Trends in ‘popular science’ came and went in nineteenth-century Britain. In 1810 it was fashionable to go to the Royal Institution. The late 1840s saw a boom in dioramas and panoramas. 1851 was, of course, the year of the Great Exhibition. The 1860s were good for ghosts, the 1870s for public aquaria. Throughout Science in the Marketplace, interesting and surprising relations between experts and audiences, producers and consumers come to light. Richard Bellon's chapter, for example, explores how the Great Exhibition, which six million people attended, failed to live up to the scientific aspirations of its backers, since it did not produce a collection of objects conducive to rational research. Its success lay instead in serving up a haphazard spectacle of entertainment which best met the demands of the public.
The informal life of science has contributed more to its success than we tend to credit. In one of the richest chapters in this compelling collection, James Secord demonstrates the ways in which conversation and friendships were at the heart of making knowledge. For example, the naturalist Sir Joseph Banks, president of the Royal Society and leader of British science for a number of decades, maintained his position through contacts and correspondence, and through his library and collections rather than through publishing. But publishing, lecturing and the like get their due here too. John van Wyhe, for example, details the extent to which phrenology was publicized through public lectures, advertisements in newspapers, dinners, and meetings with speakers, arguing that the process is best described in terms of ‘diffusion’ – a term long disdained by historians of science, who have associated it (mistakenly in Van Wyhe's view) with a passive top-down movement of ideas. Bernard Lightman – one of the coeditors, along with Aileen Fyfe – shows in his chapter that successful science lecturers in the second half of the nineteenth century were able to take advantage of an earlier institutionalization of scientific lecturing, with many travelling extensively through Britain and in the United States, earning significant amounts.
The very notion of ‘popular science’ comes in for welcome attention alongside its vagaries. Jonathan Topham considers the historical emergence and development of the category ‘popular science’, noting that the phrase originated in the early nineteenth century, at a time when both constituent words were being redefined. A new, specialized and disciplinary idea of ‘science’ was emerging, closely linked to new popular audiences, while the adjective ‘popular’ at this time was starting to be applied to particular forms of publication, ‘intended for or suited to ordinary people’, and carried a sense of a new social order. Working with materials from the same era, Ann Shteir considers depictions of the Mimosa pudica, or sensitive plant, in Erasmus Darwin's ‘Loves of the plants’ (1791), Jane Marcet's Conversations on Vegetable Physiology (1829) and other settings. She demonstrates how the move on the part of popularizing writers, in the first decades of the nineteenth century, towards the technical and away from the literary formed part of the development of a new, popular and paying readership for botany. Graeme Gooday, looking at developments later in the century, explores the arrival of the electric light, and the way that popularizers in the 1890s borrowed from Edward Bellamy's Looking Backward, and in particular its utopia of electrified homes, in order to reassure a public anxious about what electricity was and what dangers it presented with a vision of fairness and equality.
Attention is also lavished, and rightly, on the places of popular science. Victoria Carroll draws on visiting accounts in response to natural history specimens displayed at Walton Hall to tell a wider story of how different people make different objects speak. Aileen Fyfe details the ways in which museums and print found new audiences among the lower-middle and working classes as part of a wider process of working-class self-improvement. Samuel Alberti takes up the story at the end of the nineteenth century, arguing that curators' attempts to standardize and control responses were resisted by active audiences, who persisted in responding on an emotional and tactile level. And Iwan Morus discusses networks of scientific performance, showing that the authority of the performer depended on the site of the performance. For some audiences, science was experienced in magic lantern shows and conjurors' illusions; those performing at the Royal Society had different expectations to meet.
The part played by gender in the marketplace is examined in a number of the essays. Secord notes the learned couples who became central to the conversation and informal gatherings of London Regency science. Gooday observes how electricity was marketed to women, for instance in the book Electric Cooking, Heating, Cleaning (1914), packed with photographs and sketches of women using electricity – this at a time, Gooday notes, when gas and coal cooking nonetheless remained the technologies of choice. Van Wyhe points out that the phrenologist Spurzheim's wife is thought to have drawn the diagrams accompanying his lectures, which were given in the daytime because, Spurzheim thought, ‘Ladies and idle people’ preferred daytime lectures (p. 69). And Lightman records that in 1859 the entertaining natural historian Frank Buckland was lecturing to an audience of ‘working men, their wives and babies’ (p. 105). To follow up on one of Van Wyhe's points: given the excellent work that has now been done on the audiences for science in nineteenth-century Britain, notably Anne Secord's on the spread of scientific knowledge through working-class communities via local pubs, and also on families entering the marketplace, it would be useful for scholars to start thinking through the ways in which the companionate marriage – and new configurations of family life generally – may have increased the demand for scientific knowledge.
Science in the Marketplace offers an important overview of science and consumer culture in nineteenth-century Britain, with each author contributing something new to our understanding of the meaning and development of popular science. A history with a difference, it will be of wide appeal.
