According to the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare, Japan's births per 1,000 population (crude birth rate) dropped from 36.2 in 1920 to 8.5 in 2010 (17).Footnote 1 Aiko Takeuchi-Demirci's Contraceptive Diplomacy explores the transnational feminist activism, international scientific and philanthropic networks, and cultural diplomacy behind this remarkable change. The birth control movement was associated with such diverse ideas as socialism, feminism, neo-Malthusianism, anti-imperialism, eugenics, racism, and pacifism. Margaret Sanger's birth control idea, initially transplanted in pre-World War II Japan, blossomed in the postwar years. Since their first meeting in New York in 1920, Sanger and her Japanese colleague, Ishimoto (later Katō) Shizue, collaborated over several decades, during which their countries were replete with tensions over Japanese immigration and imperial expansion, which culminated in the Pacific War.
Chapter One describes how the transnational (male) socialist network put two feminists, Sanger and Ishimoto, in contact, which led to Sanger's 1922 visit to Japan. It sparked the birth control movement there. Chapter Two looks at the interwar international peace movement led by bourgeois Christian women across the Pacific. Sanger and Ishimoto appropriated their language of maternalist pacifism. Chapter Three examines American demographic interpretations of Japan's rise to imperial power. Japan's overpopulation was blamed as the cause of aggressive imperial expansion and unwelcome immigration. American eugenicists interpreted this as an example of fertile colored races’ challenge to white civilization. A new field of population studies involving reform eugenicists emerged in the 1930s. Its goal was to solve the tensions through controlling fertility. Sanger shrewdly repositioned her birth control movement in order to make it valuable in the eyes of male eugenicists and moved away from radical feminism.
After the United States defeated Japan, the latter suffered from a devastated economy and a food shortage, which was exacerbated by repatriation and the baby boom. Suddenly, limiting population growth became the national priority, a sharp turn from pre-1945 pronatalism. Chapter Four discusses population control during the Allied Occupation of Japan (1945–52). Officially, General Douglas MacArthur took a stance of “neutrality” on policies involving reproduction, which was a sensitive matter in the aftermath of the Nazi Holocaust. However, Takeuchi-Demirci's research reveals that in fact American Occupation officials tacitly facilitated discussion on Japan's national birth control programs among American and Japanese population studies experts, medical professionals, and health officials. Chapter Five turns its attention to the 1948 Eugenics Protection Law. It was revised to allow abortion based on economic necessity in 1949. Japanese official endorsement of abortion was meant to be temporary during its postwar economic despair, but average Japanese women embraced reproductive options, including abortion and birth control, and resisted efforts to rescind the economic clause for abortion, which resulted in the fall of the crude birth rate from 34.3 in 1947 to 7.8 in 2016 (214).
Chapter Six begins with Sanger's announcement of oral contraceptive development during the 1955 International Conference on Planned Parenthood in Tokyo. She envisioned that the Pill could be a Cold War tool to alleviate socioeconomic problems in overcrowded Third World societies and turn them into U.S. satellite states. They also tested progesterone on Puerto Rican and (rural) Japanese women, though Japanese health officials soon abandoned this preapproved Pill experiment having seen side effects. The book illustrates that Japan's striking fertility decline was not necessarily a natural process. Rather, it was accelerated by postwar geopolitics, and international reproductive politics involving diplomats, officials, NGOs, and wealthy reform-minded philanthropists. Sanger's birth control vision survived by finding different allies through the interwar years, Pacific War, Occupation Period, and Cold War.
This book is empirical and analytical. Chapters Four and Six are most original and illuminating. Takeuchi-Demirci examined not only Occupation records and Sanger's files but also primary sources documenting the population control work by the Rockefeller Foundation and medically trained millionaire Clarence J. Gamble. Her research uncovers that the ostensive Occupation policy of neutrality and Gamble's preference to remain anonymous kept American contraceptive diplomacy from becoming public knowledge. Sanger and Ishimoto were instrumental in the beginning of Japan's birth control movement. Yet, subsequently, they were often sidelined. The book uses the rather limited presence of the central actors to illustrate sexism. The author also points out that deciding who became human subjects to test the preapproved Pill, for example, reflected racism and classism. Furthermore, the book shows change and continuity nicely. Volatile U.S.-Japanese relations, dramatic policy change from pronatalism to birth control resulting in a remarkable birth rate decline in Japan, and Sanger's shifting political allegiances can be contrasted with the trans-war continuity of eugenic ideas and the birth/population control movement.
Further discussion is desirable to assess the feminist legacy of Sanger and Ishimoto. Takeuchi-Demirci attributes Japan's postwar fertility drop to average Japanese women's “power and decisions (153).” Yet, she also mentions that these women “suffered from the dearth of accurate information and safe and reliable methods of contraception” (153) and Japanese feminists were frustrated with the speedy 1999 approval of Viagra, the male impotence pill, as the female pill had not been approved for decades (215). Were women empowered or disempowered in the success story of Japan's birth control adoption? For instance, did rural Japanese women who endured progesterone side effects exercise their power to influence male health officials to stop the test against the American will? Were women in labor-intensive rice agriculture less interested in birth control than miners’ wives or urban working-class women? Recent lawsuits by victims of involuntary sterilization procedures performed under the postwar Eugenics Protection Law remind us of the disempowering effects of state-sponsored population control programs on women and the availability of their voices.Footnote 2
Regardless, many readers of this journal will appreciate the fascinating account of how Sanger's progressivism spread beyond America and reshaped itself by changing geopolitics and transnational interactions in the twentieth century.
