The last two decades have witnessed an explosion of books in the “handbook” and “companion” genres, with publishers eager to bring to market often massive tomes that provide overviews of a subject or the state of play therein. In our own field, the history of economics, these range from discipline-wide efforts such as the Companion to the History of Economic Thought (2006), ably edited by Warren Samuels, Jeff Biddle, and John Davis, and Jurgen Backhaus’s Handbook of the History of Economic Thought to more narrow efforts such as, inter alia, the Cambridge Companion to Keynes (Backhouse and Bateman Reference Backhouse and Bateman2006) and the companions to Adam Smith, which appear in Cambridge, Oxford, and Elgar variants. At their best, these volumes offer essays on key topics by leading specialists that can at once inform research, teaching, and the student’s understanding of a subject. At their worst, they offer little more than a paper substitute for Wikipedia.
The challenges in editing a project of this variety are substantial. One hopes for comprehensive coverage but is quickly frustrated by the lack of availability of the “right” authors for particular subjects—a problem that is only compounded by first-mover advantages that accrued to editors of previous companions or handbooks, who have already convinced your preferred authors to write on the subject of their expertise. The matter of entries of uneven length and quality further complicates the process. Author X, realizing that the professional return to such an essay is roughly zero, provides an entry that reflects a corresponding amount of effort, while author Y insists that one simply cannot do justice to the subject in the allotted 2,000 words and so insists on an essay of twice that length. And then there is the problem of avoiding one’s own preconceptions, and even biases, in the selection of authors and/or entries and, in the process, failing to deliver an end product that reflects the full richness of the subject or of approaches to it. Adding yet another layer to the challenge are those authors who have difficulty managing deadlines—at times by years rather than simply weeks or even months. Finally, having managed to fight one’s way through all of this, with greater or lesser degrees of success, and having the final product land in one’s mailbox, one is left to deal with the howls from reviewers and others about the outrageous price that the publisher is charging for the fruits of your editorial loins.
It is against this background that we come to assess the most recent effort in the history of economics handbook genre, the Elgar Handbook on the History of Economic Analysis, edited by Gilbert Faccarello and Heinz Kurz. Published in three volumes totaling more than 1,800 pages of text, the Handbook aims to, in the words of the editors, “provide a succinct overview of the development of economics since its systematic inception up until today” (p. 1). “Succinct” is clearly in the eye of the beholder, given the massive girth of this collection. Since the Handbook includes 198 entries, we will not even attempt to offer a detailed discussion of the individual essays. Instead, we will endeavor to offer the reader a sense for why this collection is a useful resource while at the same time calling attention to what we consider its limitations.
As the title suggests, the focus is on the history of economic theories, and the editors’ approach to presenting this history is, I think, rather useful for the various audiences of and needs served by a project of this type. Volume I, “Great Economists since Petty and Boisguilbert,” focuses on individuals from the aforementioned seventeenth-century writers to contemporary figures such as Robert Lucas, Joseph Stiglitz, and Paul Krugman—totaling 125 entries in all. The second volume, “Schools of Thought in Economics,” includes thirty-two essays spanning “Antiquity” (not generally considered a school) through the recent New Keynesianism, while the forty-one essays in volume III cover “Developments in Major Fields of Economics,” including traditional staples such as development and labor, but also approaches to and tools for analysis such as behavioral economics, econometrics, and institutional economics. Volumes II and III, then, offer some connective tissue across individuals and time that is necessarily absent from essays on individuals in volume I.
What, then, should we make of all of this?
We must begin by applauding the editors for the monumental scope of this project. If the individual entries are succinct—averaging five pages for the individual essays in volume I and fifteen pages for the thematic essays in volumes II and III—the topical coverage certainly is not. The number of subjects into which one can wade here exceeds that of any other resource in the field, save for the much larger and more expensive New Palgrave. The relative brevity of the entries makes these volumes a starting point rather than an ending point, but that is part of the nature of the beast, and the ample space afforded for bibliographic references can point the reader to further explorations in the relevant primary and secondary literatures. Readers of this journal are thus not likely to find this Handbook of great use for their own research, but that is not, one expects, the intent of a collection such as this. What it does offer, however, is an excellent body of source material for lectures on virtually any subject in the field (but see below) and a useful resource for students in history of economic thought courses as they work to prepare papers on topics of particular interest to them.
A further virtue of this collection is the editors’ three-pronged approach—individuals, schools, and fields—to examining the history of economic analysis. Individually, the volumes provide stand-alone overviews of this history, viewed from the angle made the focus of that volume. Taken as a group, the three volumes allow one to see the intersection of individuals and their ideas, the development and influence of schools of thought of which many of those individuals were part, and how, over time, these individuals, schools, and approaches fed into the development of various areas of economic analysis. The three volumes do offer some overlap, as information from essays on individual economists bleeds into those on schools and fields of economic thought, but this is both inevitable and excusable, and is of little consequence, given that readers are unlikely to sit down and read straight through the three volumes.
Still another highlight of this collection is the editors’ willingness to stray from what many would consider the straight canonical path. Volume I does a particularly good job of introducing readers to a variety of Continental thinkers often neglected in the literature and given at best passing mention in standard history of economics courses, while volume II provides us with an essay on the “Italian Enlightenment” alongside those on the French and Scottish versions, as well as three essays on varieties of non-Marxian socialist schools of thought and the “Russian School of Mathematical Economics.” This attempt to widen the net extends to volume III, which includes very useful essays on fields such as “Corporatism” and “Economic Geography” alongside more traditional and extensively mined fields of analysis. Indeed, a number of these short essays are enough to make the reader wish for a volume of more extensive essays on off-the-beaten-path topics, not unlike those found in the volumes on “neglected” European economists that Warren Samuels (Reference Samuels1998, Reference Samuels2003) edited many years ago. The long and the short of things is that there is something here for almost everyone—almost.
It seems almost unfair to point to perceived shortcomings in a project such as this one, knowing the herculean effort that it took for the editors to bring it off. But we would be remiss if we suggested that all is just as it should be here. As one would hope, a good share of the essays are authored by scholars with significant expertise in their particular subject. Indeed, that is largely the case throughout the three volumes. But only largely. One of the things that stands out as one reads through these volumes is the almost total absence of entries written by historians of economics hailing from the United States. While it is typical to find non-US authors penning entries for which the pool of obvious candidates is heavily populated with non-US authors, the same cannot be said for the many entries where US authors are the obvious candidates. We will not succumb to the temptation to speculate on the reasons for this.
As respects the contents per se, those who, like this reviewer, are very interested in and teach extensively on pre-classical economics will be disappointed with the absence of volume I entries on individuals who lived and worked prior to William Petty. Those not disposed to Piero Sraffa will be annoyed that his entry was accorded more space than those on Adam Smith, John Maynard Keynes, and Paul Samuelson—and more than triple that accorded to most of the major figures in the volume—not to mention more than the absent-from-the-collection Gary Becker. While I have no doubt that Sraffa is more to the editors’ taste than is Becker, one simply cannot tell the history of economics in the twentieth century without the latter, whereas the import of the former is open to debate. Volume II, meanwhile, includes a lengthy essay on Neo-Ricardianism but none on the vastly more influential New Institutional Economics (though bits of this are dealt with in the volume III essays on “Institutional Economics” and “Theory of the Firm”). Volume III, dealing with fields of economics, includes nothing on some of the most important field-level developments in post-WWII economic analysis, including the economic analysis of law, human capital, and other extensions of economics into other realms not previously considered part of the purview of the economist. While one might counter that these are not major fields, it is rather difficult to make that case based on the JEL codes of the past several decades (Cherrier Reference Cherrier2017), and these fields have certainly played a more significant role in the history of twentieth-century economics than certain of the other fields included in volume III.
All that said, these criticisms do not take away from the remarkable effort the editors have made in bringing these volumes to publication and from the many, many useful essays that the contributors have provided to this collection. While the hefty price tag will certainly minimize its presence on the shelves of scholars in the field, this is a collection that every reader of this journal should want to have available in his or her university library for self and (particularly) for students, alongside both The New Palgrave and the Samuels et al. Companion. Each has its strengths and its limitations, and they complement each other in useful ways, allowing the reader to sample an enormous variety of topics in the history of the field and from a variety of perspectives.
