Historical debates about the origin and nature of Irish nationhood have always been inextricably bound up with the impact of colonialism. Thus it is probably not surprising that the study of Irish intellectual history normally (with the exception of the United Irish Rebellion of 1798) emphasizes its development in relative isolation from general modes of European Enlightenment thought in a harsh environment scarred by centuries of colonization and suffocated by sectarian and ethnic hatreds. Michael Brown's immense recent study casts Irish intellectual history in a refreshing and more nuanced light as a distinct part, albeit a deeply troubled part, of the modern Enlightenment.
While Ireland was never a central locus of the European Enlightenment, Brown argues persuasively that enlightenment modes of thinking are central to understanding the complex intellectual milieu and variety of problems that confronted Ireland in the eighteenth century. In particular, Brown identifies three epistemological and methodological approaches—empiricism, rationalism, and “free thinking”—that operated in multifarious ways in three distinct phases: the religious, social, and political phases of the Irish Enlightenment.
In part 1, Brown examines the Religious Enlightenment, which spanned the period following the Williamite Wars (1688–1691) until the 1730s. Brown sets the Irish experience of early modernity in a specific context dominated by confessional control over the instruments of the state. As a result, the first impact of Enlightenment thought related to the question of “how to allow a variety of faith communities to worship freely” (11). Each of the three main religious groups in Ireland adopted a particular stance with respect to the questions surrounding toleration that emerged from Dutch theological debates in the late seventeenth century. The Presbyterians adopted a rationalist methodology, the Anglicans an empirical approach, while Catholics retained premodern Scholasticism and general hostility to the Enlightenment. Brown judges that all three religious communities had some adherents who experimented with “speculative free thought,” but this thought was not dominant in any of them. Each community, moreover, adopted a particular approach to the acute problem of developing intellectual means for living with ontological differences based on their own unique predicament. Presbyterians sought ways to petition for toleration from the Anglican state, whereas Anglicans developed an empirical argument for the vitality of the church-state settlement in Ireland. For their part, Catholics faced the existential dilemma of how to restore the intellectual legitimacy of the church in the wake of devastating Jacobite military defeat.
In part 2 Brown turns to the Social Enlightenment that characterized the period from the 1730s to the 1760s. This social phase was grounded in the English experience of enlightenment in which various figures mid-century reached across confessional divides seeking to embed practices and norms that allowed for fruitful collaboration. In contrast to the theological debates of the earlier phase, in this period the focus was on developing a nonconfessional broad discourse of civility within a flourishing civil society encouraging discursive practices of politeness and improvement in an extensive network of coffeehouses and clubs throughout the country. The defining intellectual posture of this period was, in Brown's view, a creative blend of rationalist and empiricist modes of thought.
In the third phase, Political Enlightenment, which Brown considers in the third section of the book, the center of gravity shifts from developing a discourse of civility and nonconfessional sociability to the seminal questions of citizenship and statehood that emerged from the revolutionary milieu in France. This period in Ireland extended from the 1760s to the establishment of the Volunteer movement and the Grattan parliament in the 1780s, and it culminated in the outbreak of revolutionary and intercommunal violence in the 1798 United Irish Rebellion. While the Irish Political Enlightenment sought to apply the practices of social collaboration to the organization of the state through a rationalist methodology grounded on natural rights and universal laws, it was plagued by the persistent lack of trust among the faith communities in Ireland and the direct challenge Enlightenment thought posed to the political domination of the state by the Anglican Establishment. According to Brown, the decline into violence in 1798 was the culmination of a long process “germinated in the soil of the Irish Enlightenment” (14).
Perhaps the most compelling feature of Brown's argument is his concluding reflections upon the question whether the Irish Enlightenment was a success or a failure. Brown's assessment is complicated. On the one hand, the victory in 1798 of the more conservative empirical wing of the Irish Enlightenment over the natural-rights-based universalist principles of the rationalist wing seemed to have destroyed the radical vision of a modern, secular Irish state implicit in the ideals of the French Revolution. Clearly the intercommunal conflict in 1798 signified how Enlightenment philosophy failed “to inoculate Irish religious identities of their fratricidal qualities” (461). However, Brown also concludes that the failure of the eighteenth-century modernizing nation-building project actually laid the foundation for the nineteenth- and twentieth-century nationalist revival based upon Romantic ideals of authenticity, belonging, and autonomy that culminated in the modern Irish Republic. Thus, the eighteenth-century Enlightenment succeeded in the sense of resetting the terms of religious conflict away from ontological dispute and towards issues of social discord and group accommodation; that is to say, early modern confessionalism became late modern sectarianism, and “the question ‘Who is Enlightened?’ gave way to the more toxic query ‘Who is Irish?’” (14).
This is a serious, learned, and provocative study that contributes enormously not only to Irish historical studies, but also to the ever growing body of scholarship relating to the intellectual history of the Enlightenment understood more generally. Perhaps Brown's most rewarding insight is that eighteenth-century Ireland, long regarded as a reactionary backwater of the European intellectual scene, was not a nation mired in premodern modes of thought, but in some respects was a forerunner of what in later centuries would be the profoundly modern struggle about the changing nature of the state and the emergence of new concepts of national identity. If anything Brown could have perhaps been more explicit about the unique vantage eighteenth-century Ireland offers as we try to understand how Enlightenment thought was assimilated into arguably Europe's earliest colony and a nation practically defined by the relation of indigenous peoples and a diverse settler population. In this sense, the portrait of an intellectually vibrant colonial Ireland that Brown offers is an early illustration of one of the central political phenomena of the twentieth century.
This connects to one criticism regarding Brown's methodology in this study. Brown acknowledges that he quotes “extensively from the sources” (10). Indeed, textualism is one of the real virtues of this book. Brown presents lengthy passages with penetrating analysis not only of original works by well-known eighteenth-century Irish authors such as John Toland, George Berkeley, and Edmund Burke, but also those of lesser-known figures such as Charles O'Connor and Peter Burrowes who rarely receive much attention today except from specialists in Irish history. However, the wealth of Irish original sources contrasts noticeably with the dearth of serious examination of European Enlightenment thinkers and texts. Brown seems to presume the reader's familiarity with the kind of panoramic intellectual history of Holland and France that we identify with Jonathan Israel, for instance. But the reader is sometimes left wishing that Brown had provided some textual basis for his general claims about the Enlightenment frame of mind. In this way, it might be easier to trace Enlightenment ideas about toleration, sociability, and civil religion from their Continental source to their eventual repercussions for the eighteenth-century Irish political imagination. But without a doubt this is an important work that will have an impact well beyond Irish historical studies.
