Performing Disability in Medieval and Early Modern Britain by Mark C. Chambers reads across “a wealth of primary evidence for all manner of premodern performance” (31) to “reconsider the reality of performed disability as a part of medieval and early Tudor culture, including its construction, reception, and popularity” (5). The archive for this valuable study, part of the Early Social Performance series edited by Pamela King and Elisabeth Dutton, comprises the painstaking research that the Records of Early English Drama (REED; https://ereed.org) project has been conducting for more than forty years, including results not yet published, such as those for County Durham that Chambers is coediting. Identity categories familiar from modern conceptions of disability structure the book, with two chapters on fools (one in secular settings and another in monasteries) and one each on blindness, small stature, and musculoskeletal or orthopedic difference. Consideration of important literary and visual representations of disability helps to contextualize the presentation of “evidence for real disabled performers as they appear in the historic record,” and Chambers selectively engages with medical, social, cultural, critical realist, and religious models for disability to “demonstrate how that evidence might help ameliorate or qualify aspects of the theory” (9).
Chapter 1 examines evidence related to persons with intellectual disabilities, whose difference was noted but accommodated by their communities (41). They were not employed as performers/entertainers until the early modern period, and the sparse references found in the REED series occur after the Tudor period. Even then, so-called natural fools are difficult to distinguish from professional entertainers (artificial fools). Important evidence comes from records of payment not only for the fool’s livery and similar expenses but also to a guardian or keeper. Contextual discussion for this chapter covers In Praise of Folly (Erasmus), the ship of fools metaphor, Piers Plowman, The Duchess of Malfi, Witty and Witless (Heywood), and Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night and As You Like It. Chapter 2 examines the REED evidence for fools in monasteries, focusing particularly on Thomas Fatuus of the Benedictine abbey at Durham in the fourteenth century but also covering the more piecemeal evidence from other priories, primarily in the sixteenth century. The nobility frequently visited the monastic houses, bringing their entertainers with them, and there exist “numerous payments in the accounts … for various musicians, minstrels, and other performers, some attached to noble households and others independent itinerants” (79).
Blind performers, particularly players of stringed instruments such as harps, began to appear in the REED records in the mid-fourteenth century. Chapter 3 details the ample evidence of payments to such musicians, including those, well known by nicknames, attached to monasteries and to royal courts. The chapter begins with the 1425 entertainment pitting four blind men against a pig in Paris, reviewing much of the extensive scholarship about this event, and wraps up discussing some of the many post-Reformation blind musicians. Chambers also reviews the historical and cultural association of blindness and musical ability beginning with Homer and including the biwa hōshi in thirteenth‑ and fourteenth-century Japan and continuing with blues musicians.
Master Nicholas of York, “a diminutive musician … who seems to have enjoyed some celebrity status in mid fourteenth century Durham,” provides the central focus for Chapter 4. The evidence for his life and that of other entertainers of small stature reveal that, like the fashion for natural fools at court, dwarf entertainers were a postmedieval trend starting in the 1520s (129). Chambers traces the literary fictions “dwarves” back to the fourteenth century, with some limited evidence of “dwarfs” (actual individuals) being viewed and even displayed as curiosities (134–7). Payments to Master Nicholas appear repeatedly in accounts of the Durham priory from 1347–8 to 1358–9 alongside payments to other performers, uniquely (during that period) identifying him as a dwarf and a harper. He stands out for his apparent agency as a performer (136–52). The chapter also reviews the evidence, much of which is pictorial, of a postmedieval fad for “keeping” dwarfs as court servants that reached its high point in the mid-seventeenth century (142–4). Chapter 5 considers the limited evidence for performers with forms of observed musculoskeletal difference other than size. Regulation of itinerant performers increased after 1572 in England, producing more records related to licensing (and thus, more records). Orthopedically divergent performers rarely show up in the court records but can be glimpsed through records of saintly healing. The earliest of these dates from 1287, present in the REED volume because the person healed happened to be a harper (159–60). This final chapter also analyzes disability and its healing as narrative prosthesis in the Croxton Play of the Sacrament, the Mort Darthur, and as allegory in Piers Plowman (157–8).
As the Afterword reiterates, the REED evidence provides a valuable resource for uncovering the lives and social place of individuals whom we would now term disabled, some of whom clearly performed and others of whom were presented as performative spectacle by virtue of their nonnormate mental, sensory, or orthopedic features. This evidence bears further exploration by those writing histories of disability. For historians of performance, art, and literature, the evidence of actual performers provides essential context for analyzing the imaginative artistic representation of individuals who shared their perceived impairments. The extensive and valuable bibliography offers essential support for further research on the history of disability and disabled performers, as well as on medieval and early modern culture more generally.
