Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:51:54.255Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Attached eddy-like particle clustering in a turbulent boundary layer under net sedimentation conditions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 June 2021

Hangyu Zhu
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Chong Pan*
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR ChinaAircraft and Propulsion Laboratory, Ningbo Institute of Technology, Beihang University, Ningbo 315800, PR China
Guohua Wang
Affiliation:
Mechanics on Disaster and Environment in Western China Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, PR China
Yirui Liang
Affiliation:
Mechanics on Disaster and Environment in Western China Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, PR China
Xiaocang Ji
Affiliation:
Mechanics on Disaster and Environment in Western China Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, PR China
Jinjun Wang
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: panchong@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

Characteristics of particle clustering in a particle-laden turbulent boundary layer at a moderate frictional Reynolds number ($Re_\tau =5500$) are experimentally investigated based on Voronoï analysis. High-inertia sand grains with a large viscous-time-based Stokes number, i.e. $St_p=10^2 - 10^3$, are used as the dispersed phase. The bulk particle volume fraction is $\varPhi _V\sim O(10^{-5})$. Two-dimensional velocity fields of the fluid and particle phases in the streamwise–wall-normal plane are simultaneously measured via particle image/tracking velocimetry. Under the net sedimentation condition, a self-similarity of the geometries of particle clusters is clearly seen in the log layer. This can be characterized by the $-5/3$ power law of the probability density functions of the particle cluster areas and the $y$-scaling of their first- and second-order moments. Considering the self-similarity of wall-attached structures in the attached eddy hypothesis, we propose a conceptual model in which a large proportion of particle clusters prefer to reside on the back ridges of low-momentum attached $u$-structures due to the high-strain effect caused by converging sweep–ejection events. Such a scenario can be partly evidenced by the conditional streamwise spectra of the streamwise and wall-normal fluid-phase velocity components being conditioned inside cluster-occupied regions, which present a distinct $y$-scaling in the log layer. Furthermore, the fluid-phase sweep and ejection events inside particle clusters are observed to be weaker than the cases outside cluster-occupied regions, and the local rate of strain inside cluster-occupied regions is relatively higher than in all unconditional statistics. Finally, conditional statistics reveal that those sand grains with relatively small slip velocities are prone to be captured by low-momentum turbulent motions to form particle clusters.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Instantaneous snapshot of $U$-component velocity fields of the fluid phase in the $x - y$ plane in case T1. The black dashed lines denote the overlapped FOV between neighbouring CCD cameras. White dashed contours and magenta solid contours represent the detected positive and negative wall-attached $u$-structures following the detection criterion of Hwang & Sung (2018), which will be discussed in § 4.2. (b) Voronoï diagrams of the particle distribution and the detected particle clusters (patches of connected cells in red) and particle voids (patches of connected cells in blue). Four clusters are marked as C1–C4, and their position is also indicated in panel (a). The black dots represent the sand grains, without an indication of their actual size.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Wall-normal profiles of local particle volume fraction being conditioned inside particle clusters ($\varPhi _V^C$) or voids ($\varPhi _V^V$), as well as the unconditional ones ($\varPhi _V^A$), that are obtained by the Voronoï tessellation method. Here $\varPhi _B^A$ obtained by the box-counting method is also shown for comparison. The dash-dotted green lines indicate a power-law scaling of $\varPhi _{V \mid B} \propto y^{-1.2}$ in the log layer. (b) Wall-normal variation of the percentage of sand grains falling inside either clusters ($NP^C$) or voids ($NP^V$). Both cases T1 and T2 are shown, and the statistics are counted in the streamwise range of $1.7< x/\delta <2.3$. The shaded regions in panels (a) and (b) indicate the log layer of the TBL.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The p.d.f.s of (a) the dimensionless area $\gamma =A_r/\overline {A_r}$ and (b) its transformed logarithmic axis at typical flow layers in case T1. In (a), the p.d.f. of a random Poisson process (RPP) is shown as a black dashed line, whose two intersections with the $\gamma$–p.d.f. profiles yield the thresholds $\gamma _C$ and $\gamma _V$ for particle clusters and voids, respectively. The two vertical shaded regions represent the range of the scattered values of $\gamma _C$ or $\gamma _V$ reported in previous studies on HIT and TCF. In (b), the red dashed line indicates a standard Gaussian distribution. Only ensembles in the range of $1.7< x/\delta <2.3$ are counted in the statistics, and the same is true in figures 4, 5, 11, 14, 15 and 16 and thus is not explicitly stated in the captions of these figures.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Scatter plot of ($\sqrt {A_{C \mid V}}$, $P_{C \mid V}$ ) of each cluster or void at (a,d) $y/\delta =0.06$ and (b,e) $y/\delta =0.18$ in case T1. The superimposed contours in a logarithmic scaling in (a,b,d,e) represent the j.p.d.f.s, while the black dashed lines indicate the most probable $A_C^{mop}$ or $A_V^{mop}$ to be shown in figure 5. (c, f) Wall-normal variation of the exponents $E_{C1 \mid V1}$ and $E_{C2 \mid V2}$ in cases T1 and T2. The error bars in (c, f) represent the uncertainty in estimating $E_{C1 \mid V1}$ and $E_{C2 \mid V2}$ via a least-squares fitting. The horizontally shaded regions in (c) indicate the scattered ranges of $E_{C1}$ and $E_{C2}$ that have been reported in previous studies on HIT and TCF.

Figure 4

Figure 5.The p.d.f.s of (a,d) $A_r$ of Voronoï cells, (b,e) $A_C$ of particle clusters and (c, f) $A_V$ of particle voids at typical wall-normal heights, all of which are normalized by $\delta ^2$ in (a–c) and by $y\delta$ in (d–f). The bold dashed lines in (d–f) indicate a $-5/3$ power law, and the vertical dash-dotted lines in (e, f) indicate the most probable area $A_C^{mop}$ or $A_V^{mop}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Wall-normal variation of (a) the normalized mean area $\overline {A_{*}}/y\delta$ ($\overline {A_{*}}=\overline {A_{C}},\ \overline {A_{V}}$ or $\overline {A_{r}}$) and (b) their standard deviation $\sigma _{A_{*}}/y\delta$ in cases T1 and T2. Hollow or solid symbols with solid lines or dotted lines denote the statistics counted in the range of $0.3 < x/\delta < 0.9$ or $1.7< x/\delta <2.3$, respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 7.A conceptual model for the spatial correlation between particle clusters and wall-attached structures.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The pre-multiplied streamwise energy spectra of (a–c) the streamwise fluctuating velocity and (d–f) the wall-normal fluctuating velocity: (a,d) case S, (b,e) case T1 and (c, f) case T2. The coloured contours are the spectra $k_x \varPhi _{uu}/u_\tau ^2$ and $k_x \varPhi _{vv}/u_\tau ^2$ of the original velocity fields, the red solid contours are the conditional spectra $k_x \varPhi _{uu}^C/u_\tau ^2$ and $k_x \varPhi _{vv}^C/u_\tau ^2$ inside particle clusters, and the black dashed contours are the conditional spectra $k_x \varPhi _{uu}^V/u_\tau ^2$ and $k_x \varPhi _{vv}^V/u_\tau ^2$ inside particle voids. The yellow and green dash-dotted straight lines in (a–c) denote the scaling of $\lambda _x^+=3.5 y^+$ and $\lambda _x^+=0.35 y^+$, respectively. The blue dashed lines in (d–f) denote $\lambda _x^+=2 y^+$. The grey shaded region in each panel indicates the range of the log layer of the TBL.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Wall-normal variation of (a) the normalized mean area $\overline {A_u}/y\delta$ and (b) the corresponding standard deviation $\sigma _{A_u}/y\delta$ of wall-attached $u$-structures in cases S, T1 and T2. Owing to the moderate- to large-scale nature of the attached eddies, as well as the approximate streamwise homogeneity of fluid-phase motion in the log layer and above, the whole streamwise span of the FOV is used for statistics.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Strength of fluid-phase sweep and ejection events conditioned inside particle structures: (a) j.p.d.f.$(u_f^{A},v_f^{A})$ (black solid contour) and j.p.d.f.$(u_f^{C},v_f^{C})$ (red dashed contour) at $y/\delta =0.06$; (b) j.p.d.f.$(u_f^{A},v_f^{A})$ (black solid contour) and j.p.d.f.$(u_f^{V},v_f^{V})$ (blue dotted contour) at $y/\delta =0.06$; (c,e) $\mathrm {j.p.d.f.}(u_f^{C},v_f^{C}) - \mathrm {j.p.d.f.}(u_f^{A},v_f^{A})$ at $y/\delta =0.06$ and 0.18, respectively; and (d, f) $\mathrm {j.p.d.f.}(u_f^{V},v_f^{V}) - \mathrm {j.p.d.f.}(u_f^{A},v_f^{A})$ at $y/\delta =0.06$ and 0.18, respectively. The contour level in (a,b) varies from 0.02 to 0.08 with an interval of 0.02. Owing to the convergence consideration, the whole streamwise span of the FOV is used for statistics, and fluctuating velocities are presented in inner scaling.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Wall-normal variation of (a) the square of the mean length of the long and short principal axes $\overline {L_{a}}^2$ and $\overline {L_{b}}^2$ of particle clusters or particle voids and (b) the mean slenderness ratio $\overline {S_C} =\overline {L_{a}/L_{b}}$ in cases T1 and T2.

Figure 11

Figure 12.The j.p.d.f.s of the dimensionless area $A_C$ or $A_r$ and the large-scale component of the rate of strain in the flow region (a) below the log layer with $y/\delta < 0.04$ and (b) of the log layer with $0.04 \leq y/\delta < 0.2$ in case T1. The black dashed contours indicate j.p.d.f.($A_C/\overline {A_C}, \tilde {S}_z/\overline {\tilde {S}_z}$) of particle clusters and the coloured patches indicate j.p.d.f.($A_r/\overline {A_r}, \tilde {S}_z/\overline {\tilde {S}_z}$) of all the Voronoï cells. Owing to the convergence consideration, the whole streamwise span of the FOV is used for statistics.

Figure 12

Figure 13.The $y$-scaled one-dimensional pre-multiplied spectra at various flow layers in case T1: (a) $k_x\varPhi _{uu}^{A}(\lambda _x/y)$ of all the events, (b) $k_x\varPhi _{uu}^{C}(\lambda _x/y)$ inside particle clusters and (c) $k_x\varPhi _{uu}^{V}(\lambda _x/y)$ inside particle voids. The two vertical dashed lines in (b,c) represent the scaling of $\lambda _x^+=0.35 y^+$ and $\lambda _x^+=3.5 y^+$ shown in figure 8(b,c).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Wall-normal variation of the mean streamwise velocity of two phases being conditioned in either particle clusters, particle voids or for all the events in cases T1 and case T2: (a) $\bar {U}_{f}^{C}$ of the fluid phase; and (b) $\bar {U}_{p}^{C}$ of the particle phase.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Wall-normal variation of the Reynolds normal stress and shear stress of (a–c) the fluid phase and (d–f) the particle phase being conditioned in either particle clusters, particle voids or for all the events in cases T1 and case T2: (a) $(u^2_{f,rms})^{C \mid V \mid A}$; (b) $(v^2_{f,rms})^{C \mid V \mid A}$; (c) $(-\overline {uv}_f)^{C \mid V \mid A}$; (d) $(u^2_{p,rms})^{C \mid V \mid A}$; (e) $(v^2_{p,rms})^{C \mid V \mid A}$; and ( f) $(-\overline {uv}_p/)^{C \mid V \mid A}$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.(a) The p.d.f.s of particle slip velocity $U_r^{C \mid V \mid A}$ being conditioned in particle clusters, particle voids or for all the events at $y/\delta =0.06$ in case T1. (b) Wall-normal variation of the averaged particle slip velocity $\bar {U}_r^{C \mid V \mid A}$ in cases T1 and T2.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Streamwise variation of two-phase flow-field statistics. (a) Wall-normal profiles of the normalized local particle volume fraction $\varPhi _B/\varPhi _1$ at $x/\delta =0.6$, 1.2, 1.8 and 2.4. The black dashed lines indicate a power-law decay of $\varPhi _B\propto y^{-1.2}$. (b–d) Plots of $\epsilon _\chi (x)$, which measures the relative deviation of $\chi$ at $x$ with respect to that at the inlet of the FOV, at five typical flow layers of $y/\delta =0.02$, 0.04, 0.08, 0.16 and 0.32 in case T1: (b) $\chi =u_{f,rms}$ or $v_{f,rms}$ (streamwise or wall-normal velocity fluctuation intensity of fluid phase); (c) $\chi =\bar {U}_p$ (local time-averaged streamwise velocity of particle phase); and (d) $\chi =u_{p,rms}$ or $v_{p,rms}$ (streamwise or wall-normal velocity fluctuation intensity of particle phase). In (a), the $\varPhi _B/\varPhi _1$ profiles in case T2 are vertically shifted by 5 for clarity.