In Care Work and Class, Merike Blofield offers a powerful corrective to the persistent invisibility of domestic workers—one the most important sectors for female employment in Latin America—in existing labor and Latin American studies. In this empirically-rich study of how and why formally democratic states have recently passed important legislation to protect the labor rights of domestic workers, Blofield also makes a passionate normative case for ending legal discrimination against domestic workers throughout the region. Blofield's research is particularly timely, charting as it does the paths to reform and enforcement of new laws in four countries (Bolivia, Costa Rica, Uruguay and Chile) and the 2011 International Labor Organization convention on domestic service. Further, Blofield's approach allows her to address the politics of economic inequality throughout the region, arguing that “how the state mediates this power relation [between employers and domestic workers]—in terms of both laws and enforcement—is an indicator of how the state balances the interests of the rich versus the poor in a democracy (4).” In addition to compiling comparative data on domestic workers' status in constitutional, labor, and judicial codes, Blofield works with congressional debates and interviews to show the economic and cultural reasons for legislative and employer resistance to allowing state intervention in domestic service relations. In light of the legislative resistance and indifference that doomed many earlier reform attempts, Blofield shows how successful legislative projects depend on reformists' ability to push the laws to a plenary congressional vote, where politicians are loathe to declare their opposition publicly. If it did nothing else—and it does much more—Care Work and Class would be important for the way it demonstrates how public opinion on matters of persistent, structural inequality can make a difference, by shifting the political calculus of elected officials and thereby propelling new legislation that generates real improvements in domestic workers' working conditions, salaries, maternity and hour limits.
In an effort to balance the specific circumstances of her selected cases with a regional view of domestic service reform, Blofield structures Care Work and Class around two approaches to the topic: exploring efforts to reform and enforce equal rights legislation in broad regional terms, and documenting the path to reform in four national cases. In the book's opening chapters, Blofield mines a wealth of regional statistics to describe the working conditions, legislative battles, and enforcement challenges related to domestic service in the twentieth century. Here Blofield draws widely on existing historical and sociological studies to sketch how ethnic and gender inequalities have been articulated in domestic service relations, stressing the near impossibility of effective redress of domestic workers' grievances prior to the recent wave of reform. While her narrative examination of disparate efforts in multiple countries renders the story somewhat opaque, Blofield's tables on domestic workers' employment, salaries, and work hours, as well as those charting relevant legislation and reform efforts, are an absolutely indispensible tool for researchers wishing to place their own work in regional or comparative context. Moreover, this approach exposes the concentration of successful reform efforts in the last fifteen years, providing compelling evidence for Blofield's central argument linking equality reform with the political circumstances of post-authoritarian rule in Latin America.
Care Work and Class is at its best in two chapters describing the disparate paths to legislative reform taken by domestic worker advocates in four countries, which supply excellent evidence for Blofield's conclusion that “domestic workers' organizations, a network of social and political allies, and political ‘windows of opportunity’ ” (40) are necessary to achieve positive outcomes. Blofield's detailed reconstruction of these trajectories through congressional records and original interviews reveals the highly personal and repetitive nature of arguments against reform: opponents frequently cite their concern to protecting domestic workers' real interests (access to employment) and stress the importance of maintaining informal, paternalistic arrangements they consider unique to domestic service. Particularly striking here is the frequency with which reform opponents, as well as advocates, recur to personal experience (usually, but not always, as employers of domestic workers) to support their views. According to Blofield, personal experience is a more powerful indicator of a legislator's position on reform than is ideology or (often nonexistent) party position, though left politicians usually offer greater rhetorical support than do their conservative counterparts. Blofield's comparative approach in these two chapters allows her to weigh the importance of issue framing to successful outcomes: for example, full reform in Bolivia and Costa Rica was achieved, at least in part, because of advocates' successful framing of domestic workers' rights within broader indigenous and human rights discourse. In post-authoritarian Uruguay and Chile, by contrast, the emergence of strong legislative and executive allies fueled successful, top-down legislative strategies. In every case, domestic workers' advocates took advantage of strategic opportunities, either in parliamentary procedure or broader legislative reforms, to advance bills on domestic service that had previously been tabled or languished in committee. In these chapters, Blofield shows why and how politics matter for the success of this agenda, including the national and historical particulars that shaped successful outcomes in each case.
This is an especially timely work, given the flurry of legislative and judicial actions that have characterized many Latin American countries since the early 1990s, and particularly in light of the 2011 ILO convention on domestic service, which is presently under consideration in national legislatures throughout the region. In her brief discussion of the new ILO convention, Blofield describes the range of gender equity reforms addressed by international and national bodies in the same time period, without directly considering the local effects of international gender politics on the creation of local political opportunities. Care Work and Class is also timely with respect to the global field of domestic service studies, which after some decades of near-neglect is experiencing a kind of renaissance in studies concerning global migration, social inequality, and discrimination against domestic service workers worldwide. Blofield's contribution offers a welcome focus on Latin American states and politics, one that like recent scholarship on indigenous, reproductive, and human rights gives us greater insight into the interaction of global and local actors in shaping specific national outcomes.
Care Work and Class illuminates both the barriers to the effective recognition of domestic workers' labor rights and the circumstances necessary to transform the definitions of labor and citizenship that have for so long maintained their exclusion. For domestic workers and their advocates, Blofield's work also serves as a manual for success. Its lessons: build a strong grassroots movement with effective leadership; identify congressional allies willing to push reform legislation to plenary session; frame lobbying efforts in terms of local and historic inequalities; and, where possible, secure executive and party support for reform measures. Care Work and Class is therefore not only a welcome contribution to the field of global domestic service studies, but also a testament to the importance and persistence of equality reform efforts in Latin America.
