Nearly a century after hundreds of striking copper miners and their supporters were rounded up in Arizona, forced into boxcars, shipped east, and summarily dumped in the New Mexico desert, the name Bisbee evokes the violent and tyrannical side of U.S. labor relations in the Progressive Era. In this deeply researched and elegantly written book, Katherine Benton-Cohen returns to Cochise County (which also hosted the surrender of Apache leader Geronimo, and the famed clash of the Clantons and Earps at OK Corral) to trace the swirling currents of race, nation, and gender in the decades before and after the deportation. The central question of the book is how racial lines “once undefined, then inconsistent” came to be a “bright border” between white and Mexican (17)—or, as the author puts it in other terms, how “‘American’ increasingly equaled ‘white’, and so ‘Mexican’ came to mean the opposite of both” (9). Her answer nicely places the leading questions of contemporary U.S./Mexico borderlands scholarship in the context of the most important themes of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era in ways that enrich both fields.
Borderline Americans is divided into two parts. In the first half, four chapters reveal the very different racial worlds contained in Cochise County in the decades after its incorporation into the United States after the 1853 Gadsden Purchase. Race worked differently—sometimes very differently—depending on where one lived. In the San Pedro valley, Benton-Cohen evocatively and convincingly argues, Anglos and Mexicans lived in “an integrated enclave that represented both a bridge to the past and a plausible future for southern Arizona” (21). Here the past fluidity of Northern Mexico's racial system persisted, with a broad base of land ownership, extensive intermarriage, and shared fear and loathing of Apaches ensuring that “Anglos saw Mexicans as comrades, not enemies” (42). The polyglot residents of Tombstone, for a time one of the county's principal towns, forged a similar amity and integration. Anglo Americans and European migrants were much more wary of Chinese—and even lawless native-born white Americans—than they were of Mexicans. In contrast, in the “White Man's Camp” of Bisbee, and less deliberately in its planned mining suburb Warren, ethnic Mexicans were from the start segregated and subjected to systematic occupational and wage discrimination. Even here, however, there was no one racial line, as Benton-Cohen shows through a close reading of newspapers, residential patterns, marriage records, and wage data. For example, Slavs, Finns, and Italians were often referred to in racially exclusive terms and experienced similar treatment as the ethnic Mexicans with whom many closely consorted (99).
The book's second half charts the violent simplification of most of these racial patterns into a starker and more brutal version of Bisbee's white-Mexican binary. Mexican Americans held their ground in much of the San Pedro Valley, but only in more homogenously Mexican-descent communities with less outmarriage and more strained relations with non-Mexican neighbors. In much of the rest of the rural portions of the county, an enormous influx of white homesteaders in the first decades of the twentieth century left ethnic Mexicans isolated, heavily outnumbered, and marginalized by “the white homesteading rhetoric of loyalty, patriotism, and nationalism”—a rhetoric that “strongly resembled the assumptions of mining officials and their allies” (196). Benton-Cohen shows how these local developments helped to shape the 1917 deportation and its consequences, although she gives due weight to local labor militancy, the rise of the IWW, and the tumult of the Mexican Revolution. Virtually all of the 2,000-odd deputies who rounded up strikers were Anglo Americans, whereas fully 90 percent of their victims were born outside of the United States. “Purging ‘foreigners,’” she concludes, “‘increased the distance between ‘Mexican’ and ‘American,’ and being European increasingly meant being ‘white’” (237).
The racial story at the heart of this account is unsurprising in its broad outlines, if rarely documented as richly or told as well as here.Footnote 1 The analysis of the changing racial status of eastern and southern Europeans puts this book in more direct conversation with works on whiteness set in eastern and midwestern industrial cities, although Benton-Cohen never adequately explains how these urban groups became white even as they were subjected to the same deportation and blacklisting that further racialized their Mexican comrades.
Where the author really breaks new ground is in how she links the developments in Cochise County to the larger trajectories of the Progressive Era and New Deal states. Progressives were a powerful force in early twentieth-century Arizona, in 1910 writing “one of the nation's most Progressive state constitutions,” which featured strong protections for labor and aggressive regulation of businesses (199). Homesteading boosters appealed to progressive “hopes of efficiency and independence, fears of wage dependence and ‘race suicide’” and created remarkable space for white female homesteading and extension work (183, 188). These appeals and progressive reform agencies gave significant power to white women, who in Benton's account become key actors in the creation of Arizona's white-Mexican racial binary. The deportation led to a general collapse of organized labor in both Cochise County and Arizona as a whole (236). In the early 1930s, the unchecked power of mining companies and white women reformers closely associated with them ensured that “Arizona's New Deal was created in the mining industry's image, and brought the stark racial division of the mining economy into the public sector” (240). The New Deal's labor protections did allow copper miners to form independent unions. Their Mexican American members enjoyed increasing success in challenging systematic racial discrimination in the World War II years. Still, the white-Mexican racial binary forged in this borderland in the early twentieth century, and so vividly and powerfully captured in Borderline Americans, endures.
