Dissertations offer original research. In the field of Chinese archaeology, a dissertation usually is the first study of an excavation site or the first secondary study of a subject, in which case it often includes material that has come out of the earth in the course of disseration research and writing. Only rarely does any dissertation lend itself to publication as a book without extensive revision. Archaeopress Archaeology in Oxford has made a bold effort to make archaeology dissertations available: Approximately 300 have been turned into books in the last ten years. Only one, Xuan Chen's work, is on Chinese archaeology.
The book consists of an introduction, three chapters, and a very brief conclusion. The focus is yamu (cliff tombs), one of two tomb types the author says in the introduction are found in Sichuan in the Eastern Han dynasty (25-220), his period of focus. The second type is a brick or stone subterranean tomb covered by a mound. The introduction then attempts to lay out the themes of Han funerary art, particularly in Sichuan during the first two centuries ce, and proposes that cliff tombs were important in Eastern Han society in Sichuan because they offer an opportunity for expression of human activities from construction itself to preparing specific burial objects to the funeral ceremony to sacrifices. It is bold agenda.
Chen selects four Western Han tombs associated with elite members of society, the early-second-century-bce pit tomb in Mawangdui, Hunan, the two-chamber tomb with an enclosing corridor that belonged to Feng Ruren in Nanyang, Henan, the unique two-story princely tomb in Beidongshan, Xuzhou, Jiangsu, dated to 129 bce, and a tomb at Dabaotai just south of Beijing of the type known as ticou as background examples. It is a small sample in a database of some 15,000 Han tombs (Western and Eastern).Footnote 1 The author cites Huang Xiaofen's very important study of Han tombs published in 2003 as a basis for the summary, and goes back to work by Robert Thorp of 1979, but not by Wang Zhongshu who began proposing typologies of Han tombs in the 1950s and wrote until his death in 2015, or any writing of Zhao Huacheng who is a strong voice currently writing about Han archaeology, nor the prolific Jean M. James, who wrote annually in the 1970s and 1980s and 1990s, for example.Footnote 2 Nor does he turn to scholarship on Chinese funerary architecture more generally for context. The author then provides a brief introduction to the social background of Sichuan in the Eastern Han dynasty, to Han history, to the debate over spending on lavish burials, and to the role of powerful families, particularly as they are known in the treatise about them, Huayang guo zhi. Discussion of “perspectives on death and the afterlife” mentions the understanding of the human soul as po and hun, but does not mention the important work that challenges this theory by Miranda Brown.Footnote 3 Returning to cliff tombs in Sichuan, the author tells us the goal is to study the tombs through wealth, private armies, and family organisation. Several times he suggests that the tombs are modelled after houses of the living, but he does not prove this, nor has anyone to date been able to prove that the similarities between residential and funerary architecture in the Han dynasty or in China were more than superficial. The entire discussion is twenty-two pages with a few illustrations interspersed, very short, it seems, for a reader who does not already have background on Han China and Chinese funerary art.
The purpose of Chapter Two is to define the characteristics of Sichuan cliff tombs and explore why this kind of tomb was so widely used there. Chinese scholars have divided Sichuan cliff tombs into six types with twenty-four subtypes. They are shown in figure 24. Scholars have also found that the more elaborate cliff tombs are in Santai, and the Fu River area more generally. Figure 25 is a chart of the different features of the tombs in four regions. Chen explores China's interest in stone, wondering if it relates to the use of stone for tombs in West Asia. He emphasizes that rock-carved architecture must be considered monumental, and he explores the relation between architectural carving and sculpture. He emphasizes an important aspect of these tombs that distinguishes them from most other rock-carved monumental architecture: they are built by non-royal families. Inscriptions, several of which he translates, confirm this fact. The chapter next turns to the extraordinary architectural detail, modelled after timber-frame structures, in the tomb, columns, bracket sets, and coffered ceilings in particular. He then mentions the almost unique representation of stoves, the central hearth idea strong evidence for this theory that these are family burials and that the hearth could have served as the centre of ritual and sacrifice.
The third chapter focuses on pictorial relief. One purpose is to contextualise the images from this region of Sichuan with those from contemporary tombs in Henan and Shandong, including relief sculpture on family offering shrines. Through images and inscriptions, he builds a yet stronger case that these are family burials because the representations are of family values. He emphasizes that the imagery is carefully considered by its patrons, never random.
The last chapter brings burial objects in the Sichuan tombs into the context of the family environment of non-royal Han patrons. Chen begins with money trees, noting that the standard theories are that they were considered a source of money for the tomb occupants and that they may have served as an axis mundi for the tomb, perhaps even a guide to heaven for the soul. Noting that the money tree is visually complex, a strong presence in the tomb, fragile, and modularly manufactured, he wonders if money trees might have been used in a funerary ritual. An image of a money tree on the base of a money tree found in a tomb in Yong'an, Santai, shown in Figure 98, may illustrate a ritual in which the tree was central. Bringing both the Queen Mother of the West and the Buddha, both represented on money trees, into the discussion, Chen is not able to identify the specific ritual associated with the money tree, but he is certain that it represents the strength and aspirations for fertility of a family's future. He contrasts the symbolism of the tree with that of a stone coffin, many of which also survive in Sichuan, arguing that the sarcophaguses in the shape of buildings, like que (gate-towers) and representations of architecture, should be viewed as a means of accession of the heavens. He wonders if the stone coffin should be considered a microcosm of the entire tomb. On this subject and the discussion of approximately ten images found on numerous Han sarcophaguses, the author does not give due credit to Wu Hung; the relevant studies are all listed in the bibliography, but only Wu's book on the Wu Family Shrines is cited, and only in the discussion of representations of filial piety. Chen's single-page conclusion to the book emphasizes that Sichuan cliff tombs are a unique structural type and that their form and imagery underscore a fundamental belief in a continuous family.
To date, the material in this dissertation has been discussed primarily in two Chinese monographs and in three articles by Susan Erickson, all cited through the study and listed in the bibliography. The publication serves it purpose of making the extraordinary architecture, highly interesting, and occasionally profound imagery of the tombs, and the possible relation of objects, relief sculpture, and paintings to family life and ceremony, available to a much wider audience than those who read dissertations. There is, however, a more carefully written and documented, expansive book on Sichuan cliff tombs that remains to be written.
