This book, in the words of its editors, “offers a critical and wide-ranging assessment of the air transport liberalization process during the past 40 years” (p 1). It is a collection of 17 original papers, divided into three distinct parts: country and regional reports; topical issues; and future challenges. It makes for a fascinating read, tracing the development of air transport liberalisation and its spread across the world, highlighting the benefits this has produced for consumers and the industry itself, as well as a few of the less foreseen and perhaps even less beneficial outcomes, and outlining at least some of the challenges that lie ahead. It certainly meets the editors’ objectives of being both a critical and a wide-ranging analysis.
Half of the book is devoted to the country and regional reports. As you would expect, there are chapters on US deregulation and European liberalisation, as well as coverage of similar developments in Canada, Australia and Ireland. (The chapter on Ireland is a little odd given the broader European analysis. For the past 30 years or so the regulation of air transport in Ireland has not differed in any significant way from that in the rest of the EU.) There is also coverage of selected countries where liberalisation has made progress, but still falls short of what has been achieved elsewhere. India, Latin America and the Caribbean and Africa are included, as well as a comparative study of China and India.
The second section of the book, called ‘Topical Issues’, provides studies of aviation safety, the provision of air services to small communities, the oligopolisation of markets, the domination of hub-and-spoke systems and a particularly interesting analysis of airline market instability by Ken Button, one of the book’s editors. Market instability has plagued air transport from its inception and will be a key factor in determining the industry’s future. Button draws on both “empirical evidence and theoretical arguments to highlight the nature of the problems, their scale and their underlying causes” (p 285), and presents the evidence in a way not often seen in either academic or industry analyses. Overall, as is evident from the titles of the papers in this section, the focus is mainly, though not wholly, on market imperfections; the other side, as it were, of the liberalisation story. The editors point out that on the whole these “fears and objections … have turned out to be unfounded”, although it is also true that deregulation/liberalisation has led to new, originally unanticipated challenges.
The book’s final section is probably the most disappointing, not for the quality of the papers but because it covers such a narrow range of topics. It claims to address “Future Challenges”, but has only three chapters, two of which deal with a single subject, air traffic control. The other covers aviation security. ATC and security are certainly important and present substantial challenges for the aviation industry going forward. However, it is difficult to accept that there are not also several other issues which might have justified papers in their own right. To be fair, the editors do recognise this point. They specifically mention such challenges as reducing the adverse environmental impact of aviation, developing institutions that permit the maximum exploitation of economies of scale, scope and density without the economic distortions that can accompany monopoly power, and ensuring that less developed parts of the globe are not excluded from the benefits of adequate air services. “However, such challenges will have to be left for further research and publications”, they say. It is not at all clear why at least some of them, and indeed other concerns facing the industry, could not have been addressed in this book.
As ever with a collection of studies such as this, the quality of individual papers varies somewhat. Nevertheless, each one presents thought-provoking historical and economic analyses which are well worth reading, not least because this is a particularly interesting time to review the progress made around the world to liberalise the air transport industry. There can be no doubt that such progress has been substantial and despite the arguments of a small minority of commentators, one seen by most to have brought real benefits to consumers and the industry itself. It can be difficult today to recall the extent of the fetters that were once placed on airlines, preventing them from operating as other businesses. There is still much to be done, especially in reforming the archaic ownership and control rules which continue to hamper cross-border airline mergers and consolidation, but we should not lose sight of the progress which has been made, as illustrated in this book.
The timing of the book is particularly apt because while not long ago the trend towards an ever more liberal regulatory regime for aviation seemed unstoppable, that is no longer the case. There is clear evidence that protectionism is on the move again in several industries, and aviation is no exception. Opposition to the rise of the Gulf carriers, the departure of the UK from the EU (the UK was the main architect of the EU internal aviation market and the principal bulwark against a protectionist external policy) and probably soon the market power of Chinese airlines are not only creating barriers to further liberalisation, but also risking a move back to a more protectionist environment. “Air Transport Liberalization. A Critical Assessment” is, therefore, a timely, useful and welcome contribution to the debate.
Despite this, it is not possible to ignore a shortcoming in the book. This reflects not so much the contributions of individual authors, but more the editorial approach. As ever with academic books about air transport, this one contains some annoying factual errors which more vigorous editing might have avoided. More importantly, the Introduction is too short. A longer, more detailed opening chapter might reasonably have provided an overview to help the reader, bringing together the various threads of the individual contributors and drawing out some useful general conclusions. Instead, the Introduction is very thin, less than three pages long, a mere eight paragraphs, and two of those have just a single sentence.
Nevertheless, I would certainly recommend this collection of essays to students of and practitioners in the air transport industry. It is a timely contribution to an important debate about the future of the sector which may well continue for some time. However, the reader will have to draw their own conclusions about the overall messages the book seeks to convey.
