Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T09:37:09.374Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Televising Talent: Musicality, Meritocracy, and the Aesthetics of Exclusion

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 January 2024

Lindsay J. Wright*
Affiliation:
Department of Music, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Throughout the history of television, American audiences have participated in a tradition of programs that follow a consistent structure: Amateur musicians and entertainers are offered an opportunity to display their talent on stage, competing for audience votes to win first prize and a chance at stardom. This article contributes to a growing literature on the significance of televised talent shows, demonstrating how their remarkable longevity and representational power stems from their configuration as a “format,” the set of guidelines that structure and constrain the content of each broadcast—an aesthetic process grounded in exclusion. Through their formatting, I argue, these programs reify the notion of “talent” at the heart of talent shows, transforming a multidimensional and context-contingent assemblage of musical abilities into a seemingly stable object able to be recognized, rated, and ranked. Musical auditions offer a microcosm of formatting's role as a means of training audiences’ attention. They normalize the practice of eliminating whatever (or whomever) is deemed unworthy—on these programs and in the wider world. Through analyzing examples from Ted Mack and the Original Amateur Hour (1948), The Gong Show (1978), and The Voice (2017), the article demonstrates how beneath the widely discussed content of contestant demographics, judge commentary, or audience voting results, the talent show format serves to obscure the contradictions upon which meritocracy's cruel optimism rests.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the Society for American Music
Figure 0

Figure 1.Louis Eugene Walcott (1949), and Jascha Heifetz (1952).

Figure 1

Example 1.“Csárdás” by V. Monti, ed. G. Recordi & C., 1904, p. 1–2.

Figure 2

Example 2.“Csárdás” by V. Monti, ed. G. Recordi & C., 1904, p. 3.

Figure 3

Example 3.First 4 measures of The Waiters' 1978 performance of “Hello Dolly” on The Gong Show. Transcription by author.

Figure 4

Example 4.First 7 Measures of Chris Weaver's 2017 performance of “Try a Little Tenderness” on The Voice, with chair turns added. Transcription by author.

Figure 5

Figure 2.The Voice Season 17, top 11 contestants.