was a more complicated concept in India and not a mere mimicry of the West. This aspect of Indian modernity needed more discussion and added theoretical rigour, especially in the wake of the innovative work by Arjun Appadurai, Kapil Raj, Abha Sur and Michael Dodson. I fully agree with Phalkey about the importance of studying ‘big science’ in the developing nations, but I feel that its corpus should transcend the narrow confines of the nuclear and include underexplored topics like radio astronomy, condensed-matter physics, nanotechnology and bioinformatics, among others.
Furthermore, another problematic feature of her narrative, especially in the wake of the ‘subaltern’ turn in South Asian history, is the focus on elite figures and institutions like Nehru, Nehruvians and the TIFR. However, Phalkey is not alone here; earlier works on the nuclear history of India, by George Perkovich and Itty Abraham, have also emphasized the contributions of Nehru and Bhabha and one wonders if a history of science in modern South Asia can be narrated without such elite figures. Robert Anderson's recent book Nucleus and Nation (2010), however, traces the ‘nucleus’ of people who made possible the first atomic bomb in India in 1974, and is more theoretically grounded, making good use of Bruno Latour and Gregory Bateson in exploring the relationship between science and culture. This is an aspect which is missing from Phalkey's analysis. Overall, however, Atomic State shines in displaying that South Asian societies like India were not passive recipients of Western modernity, but had myriad individuals, institutions and innovative practices for co-constructing knowledge. The picture it provides is very unlike the centre–periphery linear diffusionist models of the older Eurocentric histories of science.
