The Abu Dhabi that Christopher Davidson describes in this newest of his books on the United Arab Emirates (UAE) (others include The United Arab Emirates: A Study in Survival [Boulder, Colo.: Lynne Rienner, 2005] and Dubai: The Vulnerability of Success [New York: Columbia University Press, 2009]) is the epitome of what he calls a “tribal capitalist” state: tightly knit, unimaginably wealthy, and starkly secretive (p. 2). In this slim, detail-packed portrait of the UAE's richest and most powerful member, Abu Dhabi emerges as a closely managed, but global “economic superpower” (p. 1), led by the astute and extensive al-Nahyan family. With a population of only 250,000 nationals (an estimate), it commands close to 8 percent of the world's oil reserves and controls over $1 trillion in sovereign wealth funds. This, Davidson points out, means its managed assets exceed those of Kuwait, Norway, Qatar, and even China. At once remote, brand new, and deeply traditional, the island nation has embarked on Plan Abu Dhabi 2030 to help it move into an orderly future—contrasting sharply with the chaotic expansion plans adopted by its famous sibling Dubai. Emirate-wide and focused on long-term strategies, the Plan envisions diversifying into significant non-oil-related sectors by developing high-tech heavy industry, expanding oil-based industrialization, and managing the real estate and tourism industries so as to protect and insulate Abu Dhabi culture from the invasion of Western practices. From this account, it becomes clear that Abu Dhabi under the leadership of the al-Nahyans cherishes its stability and has raised allocative rentier governance to new levels to ensure traditional continuity and popular acquiescence.
Davidson's first two chapters sketch an engrossing history of this dusty nation of linked islands and warring tribes, whose development trailed its emirate neighbors until well into the 1960s. Until the takeover of the visionary Shaykh Zayed bin Sultan al-Nahyan in 1966, it had no infrastructure, no banking system, no bureaucracy, no educational system, no health system, and, despite its rapidly rising oil revenues, was plagued by poverty. Under Shaykh Zayed's tutelage, not only Abu Dhabi flowered into a modern state but the UAE did as well, which hinged together the other peninsular sheikhdoms into the federal arrangement they constitute today. In fact, Davidson provides useful insight throughout this study on exactly how the UAE and Abu Dhabi work together, how the other shaykhdoms fit into the UAE's mobilelike structure, and how money and power have tipped the balance of power increasingly toward Abu Dhabi, always the capital, but now, with 98 percent of the peninsula's oil revenues, also its banker, planner, governor, military commander, and media center.
In subsequent chapters, Davidson offers a detailed and highly descriptive picture of a corporate state, yet with little analysis and even less color. The book contains no map, either of the UAE or of Abu Dhabi, which not only would have provided a useful reference for the historical section but also would have added geographical texture to the narrative. Likewise, there is no family tree or diagram of the seven ruling tribal families, a critical oversight in a book that refers frequently to different generations of leaders and siblings with similar names and titles. Chapter 5, which sets out to delineate the levels of power among the ruling elite, and lists tribal notables and the positions they hold, reads like a modern “Deuteronomy.” As for the al-Nahyan leaders themselves, although we come to know intimately the nature of their investments and economic vision, as well as their shrewd ability to adapt a system of hybrid politics combining traditional and tribal elements to modern needs, they remain for all intents and purposes faceless, without individual character traits that not only would have distinguished them in the reader's mind but also would have imbued them with much-needed personality.
The Abu Dhabi that Davidson paints lacks depth and seems encased in an impregnable shell, chary of revealing its inner soul. This impression is reinforced in the final, if disappointingly thin, chapter entitled “Unresolved Problems,” in which Davidson points out in carefully constructed language that Abu Dhabi is able to brook little criticism, shields its human rights abuses, limits Internet access, and controls its media through outright bans on freedom of speech and publication while encouraging rampant self-censorship. Though meticulously researched, and often filling gaps with personal interviews, Abu Dhabi: Oil and Beyond mirrors the place it describes through its judicious self-censorship, which enables it to successfully walk the very fine line between solid academic writing and sufficient political correctness that will ensure the doors of the Emirate remain open for future visits and research.
What is more, although the intent of the book is to provide a broad overview, several subjects are singularly absent. The historical chapters offer a good survey of tribal disputes and competing territorial claims, but they do not link these to the history of oil in the region; the reader is offered only two paragraphs (pp. 31–32) summarizing the oil deals and income Abu Dhabi accepted between the 1930s and 1960s. Absent is an overview of when and how this hugely important industry began in the peninsula, who the personalities involved were, and what the negotiations between the different tribes and companies encompassed. Despite the existence of other books that include a history of the Emirates’ oil industry, it seems surprising that there is no section dedicated to oil here or an elaboration of the Petroleum Trucial Coast Ltd., the hybrid of international oil companies that excavated and operated in all seven tribal shaykhdoms dotted along the southeastern Arabian coast. Its role in halting the tribal strife that reigned during the initial drilling period was crucial, as without stability, the massive investments needed for extraction would have been too risky.
This oversight relates to a second one regarding the Gulf Cooperation Council, which is mentioned only six times and warrants no section of its own. Yet the Gulf Cooperation Council is another key organization for understanding how Abu Dhabi, and the Emirates more generally, relate to their immediate neighbors as well as the rest of the world. As one of the very few Arab regional organizations to survive several years of existence and not a little redefinition, it has been important to the development of a regional foreign relations—itself a subject that is little addressed. Finally, and in a completely different vein, Davidson largely ignores Abu Dhabi's women—their rights, literacy and educational levels, and role in society.
What Davidson achieves is akin to an extended annual report—useful particularly for scholars of development economics but at risk of dating rapidly. As a reference, the book is clearly valuable, but an in-depth analysis of this rising economic superpower still needs to be written.
