This book has an ambitious aim: to articulate a vision of future public health and practice, no less. At the outset the authors make it clear that they are not seeking to write an introductory text but to articulate a new way of understanding the key health challenges of public health. Nonetheless, the book has a feel of textbook and despite the authors’ protests to the contrary will be used by teachers and students for this purpose. The book provides a good overview of the field of public health and contains some useful case studies (for example, on health inequalities, sustainability, obesity and addictions). It is also clearly written, coherently structured, well-signposted throughout and accessible. The extensive use of tables, boxes and figures throughout (forty in a book of less than 200 pages) is impressive.
The book covers a range of issues and topics, including the historical development of public health, where four previous, overlapping phases are outlined: classical public health of the nineteenth century, scientific rationalism, the welfare state and effective health interventions combined with a focus on risk factors associated with lifestyle. Although it looks backwards, the book's primary focus is upon contemporary challenges and future threats to public health. While this is laudable, the adoption of such a broad sweep in such a relatively short book means that it spreads a little thinly in places. A more critical analysis of medical public health and multidisciplinary public health would have been extremely useful in this context. I also expected a more thorough investigation of lay perspectives, citizen participation and community development. My biggest criticism, however, is the relative neglect of the political dimensions of public health. Political and policy themes are not absent but should in my view have received far more attention given their importance to public health historically, today and in the future. The book does not consider in any depth the policy-making process, politics and political influence, nor does it provide a conceptual framework for analysing these crucial factors.
The authors’ strengths lie elsewhere, chiefly in their analysis of the current and future challenges facing practitioners in the field of public health and how they should respond. The authors perceive an ingenuity gap, a ‘gulf between the spectrum of problems we encounter and our capacity to devise effective solutions’. Like others before them, they highlight the wicked and intractable nature of many public health problems. However, the usual despondency one finds in the public health literature is replaced by what the authors call ‘cautious optimism’. They argue that ‘The future public health will plausibly need to be radically different from today's orthodoxy, while retaining all that is worthwhile in current practice’, and propose an integrative approach which seeks to re-integrate dimensions of life that have been separated out by modernity. Future public health should be ecological, ethical, creative and also ‘beautiful’ (in the sense that it raises spirits and fires imagination). The authors’ conceive these elements as part of a fifth wave of public health, which includes acknowledging health as a resource for living, encouraging individual self-responsibility, maintaining sustainable systems and society and a collective fostering of good interpersonal relations, high trust and cooperation, mutual awareness and acceptance, social justice and strong ethical principles. These are perhaps ideals, but they merit discussion and debate not only in practitioner communities but more widely by policy makers and society. The authors freely concede to charges of utopianism. Further work should perhaps concentrate on how these ideals can be translated into reality, for example through intersectoral policies that fully acknowledge socio-economic factors that cause ill health and reduce wellbeing, the development of a multidisciplinary health-promoting workforce across a range of agencies and institutions, and a much greater degree of public participation in health. For the truth is that despite the lip service played to public health ideals in recent years, and the attention given to problems such as obesity, alcohol misuse and smoking, this field has in reality remained a low priority both in terms of health policy and practice. In this context it remains to be seen how new institutional changes in England, namely the creation of a national public health body and the transfer of key public health functions to local government, will alter this (in the context of widening inequality, public sector retrenchment, and enduring corporate power, the answer is probably ‘not much’).
In short, this is a thought-provoking and clearly articulated book. The ideas and reflections are certainly worth pondering and I personally enjoyed reading it. I recommend it to anyone with a scholarly, policy, professional or practical interest in public health.
