In 1984, Joseph Mkhululi, a Rastafarian and an academic at the University of Dar es Salaam, wrote to the president of Tanzania, Julius Nyerere. Mkhululi requested the ‘right for the Afrikans born in the West to return to Afrika as residents’. The following year, his wish was granted and the Tanzanian government permitted wajamaika weusi (black Jamaicans) to resettle in the country. The transnational life stories of Mkhululi and several of his fellow Rastafarians who travelled to Tanzania serve as the driving dynamic of Monique Bedasse's book, which makes an important contribution to the intellectual history of postcolonial Africa and the diaspora.
Bedasse establishes the case for taking seriously the intellectual content of Rastafarianism. She argues that historians’ focus on Rastafarian symbolism and culture has obscured the movement's radical critique of colonialism, racism, and capitalism. Rastafarianism, Bedasse stirringly concludes, ‘has been subjected to the same hegemonic structures that have frozen Martin Luther King Jr. in his “I Have a Dream” speech, extracted only “one love” from Bob Marley and converted Nelson Mandela the freedom fighter into Mandela, the loveable voice of reconciliation’ (188). Moving away from such stereotyped renderings of Rastafarianism, Bedasse situates the movement within the rich, polyphonic debate about pan-Africanism in the era of decolonisation.
At the core of Rastafarian beliefs was the idea of the ‘trod’ back to Africa: an intellectual, spiritual, and physical journey. As Bedasse writes, Rastafarians were therefore ‘at the center of not only how pan-African collaboration was imagined but how it translated into a lived reality’ (107). Until 1974, Rastafarians had looked to Ethiopia and its revered emperor, Haile Selassie, as their escape from the ‘Babylon’ of Jamaica. But the Ethiopian Revolution prompted many Rastafarians to look instead for a new ‘Zion’ in socialist Tanzania. By the 1970s, Tanzania had firmly developed a reputation as a Mecca of radical pan-Africanism. Nyerere's regime conceived the struggle for decolonisation beyond ‘flag independence’, both in terms of its ambitious African socialist development plans and in its commitment to the liberation of those parts of the continent still under white minority rule. Rastafarianism shared much with Nyerere's idea of ujamaa, in that they both looked at a romanticised, pre-colonial African past as the inspiration for their own future. ‘In essence’, Bedasse observes, ‘both ujamaa and the Rastafarian movement initiated a call to memory’ (64).
Yet the ‘lived reality’ of repatriation was replete with tensions. The Rastafarians rejected the idea of the Jamaican nation-state; some even attempted to travel to Africa without passports. But, upon arrival in Tanzania, obtaining resident visas became essential not only to prolong their stay in the country, but also to establish their credentials as repatriated Africans at a time when hopes of genuine pan-continental political unity had almost evaporated. The repatriates furthermore found it difficult to achieve acceptance into local communities and, when trying to build bridges with local Rastafarian converts, became gripped in debates about ‘authenticity’. Sensitively introducing the marginalised voices of female Rastafarians into this history, Bedasse also acknowledges that the movement's patriarchal structures, themselves girded by oversimplified understandings of African society, led to rifts among family members once they had settled in Tanzania.
The book is strongest when it delves beyond the public statements of leaders like Nyerere into the Rastafarians’ personal archives and oral histories which Bedasse so skilfully explores. Here, we are offered tantalising glimpses of the reception of Rastafarian repatriates in Tanzania. The book deals well with the perspectives of both Jamaican and Tanzanian governing elites, and the ‘grassroots’ Rastafarians themselves, but we hear less about the responses of those Tanzanians who encountered the repatriates in their home villages or cities. Another dynamic that invites further attention is the temporal disjuncture between the heyday of ujamaa socialism in the 1960s and early 1970s, and the period of economic collapse and structural adjustment that followed, which is when the Rastafarians travelled to Tanzania. Bedasse is certainly alert to the shifting fortunes of socialism, but more could be said about the Rastafarians’ engagement with the circumstances of the 1980s, especially given their own critique of capitalism.
This is a stimulating, engaging, and accessible book. Bedasse is conscious that she is bridging the fields of diaspora and continental African history, and so writes with a heterogeneous audience in mind. The present reviewer specialises in East African history, and so found helpful the explanations of Rastafarianism threaded into the argument; doubtless someone working from the opposite perspective will appreciate the grounding offered here in Tanzanian socialism. But the optic provided by the liminal yet instructive position occupied by the Rastafarians means that Jah Kingdom will be of interest to any historian working through the complex intersection of the transnational and national. Just as the Rastafarians’ experience of the ‘trod’ to Tanzania challenged their pan-African imaginaries, so too does their history disrupt our own assumptions about relations between the continent and the diaspora.
