Unlike the hundreds of canonized histories of twentieth-century physics in the style of Abraham Pais's classic Inward Bound (1988), all focusing on the route from atomic to nuclear physics and to elementary particle physics with its standard model, this book tells a non-standard history from the unusual vantage point of solid state physics. The main title, Solid State Insurrection, signals the author's goal of restituting a fair share and an adequate role to solid state physics and allied fields such as materials science. All of the latter were for a long time denounced as ‘dirty physics’ (Schmutzphysik or Schmierölphysik) by the powerful protagonists of ‘fundamental physics’ such as Wolfgang Pauli in the 1930s, or Murray Gell-Mann or Wolfgang Panofsky in the 1960s. In fact, Henry A. Rowland's programmatic ‘plea for pure science’ in 1899 canonized the self-image of American physicists for decades (pp. 19 ff.), even though this ideal soon no longer fitted the actual practice of blossoming industrial research at Bell Labs and elsewhere. Based on earlier studies by Spencer Weart on the emerging ‘solid community’, Martin documents that the strong growth of physics as a profession in the US was to a large extent based on the growth of materials research. However, for a long time the members of this growing subcommunity of researchers into the properties of materials were anxious about the identity and status of their new field. It was christened ‘solid state physics’ after 1940 (see Chapters 3–5), and later redubbed ‘condensed matter physics’ (see Chapter 8) in an effort to broaden the field to include fluids and to underscore its proper methodicity.
The author of the book under review, Joseph D. Martin, is vice chair of the Forum on the History of Physics of the American Physical Society (APS), editor of the journal Physics in Perspective, and currently teaching associate in the Department of History and Philosophy of Science at the University of Cambridge. His close links to the APS and his intense and deep analysis of programmatic talks, papers, letters and minutes of committee meetings make this book a fascinating read. Complementarily to the usual content-oriented texts on the history of physics, Martin offers a sophisticated analysis of discourses, rhetorics and strategic moves by solid state physicists as long-time underdogs in a kind of battle of supremacy over the APS and new APS committees such as the Division of Solid State Physics (founded in 1947 – see pp. 54 ff.), journals such as the Physical Review or Physics Today (see Chapter 4 on the ‘publication problem’), positions (there is no good overview of how many professorships in solid state physics existed when and where), and monetary resources. Martin describes how – de facto – solid state physicists dominated the actual practice of American physics from at least 1950 and how hard it was for them to obtain adequate functions and representation not only in the governing bodies of the APS, but also in the National Academy of Sciences (p. 143), which – between 1957 and 1967 – admitted only six solid state physicists compared to twenty-seven nuclear and particle physicists. Chapter 7 unfolds the various responses to the reductionist world view, be it Alvin Weinberg's calling for fair criteria of scientific choice, emphasizing utility and interconnections with other fields, or Philip W. Anderson's ecumenical statement that ‘more is different’ (pp. 142 ff.). The refusal of the US Congress to finance the SSC Super Collider in 1993 marked the symbolic end of the supremacy of elementary particle physics as the allegedly most fundamental field within physics (see Chapter 9 on ‘mobilizing against megascience’).
Three weaknesses: I was first disappointed with Martin's unwillingness to look beyond the horizon of American physics at least occasionally, and by his strict avoidance of any peek at other countries or regions. His discussion of pertinent journals, for instance, would have gained from an inclusion of newly founded international journals such as Physica Status Solidi (founded in 1961). My study on the trajectory of materials research to materials science in Germany (‘Von der Werkstoffforschung zur materials science’, NTM (2011) 19, pp. 5–40) would have warned Martin to parallelize the evolution of materials science, allegedly ‘following in solid state's footsteps’ (p. 121): in Germany the two are roughly fifty years apart; their development is altogether less similar than Martin thinks, and the reasons for their formation definitely include non-local, non-contingent and conceptual factors (all in direct contrast to Martin's diagnosis on p. 121).
Second, his study only weakly captures the interplay of the well-described moves of strategic positioning with the cognitive development of the field which has developed quite fast since the 1960s. A few of the prominent textbooks, such as Charles Kittel's Introduction to Solid State Physics (1955) or Frederick Seitz's Modern Theory of Solids (1940), are mentioned briefly but not analysed in terms of coverage, internal coherence or the, presence or absence of paradigms forming the basis of a disciplinary matrix. Here, too, a structural comparison with Bernadette Bensaude-Vincent's or my analysis of textbooks in materials science would have helped. Nor are the cognitive differences of older ‘solid state physics’ and later ‘condensed matter physics’ clearly spelled out – all of these changes are interpreted as mostly strategic or rhetorical moves (cf. e.g. pp. 61, 152 ff.). So certain parts of Martin's book acquire a strange externalist flavor.
Third, the issue whether there ever was one community of solid state physicists or whether it was rather a loose aggregate of specialist areas of research is not discussed properly (pp. 6, 40, 55 rather sound like the latter); sociological criteria of social cohesion or of discipline formation are not used, so that the community (or communities?) remain rather vague; and technologists are not thematized throughout. That might be fitting on the physicists’ programmatic level, but not at all in actual research practice, especially of materials science and engineering (MSE). This is another dimension intensely discussed in the secondary literature but beyond the horizon of this study, exclusively devoted to physicists.
Notwithstanding these three blind spots of missing disciplinary and international comparisons, weak coverage of cognitive developments within solid state physics, and a rather loose usage of the concept of scientific communities, I can recommend this book to anyone interested in the history of the scientific studies of materials; the development, rivalry and coexistence of subdisciplines; or issues of science policy in the Cold War era.
