The 1990s presented new historic opportunities for Afro-Colombian communities seeking economic, social and cultural rights. The Colombian Constitution of 1991 introduced a new set of rights which called for the recognition of blacks as well as providing provisions for them to seek titles to territories on the Pacific Coast. Law 70, or the Black Rights Law, officially recognised Afro-Colombians as an ethnic group and established a framework for territorial, cultural and citizenship rights. Such rights, which had been previously accorded only to indigenous communities, represented a significant shift in black rights legislation in Colombia and throughout Latin America. The recognition of black communities in the 1991 Constitution is based on Article 55, which reads:
The government will create a law that recognises, for black communities that have come to be occupying public land (tierras baldías) in the rural riparian zones of the rivers of the Pacific basin, in accordance with their traditional practices of production, the right to collective property over the areas that will be demarcated by the same law (p. 43).
Since 1995 Afro-Colombians have been making collective territorial claims and defending their territory based on these new rights. In Colombia, Afro claims to territory pose some vexing questions since it has been indigenous peoples who have been historically and politically constructed as the bearers of land rights. While Afro groups in Latin America have been accorded basic rights as citizens, the provisions in the new Colombian Constitution provided Afro-Colombian communities with a legal tool to make claims to lands specifically demarcated on the Pacific Coast. How was this possible, and what are the social and political implications? These questions and more are dealt with in Bettina Ng'weno's book.
Ng'weno's research focuses specifically on the claims to territory being made by two distinct Afro communities located in the south-western part of Colombia in the Cauca Valley. She is interested in the differences and similarities of the claimants as well as in the complicated connections, politics and strategies employed by these communities. It is argued that these claims represent, on the one hand, a more general and unified attempt at self-definition as communities (ethnically, ideologically and territorially) and, on the other, a political opening (as citizens and constituencies).
One of the central arguments of the book is that the relationship between third-world states and citizens is being structured around territory through efforts to reincorporate people and territory within national boundaries in the face of demographic sub- and supra-governmental structures, namely armed groups and economic structuring that questions the relevance of the state. Citizens and states are trying to recapture and reconstitute both property and authority and in the process are changing the form and function of the state.
The state is central to Ng'weno's research. It is being challenged by national and transnational currents and cross-currents, which run in many directions. This is particularly true in Colombia, as the state must deal with a vast array of social movements as well as insurgent guerrillas, paramilitaries and drug traffickers. These forces present a myriad of problems for Colombia. In her analysis of citizenship, territory and the state, Ng'weno highlights the tensions, contradictions and problems among groups and states while trying to untangle and make sense of them.
Afro communities seeking titles must engage in processes and practices that seek state legitimacy, while simultaneously challenging and questioning state authority and legitimacy through occupation, possession and control of territory to reform the basis of participation in the political field in their own interest. The question of state legitimacy and authority is particularly important for poor Afro-Colombians because it is through the state that their resources are secured.
Ng'weno's analysis underscores the tense relationship between the legal right to claim land and basic citizenship. In other words, only citizens may claim land, and it is done through processes and procedures established by the state. Ng'weno argues that it is through being identifiable as territorially based groups that Afro-Colombians of the area come to gain recognition and power. The claims made by Afro communities, then, are as much about the contemporary state and governance as they are about land, resources, citizenship and power. They are new claims to full citizenship obtained through territory and participation, claims to be recognised as legitimate subjects of the state, with the right to have a say in state practices, policies and actions. The process of obtaining collective titles is seen as one of inclusion into the nation-state rather than as one of separation. Afro-Colombians are therefore involved in three separate but overlapping processes. Firstly, they are seeking the rights and legal status to lands they have occupied for centuries; secondly, they are constructing and expanding citizenship, which had hitherto been denied to them; and thirdly, they are developing new avenues of political participation.
The construction of citizenship or lack thereof in Colombia is rooted in how blacks were first made socially invisible by various forms of hegemonic discourses, like racial democracy, which denied racial discrimination while simultaneously promoting racial inequality. The Black Rights Law, which recognised Afro-Colombians as an ethnic group, made them legally and culturally visible, and set in motion a new social calculus. In Colombia and throughout Latin America, claims to territory are rooted in struggles around ethnicity, culture and history. In order to claim lands, you must have a recognised cultural and ethnic identity. Therefore, Afro-Colombians' claims to territory mark a shift from their being de jure non-citizens to de facto citizens.
According to Ng'weno, Afro-Colombians moved from being legally invisible silenced racial groups to being legally visible ethnic groups. This shift is crucial to understanding why and how Afro-Colombians are now positioned to make these claims. It is argued that the process (or processes) of claiming territory is a form of citizenship negotiation and affirmation, as Afro communities must negotiate new political relations with other groups (indigenous peoples), companies (mining, coffee) and the state (local, regional, national and transnational). Ng'weno points out that these claims open up new spaces for politics in a variety of ways.
Along these lines, a new political and social equation emerges as Afro groups are seen and judged as legitimate political actors. Claims produce new political spaces, actors and constituents that put Afro-Colombians in new relations with other ethnic groups, local government and armed groups as territory-governing entities. Within this context, Afro groups will have to establish new organising tactics, cultivate new allies and enter new strategic political relations at the local, regional, national and transnational levels.
What is significant about Ng'weno's work, and how should it be interpreted? It opens up new ways to understand better the problematic relations among the state, citizens and territory. Ng'weno's careful attention to the role of the state as being the arbiter of rights and her questioning of its relevance and viability is crucial to her analysis of Afro-Colombian land claims. At the same time, she demonstrates how the state's new construction of Afro-Colombian ethnicity, despite some historical problems, set in motion a new stage of Afro-Colombian agitation for citizenship and political participation.
Ng'weno argues that claiming territory is only one piece of the political puzzle. The struggle of Afro-Colombians must be seen through a wider lens. Afro peoples in Colombia are claiming recognition as active, visible, salient communities. They are entering into new political, administrative and social positions at a time when territory is being used as both a claim to and a demonstration of power in negotiations over authority, legitimacy, citizenship and political participation.
By teasing out these relationships, Ng'weno reveals how citizenship is constructed as well as how new spaces are created for new forms of political participation. In a broader frame, her work has implications for other African-descendant populations in the Americas who are making similar claims to land and territories. Central to this process is the way in which racial and ethnic categories are constructed, for whom and by whom; and how groups self-construct their identities, which are then crucial to how claims to territory are read. Ng'weno's work is therefore highly recommended.
