The previous chapter provided an overview of the main constitutional challenges related to homelessness and laws that govern public property in Canada and the United States. It showed how constitutional law does not provide a positive right to housing, and it demonstrated how existing interpretations of constitutional rights fail to protect unhoused persons against different threats of governmental interference.
This chapter explores how legal theorists have examined the relationship between homelessness, property, and two forms of liberty: negative liberty as noninterference, and positive liberty as self-actualization.Footnote 1 These conceptions of liberty (or freedom) deepen our understanding of homelessness.
The present chapter shows why positive and negative conceptions of liberty provide an incomplete understanding of the relationship between homelessness, liberty, and property. Subsequent parts of the book show why we gain a more complete understanding of this relationship when also consider how unhoused persons lack a third form of liberty: republican liberty as nondomination.Footnote 2 The term “domination” implies that individuals are vulnerable to the threat of unilateral interference by others.Footnote 3 Together, this chapter and the following ones illustrate how unhoused persons lack political equality because their positive, negative, and republican freedom are all limited in ways that do not affect people with access to housing.Footnote 4
3.1 Private Property and Positive Freedom
3.1.1 An Overview of Positive Freedom
Isaiah Berlin famously distinguished between two conceptions of liberty: positive and negative. Positive freedom implies liberty as a form of self-mastery, self-actualization, or self-government.Footnote 5 The positive conception of liberty seeks to answer basic questions such as “who governs me?” and “by whom am I ruled?”Footnote 6 It is closely related to values such as autonomy and self-government.Footnote 7 Berlin argued that the positive conception of freedom distinguishes between one’s higher and lower selves.Footnote 8 The higher self is self-actualized, rational, self-controlling, and concerned with one’s long-term interests.Footnote 9 The lower self is the opposite: irrational, impulsive, and driven by impulses and short-term interests.Footnote 10 Berlin contended that positive liberty is central to certain religious and philosophical traditions, such as Ascetism, Quietism, Stoicism, and Buddhism.Footnote 11
Positive liberty acknowledges that structural factors can influence the availability of opportunities that promote self-actualization.Footnote 12 For instance, poverty and lack of access to resources can hinder individuals’ liberty to achieve certain goals, pursue certain plans, or make certain decisions.Footnote 13 Matthew Kramer notes that positive freedom emphasizes the availability of resources and opportunities, and individuals’ actual use of such resources and opportunities to achieve their own authentic ends.Footnote 14 In his view, positive liberty emphasizes the accomplishment of objectives rather than whether others physically hinder an individual’s actions or plans.Footnote 15 In contrast to the negative theory of liberty – which construes freedom as noninterference – positive liberty is less concerned with coercion and concrete obstructions that restrict with one’s movement or actions.Footnote 16
Berlin was preoccupied by how the positive conception of liberty was incorporated within political theory and ideology.Footnote 17 He argued that authoritarian and totalitarian regimes emphasized positive liberty to justify tyranny.Footnote 18 In his view, these regimes employed coercion under the guise of necessity for individual and collective self-actualization.Footnote 19 He objected that totalitarian regimes portrayed coercion as a form of liberation rather than a hinderance to freedom.Footnote 20 Despite these concerns, Berlin also recognized that positive freedom is an essential component of liberty and that it is a “valid universal goal.”Footnote 21
Scholars argue that the positive conception of liberty is valuable for various reasons. First, in contrast to negative liberty theory, the positive conception of freedom more heavily emphasizes how access to opportunities and resources are necessary for self-actualization.Footnote 22 Impecunious persons may lack the financial resources to travel, access education, or enjoy a basic standard of living – all of which endow greater positive liberty to pursue their authentic interests and shape the course of their lives.Footnote 23 This explains why positive liberty is associated with the welfare State, resource redistribution, and structural forces within society that influence individuals’ opportunities.Footnote 24
Second, the positive conception of liberty elucidates the comparative or relative social dimension of freedom.Footnote 25 All individuals may enjoy the same negative rights, meaning rights that protect against State interference. Yet positive liberty underscores how impecunious persons enjoy less positive freedom compared to affluent ones, even if the former experience no concrete interference.Footnote 26 Positive liberty thus acknowledges how individuals may enjoy different degrees of freedom based on the resources and opportunities that are available to them.
Third, positive freedom is concerned with the authenticity of human agency.Footnote 27 It accords importance to the ways in which values and preferences are shaped, and the ways in which individuals maintain control over the formation of their values and preferences.Footnote 28 For instance, individuals enjoy less positive freedom when their preferences and choices are conditioned by external influence, brainwashing, or manipulation.Footnote 29 Positive liberty thus connotes that individuals act consistently with reasons and values that they themselves shaped.Footnote 30
Fourth, positive freedom is associated with the protection of basic capabilities that are necessary to live a dignified life.Footnote 31 Scholars such as Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum have advanced the Capabilities Approach, which posits that a central set of capabilities – or freedoms – must be protected so that individuals can live a meaningful life.Footnote 32 Central capabilities include, for instance, being able to live a normal-length life, enjoy bodily health and integrity, have control over one’s environment, and affiliate with others.Footnote 33 Factors such as poverty, lack of educational resources, and diminished opportunities all influence the degree to which individuals enjoy such basic capabilities and can live a meaningful life.Footnote 34 The Capabilities Approach also recognizes that the State must provide access to resources that protect the basic capabilities and allow for human flourishing.Footnote 35
The distinction between positive and negative liberty is not neat. Some posit that positive and negative freedom are inseparable from one another.Footnote 36 They suggest that the negative conception of liberty as noninterference is valuable because it secures positive freedom and individual autonomy.Footnote 37 According to this view, negative freedom is thus a precondition for positive liberty.Footnote 38 In other words, “freedom is always both freedom from something and freedom to do or become something.”Footnote 39
3.1.2 Property Rights, Positive Freedom, and Homelessness
Property promotes positive liberty in various ways. First, a private property right allows a person to secure autonomy through means other than their physical bodies.Footnote 40 Individuals use property – such as structures, objects, and things – to pursue their authentic goals and purposes.Footnote 41 The ways in which property resolves allocation problems fosters autonomy in a consistent and predictable manner. The property law regime solves issues regarding the allocation, control, and use of things.Footnote 42 A private property scheme settles competing claims about who is entitled to use or enjoy a given thing.Footnote 43 In doing so, it protects expectations, ensures predictability, and promotes stability in how individuals can use objects to self-actualize.Footnote 44 Individuals can better plan their lives and coordinate with others knowing that they can use property to further their interests.Footnote 45
Second, property protects the central capabilities, and safeguards interests that are central to self-actualization, such as liberty, privacy, well-being, and security.Footnote 46 A home characteristically safeguards these interests and can promote an individual’s sense of belonging.Footnote 47 Within the home, individuals can privately pursue certain aims free from scorn, judgment, or ridicule by others.Footnote 48 Similarly, a home’s privacy allows for intimate acts or deep discussions that may be less appropriate or candid in public.Footnote 49 Housing fosters self-authorship because an individual controls access to a place that safeguards their interests without the need to rely on others.Footnote 50
Third, certain types of property – such as a wedding ring or a home – are bound up with an individual’s personhood and are central to their past, present, and future.Footnote 51 The home is often the locus of family life, intimacy, holidays, friendships, and gatherings.Footnote 52 Children are often raised within their homes. And certain monumental life events – such as moving to a different city to pursue education or employment – are marked by one’s departure from their home. The notion that something “feels like home” exemplifies a sense of comfort, belonging, and familiarity that highlights the relationship between property and personhood.
Fourth, private property rights structure legal relationships in a manner that promotes autonomy.Footnote 53 Private property confers normative powers – such as the power to exclude others – which individuals exercise to secure their privacy, security, and liberty.Footnote 54 In this way, the right to enjoy property constitutes a form of “keystone right” that secures other rights, interests, and ultimately, individual autonomy.Footnote 55
To be clear, distinct types of private property – such as homes, condominium units, apartments, trailers, and so on – foster positive freedom to different extents. Moreover, each of these types of private property also vary in terms of their size, location, quality, and degree of governmental regulation, which affects the rightsholder’s autonomy and self-actualization. A rightsholder’s status can also shape the degree of positive freedom they enjoy. For instance, individuals who own a detached home may enjoy the greatest privacy and liberty to undertake certain activities that are associated with self-actualization. In contrast, tenants may not engage in autonomy-promoting activities – especially those that result in greater noise or movement within the dwelling – because it may lead to conflicts with neighbors, noise complaints, or eviction. Tenants also enjoy less positive freedom in contexts where landlords fail to maintain a dwelling’s quality, such that the tenant is exposed to danger, unsanitary living conditions, or excessive noise.
The fact that unhoused persons lack private property rights explains why they enjoy less positive freedom than others. Those who must live on public property lack the security and privacy that others enjoy.Footnote 56 They may suffer physical and psychological harm because they lack protection against the elements, and against threats of interference by other individuals.Footnote 57 As discussed in previous chapters, unhoused persons have a lower life expectancy compared to the general population.Footnote 58 They may be less able to plan their lives because they lack the stability and predictability that housing affords.Footnote 59 Furthermore, without access to housing, they may be unable to accumulate or store a significant amount of property that individuals normally keep within their homes.Footnote 60 They may not have access to basic sanitation infrastructure that helps them live a meaningfully dignified life, such as a bathroom or shower.Footnote 61 And without access to housing, they may lack free access to the place that typically anchors family life, belongingness, and continuity with the community.
The lack of a judicially enforceable right to housing in Canada and the United States contributes to unhoused persons’ lack of positive freedom. Courts in Canada and the United States have not yet recognized a positive constitutional right to housing, which would protect individuals against the condition of homelessness, and safeguard their most basic capabilities and interests.Footnote 62 Without the judicial acknowledgment of such a right, the State has no constitutional duty to secure one of the most fundamental resources to promote self-actualization and human flourishing: access to housing.
3.2 Private Property and Negative Freedom
3.2.1 An Overview of Negative Freedom
Isaiah Berlin’s second conception of freedom is negative liberty, which construes freedom as noninterference.Footnote 63 Individuals are negatively free to the extent that they do not experience concrete interference by others.Footnote 64 The fewer externally imposed constraints, the greater an individual’s freedom.Footnote 65 Negative liberty is fundamentally concerned with coercion, which Berlin described as “deliberate interference of other human beings within the area in which I could otherwise act.”Footnote 66 The negative theory of freedom seeks to answer basic questions such as “how far does government interfere with me?” or “how much am I governed?”Footnote 67 As Philip Pettit notes, various influential political theorists described liberty in negative terms, including Thomas Hobbes,Footnote 68 William Paley,Footnote 69 and Jeremy Bentham.Footnote 70
The negative conception of liberty posits that actual interference is necessary to restrict freedom.Footnote 71 According to this view, individuals enjoy freedom unless others concretely hinder their actions, movement, or choices.Footnote 72 Negative freedom theory underpins the ways in which constitutional law primarily protects negative rights, which safeguard individuals against concrete governmental interference.Footnote 73 Doctrines such as standing – which requires an individual’s rights to be infringed to bring a constitutional claim – and the cases and controversies requirement in the United States – which authorizes courts only to hear cases between parties and forbids judicial advisory opinions – exemplify the role of negative rights and actual interference within constitutional law.Footnote 74
Private property rights safeguard negative freedom in various ways. First, the physical structure of a home protects individuals and their property against attacks, trespasses, and intrusions by others.Footnote 75 It also shields individuals against surveillance.Footnote 76 Actual or suspected surveillance alters how an individual experiences a situation.Footnote 77 Surveillance unwillingly turns authentic participants of an unfiltered experience into guarded observers of their own actions.Footnote 78 A person may watch themselves, change their behavior, or self-censor because they are concerned with how they appear to outsiders – all of which undermine autonomy and authenticity.Footnote 79 Private property rights are valuable because they enhance authenticity by shielding individuals against surveillance. Private property rights also confer private law protections that safeguard individuals against interference by others.Footnote 80 Statutes and the common law prohibit individuals from trespassing onto others’ private property.Footnote 81 The police are empowered to remove trespassers from an individual’s property.Footnote 82 Private property rights also safeguard individuals’ land against encroachments, which also constitute a form of trespass.Footnote 83 For instance, individuals cannot lawfully place fences or billboards on another’s property without permission.Footnote 84
Second, private property rights protect individuals against governmental interference.Footnote 85 The home attracts one of the strongest expectations of privacy in search and seizure law.Footnote 86 Leaving aside exigent circumstances, officers generally require a warrant to search a person’s home.Footnote 87 They also tend to require a warrant to arrest someone within their home.Footnote 88 The State is also prohibited from using various forms of warrantless surveillance within a person’s home, such as wiretaps or surreptitious video recordings.Footnote 89 The areas surrounding a person’s home – such as their yard and the home’s perimeter – also enjoy protection against trespassing and police surveillance.Footnote 90
Third, private property rights protect negative liberty because they reallocate power away from the State and towards individuals.Footnote 91 Property rights trace a boundary between the individual and the State.Footnote 92 Private property imposes limits on the State’s authority over certain matters, activities, and conduct that take place in the private sphere – a sphere where individual liberty takes precedence over State regulation or intrusion.Footnote 93 Given the vast array of authority that the State exercises over individuals, private property shifts some of that power back to the individual and allows them to be the master of their own lives within a certain space.Footnote 94 To the extent that a person’s lawful conduct on private property defies majoritarian preferences, the sanctity of private property protects that individual’s lifestyle against majoritarian will.Footnote 95 Conversely, without private property rights, the State has greater power over the individual and the latter is subject to a greater degree of majoritarian will.Footnote 96
Fourth, private property rights help secure negative freedom because they grant a power to exclude others.Footnote 97 Individuals preserve their negative liberty by excluding others from their homes.Footnote 98 Conversely, a home maximizes freedom as noninterference because it protects individuals against others’ power of exclusion.Footnote 99 This power of exclusion protects an individual’s agenda-setting authority, meaning that they can determine who can access their private property and what they can do in that space.Footnote 100 Agenda-setting authority enables a person to control and enjoy property by simultaneously denying that same control and enjoyment to others.Footnote 101
Fifth, private property rights protect third parties’ negative freedom and other interests. These rights ensure that an individual can privately engage in conduct in a manner that does not affect others.Footnote 102 Rightsholders can engage in personal or intimate acts in the privacy of their homes without turning others into unwilling spectators.Footnote 103 In this way, an individual’s private property rights promote others’ sovereignty and autonomy.Footnote 104 Individuals who engage in private conduct within their homes respect others’ choices not to witness conduct that may be personal, inappropriate, or offensive.Footnote 105
Several caveats are necessary. For one, private property can also negatively impact an individual’s liberty, security, and autonomy.Footnote 106 The home may be a place where a person is subject to violence, abuse, and neglect – acts that are hidden from others’ view because they take place within the home.Footnote 107 Although private property rights can promote a range of fundamental interests, a home’s physical barriers can also conceal particularly egregious forms of wrongdoing.
Furthermore, an individual’s degree of negative freedom also varies according to their type of private property right. Different types of private property may be subject to varying degrees of governmental regulation and interference. For instance, police officers typically require a warrant (or judicial authorization) to enter a private home or its periphery to conduct a search.Footnote 108 Yet individuals who reside in public housing may be subject to more surveillance, inspections, and other forms of interference that restrict the degree of their liberty.Footnote 109
Lastly, the extent of a rightsholder’s reasonable expectation of privacy also varies according to their type of private property.Footnote 110 Individuals who own a detached home may enjoy greater protection against governmental surveillance compared to tenants who reside in an apartment building.Footnote 111 Police officers cannot lawfully trespass onto the perimeter of a detached home to look through its windows, or to attempt to listen to conversations that take place within the home.Footnote 112 In contrast, individuals who reside in an apartment enjoy less privacy. Police officers can freely enter common areas in an apartment building, such as entrances and hallways.Footnote 113 Like everyone else, they may be able to hear conversations or smell substances that emanate from a particular apartment without having to obtain a warrant.Footnote 114 The scope of a rightsholder’s negative freedom thus varies according to their type of private property. And as discussed in the next subsection, unhoused persons tend to enjoy the least negative freedom because they have no private property rights.
3.2.2 Property Rights, Negative Freedom, and Homelessness
Compared to people with access to housing, unhoused persons enjoy less negative freedom because they lack private property rights and the physical and legal protections that these rights secure. Without access to housing, unhoused persons do not have physical protection against violence, threats, and theft.Footnote 115 Research indicates that compared to individuals with access to housing, unhoused persons are roughly ten times more likely to be victims of assault.Footnote 116 Studies also show that people experiencing homelessness are more likely to be victims of theft compared to the general population.Footnote 117 Unhoused persons also lack various legal protections that safeguard negative liberty. Some courts decide that unhoused persons have no right to store their belongings on public property.Footnote 118 Others conclude that the police do not require a warrant to search an unhoused person’s tent because they have no right to erect one on public property.Footnote 119 Furthermore, people experiencing homelessness are more vulnerable to police surveillance because they spend much of their time in public space.Footnote 120
Jeremy Waldron argues that unhoused persons are negatively unfree because of the cumulative effects of two forces: laws that regulate public property and others’ private power of exclusion.Footnote 121 The starting point of Waldron’s argument is that “[e]verything that is done has to be done somewhere,” meaning on public property or on private property.Footnote 122 As part of the human experience, everyone must sleep, eat, urinate, defecate, sit, and so on.Footnote 123 Individuals cannot refrain from these acts without experiencing harm.Footnote 124 Most individuals alleviate their basic needs within their homes.Footnote 125 But the situation is different for unhoused persons. Since they lack private property rights, they have no default private place where they can freely alleviate their basic needs without interference.Footnote 126
The problem is that the law prohibits unhoused persons from alleviating their needs on public property and on others’ private property.Footnote 127 As discussed in the Introduction, municipal ordinances proscribe sleeping, erecting shelters, urinating, and defecating on public property.Footnote 128 However, unhoused persons require permission to do these acts on others’ private property.Footnote 129 People experiencing homelessness commit a trespass if they attempt to access others’ private property or alleviate their needs on others’ land without permission.Footnote 130 This explains why there is no public or private place where unhoused persons can freely and consistently alleviate their needs without interference; it is as if the law comprehensively prohibits them from alleviating their needs.Footnote 131 For this reason, Waldron concludes that “homelessness consists in unfreedom.”Footnote 132
Waldron’s Complementarity Thesis offers an account of why laws that govern public property are objectionable in how they apply to unhoused persons.Footnote 133 The Complementarity Thesis evaluates whether individuals do acts on public property as a complement to what they could have done on private property.Footnote 134 When all individuals have access to housing or shelter, they have a private place to alleviate their needs, and enjoy complementarity between public and private property.Footnote 135 Laws that govern public property are more legitimate in such contexts because individuals can obey them freely. In contrast, unhoused persons lack such complementarity.Footnote 136 Laws that regulate public property are objectionable in such contexts because unhoused persons lack reasonable alternatives to violating these laws. Ultimately, municipal ordinances are problematic because they presume that unhoused persons enjoy complementarity between public and private property that they in fact lack.Footnote 137
Other scholars highlight that unhoused persons lack negative freedom because of how the private property regime disparately allocates rights, duties, liabilities, and powers within society – an argument that is based on Wesley Hohfeld’s concept of jural correlatives.Footnote 138 Hohfeld famously argued that the jural correlative of a right is a duty and that the jural correlative of a power is a liability.Footnote 139 When an individual has a real private property right, others have a duty not to interfere with that right.Footnote 140 The rightsholder also has a private power to exclude others from that property, while others are liable to that power of exclusion.Footnote 141
Jeremy Waldron and Jane Baron note that the private property regime disproportionately burdens unhoused persons with duties and liabilities yet confers them none of its rights and powers.Footnote 142 Unhoused persons have a duty not to interfere with everyone else’s private property rights.Footnote 143 They are liable to civil trespass or criminal liability if they do not fulfil that duty.Footnote 144 Yet they have no correlative power to exclude others because they lack private property rights.Footnote 145 Conversely, others have no duty to respect unhoused persons’ private property rights because they have no such rights.Footnote 146 This explains why people experiencing homelessness enjoy less negative liberty than people with access to housing. To paraphrase Jeremy Waldron, unhoused persons bear all the burdens of the private property regime that constrain their negative liberty yet enjoy few of its benefits that would expand their negative freedom.Footnote 147 This unequal allocation of benefits and burdens results in rightsholders exercising their power of exclusion simultaneously and collectively against unhoused persons.Footnote 148 People experiencing homelessness are constantly at the receiving end of interference, with none of the rights or powers that can protect them against it.
3.3 Conclusion
This chapter provided an overview of two main conceptions of freedom: positive liberty as self-actualization and negative liberty as noninterference. It showed how private property rights promote both forms of freedom. It demonstrated how the extent of a rightsholder’s positive and negative freedom vary according to their type of private property right. And it explained why unhoused persons enjoy less positive and negative liberty because they lack private property rights.
The next chapter introduces a third conception of liberty: republican freedom as nondomination.Footnote 149 It argues that republican freedom offers new insight into the importance of private property rights, the nature of homelessness, and the impact of laws that govern public property. Together, this chapter and the next show how unhoused persons lack political equality because they lack freedom in all its forms: positive, negative, and republican.Footnote 150
