The relationship of citizens to each other, the extent to which government should provide a social safety net, and the political organization of society—all of which come under the rubric of the social contract—are pressing topics in the 21st century. Debates among national policymakers include whether government should guarantee health insurance, if corporations can enter the political fray as legitimate actors, and who should be eligible for citizenship, to name just a few.
Constance Flanagan adds context to these important discussions with her significant Teenage Citizens: The Political Theories of the Young. This wide-ranging book is situated in theoretical frameworks from both developmental psychology and political science, thus reuniting the disciplinary origins of the field of political socialization. Indeed, one of the many strengths of the book is that although Flanagan herself is a developmental psychologist, she is so well versed in the theory and research in political science that she is able to make significant contributions to both disciplines.
Teenage Citizens reports on a series of original studies, collected over a dozen years, which ask new questions about teens’ orientations to public life. In these surveys of youth, Flanagan has replaced the usual emphasis on “state sanctioned rights and obligations (such as voting)” with an examination of “the developmental processes whereby concepts of self, of others, and of the ties that bind them in a political community evolve” (p. 2). Flanagan’s framework—with her explicit focus on how individuals develop citizenship orientations, their political identity, and their own notions of the role of government in society—is what makes this book such a compelling contribution to the field of political socialization. This is not about how politically engaged youth are, or what their partisan leanings appear to be, or even what they think about government and the political process. It examines the process of becoming a citizen and the influences and factors that affect the ways in which teenagers construct an understanding of what it means to be a member of a polity. Flanagan argues that teenagers construct their understanding of the social contract in their everyday interactions with each other and with their parents, in their schools and community organizations, as well as through their engagement in the broader culture—arenas she terms “mini-polities.”
To illustrate her argument, Flanagan relies on four different studies of youth. Some are cross-national; others are longitudinal. Some include responses of linked parents; others focus on comparing early, middle, and late adolescents. Her samples are always diverse, but not always representative. One study, for example, was 21% African-American, 13% Arab-American, 6% Asian American, 5% Native American, 3% Latino, and 52% Caucasian, which is why she is not able to provide us with sharp numbers of how many young people today hold particular beliefs. For those who monitor changes in public opinion, this may be a minor complaint. Others may be frustrated by the lack of information about when key surveys were fielded. One wonders if questions about attitudes toward immigrants, for example, were asked before or after the 2006 protests.
But this is largely a book of assets, not weaknesses. One of the strengths is the use of innovative measures to capture key concepts. Flanagan asks questions that have not been asked often, if ever. She makes extensive use of open-ended responses, and employs thoughtful, nuanced vignettes to allow respondents to consider a range of values when evaluating state powers and government benefits. For example, one study asks all respondents, regardless of their race or ethnicity to “tell us some times when you feel like an American.” It is fascinating to read how some European American youth, whose families have been in the United States for generations, cited disagreements with their parents as a time when they felt like an American. This suggests that there is something in practicing freedom of expression, and perhaps even in generational protest, that is a defining feature of American identity. There are countless such provocative questions and answers throughout the book.
To address the breadth of issues under the umbrella of the social contract, Flanagan covers a wide range of topics—American identity and definitions of democracy, inequality, trust, community service, attitudes toward government regulations, and issues of public health. Each chapter is chock full of original research, with implications for researchers and public officials alike. One of the most compelling chapters is based on cross-national surveys of youth from “opportunity” societies (the United States and Australia) and “security societies” (Sweden, the Czech Republic, Bulgaria and Hungary), which were completed during the 1990s as the former Eastern bloc nations were transitioning to new economic and political systems. Flanagan illustrates how interpretations of the social contract, and “the degree to which government, the market, or individuals are responsible for managing peoples’ risks, well-being, and security” (p. 11) vary in predictable ways depending on the cultural conditions of one’s socialization. Youth in the United States and Australia were more likely to support meritocratic values and to worry about the moral hazards associated with government provision of entitlements. Swedish youth, as well as those from former communist nations, were more likely to believe that government had a responsibility to provide a safety net in the form of unemployment compensation or housing. Even more interesting, however, is that Flanagan also discovers that within these different societies, teens’ opinions varied, depending on how much one’s family might have relied on the social contract. So, for example, within the former communists nations, youth whose parents had higher levels of education were less likely than youth from less well-educated families to support government safety nets.
She also explores how one’s orientation to the safety net and meritocracy is related to “routine practices” through questions about chores and allowance. Across all countries, most children had to do chores and most children were given some amount of “pocket money”—although the two items were not necessarily linked. All respondents generally thought young people should do chores, but when asked why, teens’ answers varied by economic system. “Youth from nations with a strong social welfare contract” thought they should do chores so that they could learn responsibility as members of a family, while youth from the United States and Australia thought that doing chores was good because it taught “self-discipline and individual responsibility” (p. 45).
It is a testimony to the depth and breadth of this book that one cannot begin to capture the complexity of topics within it in a short review. Flanagan situates her findings in work from the growing, cross-disciplinary field of youth political engagement. There are detailed reports about teens’ personal experiences with racial and ethnic discrimination, and the types of parenting practices and discussions that occur around issues of race and ethnicity. There is an examination of whether (and why not) youth of all backgrounds believe the terms of the social contract apply equally to everyone, and a chapter that discusses how individuals come to an understanding of “democracy.” There is a fascinating discussion about why the rational choice framework used in adolescent development studies of health risk may be short sighted, since evidence suggests that teens respond to arguments about the “public consequences” of individual decisions. Indeed, there is much here that will inform studies for years to come.
One cannot read Teenage Citizens, however, and not be reminded of the early socialization studies and the emphasis on the primacy of parental influences. In study after study, Flanagan finds evidence of the significance of family discussions, parental values, and the “multiplicative advantages to growing up in a well-educated family” (p. 91). Other mini-polities—schools, community organizations, extra-curricular activities—have an impact as well, but the direct and indirect influence of family is prominent throughout. And it is this nod to the original studies that reflects why Flanagan’s work will be a mainstay of socialization scholars for decades to come: She has reunited a focus on developmental processes with the most important political questions about us as members of a community and the rights and responsibilities that come with these shared attachments to each other. For practitioners who work with young people, for scholars who study their attitudes and behaviors, and for those of us who are lucky enough to engage with them in the classroom, there are few questions that are more relevant.
