San Francisco's Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915 commemorated the opening of the Panama Canal. The exposition also served a local function by highlighting San Francisco's reconstruction following the devastating earthquake and fire of 1906 and promoting California's continued economic development by linking the state to the nation's overseas empire. Like other world's fairs held in the United States during the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era, the Panama-Pacific Exposition celebrated the conquest of the North American continent and cast the creation of an American empire overseas as the logical extension of Manifest Destiny. Scholars, most notably Robert Rydell, have explored the ways in which a world's fairs justified American expansionism and valorized technological progress.Footnote 1 More recently, however, scholars have extended this analysis to illuminate the bonds linking gender and world's fairs, paralleling similar efforts to broaden studies of empire to include gender and culture.Footnote 2 Sarah Moore, a professor of art history at the University of Arizona, Tucson, contributes to both of these fields through her use of art history and cultural studies to examine the Panama-Pacific International Exposition.
Moore contends that the Panama-Pacific Exposition symbolically embraced progress, celebrated masculinity, and drew upon Social Darwinism to justify expansionism. This Social Darwinian discourse placed Euro-American men at the apex of human civilization and depicted the construction of the Panama Canal as a manly enterprise. Moore analyzes the ways in which promotional materials—including pamphlets, advertisements, and postcards—helped to advance these objectives. More importantly, however, she utilizes her background in art history to examine the exposition's statuary, its architecture, and even its spatial orientation. The spatial analysis of the exposition is particularly insightful as Moore notes the repeated employment of east-to-west orientations as a manifestation of progress. For example, Calder's Fountain of Energy, located at the main entrance to the exposition, included an equestrian statuary group. According to Moore, the east-to-west alignment of the grouping “suggests the sun's course and the evolution of mankind to the pinnacle of civilization” (105). Moore draws similar conclusions about the Court of the Universe, located at the center of the fairgrounds. The Court of the Universe included two massive arches dedicated to the rising and setting sun. The Arch of the Rising Sun included a sculptural grouping entitled Nations of the East, hinting at the past contributions of Asian civilizations. The Arch of the Setting Sun, however, included a sculptural grouping entitled Nations of the West celebrating the conquest of the Americas and suggesting the present and future of the United States as an imperial power.
Moore's analysis of a massive replica display of the Panama Canal is also noteworthy. The model of the Panama Canal ultimately covered five acres, requiring fifteen months and $250,000 to construct. Visitors entered the amphitheater surrounding the display to obtain a bird's-eye view of the painstakingly re-created Canal Zone, the surrounding territory, and the canal itself. The model included miniature trains and ships traveling at the same relative speed as their life-sized counterparts in Panama. Moore argues the highly elaborate model condensed time and space and served a pedagogical purpose by allowing viewers to gaze upon “the national will of the manly United States to enact the progress of civilization” (185).
Though Moore highlights the importance of Social Darwinian discourses, she neglects the efforts of eugenicists at the Panama-Pacific Exposition to improve human breeding and restrict the propagation of those labeled as intellectually, morally, or physically deficient. Alexandra Stern's Eugenic Nation includes a discussion of the Panama-Pacific Exposition and highlights the ways in which organizers equated efforts to promote race betterment with hygiene and the conquest of tropical diseases.Footnote 3 Moore similarly excludes many scholarly examinations of the racial discourses joined to studies of disease and hygiene during the early years of the twentieth century.Footnote 4 While highlighting public health campaigns carried out in Cuba, the Philippines, and Panama, San Francisco's exposition also included an award-winning race betterment booth providing fairgoers with information about eugenic organizations, warnings about race degeneration, and access to medical instruments used to assess biological fitness. Stern's analysis indicates that proponents of eugenic laws appropriated the exposition's idealized statues of Greek and Roman gods as examples of humanity's potential if the public supported efforts to regulate human breeding. These exhibits would provide intriguing material for an art historian's analysis. Moore does acknowledge that current scholarship identifies world's fairs as contested spaces featuring multiple narratives. As such, it would be fruitful to assess the influence of Californians who feared the completion of the Panama Canal would facilitate the arrival of undesirable newcomers, particularly Southern Europeans.
Moore enhances her arguments with Empire on Display’s numerous illustrations, diagrams, and photographs, enabling readers to examine these symbolic representations of expansionism and masculinity. Future scholarship might explore the parallels between the promotional materials created to advertise the exposition and the images the Southern Pacific Railroad and citrus producers used to cast California as a salubrious, edenic paradise. Citrus crate labels, for example, included images of nonwhite populations as a colonial workforce, presenting an idealized vision of California's Spanish past, and frequently depicting youthful women. Such a comparison might elicit broader conclusions about the ways in which Californians drew upon conceptions of empire and gender to understand their liminal position between the continental United States and its Pacific empire.
