Mecca and Eden is a textual study of Islamic pilgrimage, relics, and purity rituals. Brannon Wheeler has two explicitly stated goals for the book. The first is to bring Islamic materials into the wider academic study of religion. He laments the dearth of engagement between Islamic textual and historical studies and religious studies (p. 2). Wheeler's second goal is “a description and analysis of the rituals and objects surrounding and associated with the sacred status of the sanctuary as delineated in Islamic exegetical and legal texts” (p. 2). He is primarily interested in “ritual[s] and relics associated with Mecca and the origins of Islam” that are, he asserts, socially constructed and not naturally sacred (p. 10). The author concludes that these rituals and relics serve to remind Muslims of the myth of the fall from utopian Eden, a myth that “can be interpreted as a narrative expression of an ideology stipulating the necessity of religion and the state” (p. 12).
Beginning with a discussion of the work of Robertson Smith regarding the ancient Semites' conceptualizations of the camel as sacred and Jonathan Z. Smith's work on the ritual of bear hunting, the introduction goes to great lengths to establish relics and rituals as social constructions. Wheeler then brings into comparative focus the Islamic data selected for this book: the treasure of the Kaʿba, purity rituals, relics of the Prophet, and the long tombs of “giant prophets.” However, the comparative emphasis with non-Islamic materials is not carried through equally in the chapters that follow; sometimes the comparisons seem rather arbitrary (such as the comparison of the cultural construction of religious relics to that of American “curiosity shops,” which warrants one of only two photographs in the book).
Chapter 1 focuses on narratives of and references to the recovery of the “treasure of the Kaʿbah” by Muhammad's grandfather as an example of a “more general myth of the origins of Islamic civilization” (p. 15). Wheeler argues that the specific content of the treasury suggests that it may have been votive offerings made by pre-Islamic kings establishing sanctuaries. A detailed discussion of the symbolic significance of swords found in the treasury, specifically the named swords of Muhammad, concludes that swords are “linked with the primary offices of civilization and its governance” (p. 43). Thus the treasury is associated with both the founding of the sanctuary by Adam after his fall from Eden and the “role of prophets and kings in the development of civilization” (p. 47).
Just as the recovered treasury reminds Muslims of the fall from Eden and the subsequent establishment of civilization, so too, Wheeler argues, do certain purity rituals remind Muslims “of this distinction between civilized life on earth and the utopian existence of Eden” (p. 47). Chapter 2 begins with a focus on finely argued legal definitions and injunctions about purity/impurity as they relate to sex and touching genitalia. Wheeler then brings other rituals, such as the fast, pilgrimage, and offering, into the framework of the fall from Eden. Each ritual, he argues, reminds Muslims of this fall and temporarily allows the ritual practitioner to experience a taste, breath, or fragrance of Eden. Because ritual purity is impossible to maintain in the human condition, however, the experience of Eden cannot be maintained, hence the need for “religion and its upkeep by jurists” (p. 70).
In Chapter 3, the reminder of humanity's fallen state is relics of the Prophet and those of “pre-Islamic prophets and kings, as they relate to the conception of the sanctuary at Mecca and the origins of civilization” (p. 71). The distributive spread of the relics of the Prophet and his textual remains, hadith, extended the geographic boundaries of Islamic civilization as well as religio-political authority of Islamic rulers, who protected Islam and oversaw its spread. “Official collection and preservation of these relics allowed local states to assert their legitimacy as patrons of the religious law necessary for the development of civilization in a postfall world” (p. 99).
Finally, Chapter 4 identifies “long tombs” of giant early Muslim prophets and saints (South and Southeast Asian warrior saints in particular) as a site of state patronage that constructs continuity of authority between the prophets and the state. Wheeler asserts that these forms of prophetic relics “are understood as physical reminders of the fall from Eden and the progress of civilization toward the prophet Muhammad and Islam” (p. 100). Islamic traditions report that Adam was reduced in physical stature when he was thrown out of Eden, although his tomb is longer than those of subsequent prophets, which are longer than those of the saints.
Wheeler presents us with a single overarching explanatory model into which he fits his chosen data: Islamic ritual and relics-practices are reminders of the human fall from Eden, and the mythologies of these practices express “an ideology that makes necessary the existence of the state as the means to administer religion to humanity in its fallen condition” (p. 123). He presents encyclopedic textual support of his argument in Islamic legal and hadith traditions. We know where to go to find mention of the treasures, prophetic relics, long tombs, and so forth—almost half of the book (111 pages) consists of detailed endnotes. However, a reader may be left questioning what are possible alternative interpretations for and experiences of the particularly chosen rituals and relics and/or textual references to them. Existing ethnographic and historically nuanced analyses of Islamic pilgrimage, for example, or veneration of relics would also surely find more variation, texture, historical shifts, and alternatives to this singular analytic model.
One of Wheeler's goals is to bring Islamic materials into the study of religion. The thesis and some of the comparative data will be interesting to scholars of religion outside of Islamic studies. Yet, a book that consists half of endnotes suggests a specialized readership of Islamicists, for whom Mecca and Eden is an encyclopedic resource for further study of any of the selected themes and motifs.
