The study of the Amistad, the schooner on which a group of enslaved Africans in 1839 rose up off the coast of Cuba to reclaim their freedom, is enjoying something of a renaissance. In the two decades since Steven Spielberg's well known (if at times maligned) film about this revolt, the Amistad affair has tended to be understood through the lens of the American abolition movement; its history has been hitched to the actions of white politicians and antislavery campaigners. A number of scholars have recently challenged this America-centered narrative by framing the Amistad story in an Atlantic context and using it to raise important new questions about slavery, freedom, and capitalism. Michael Zeuske has been at the forefront of this trend, having published in German his Die Geschichte der Amistad: Sklavenhandel und Menschenschmuggel auf dem Atlantik im 19. Jahrhundert (2012); the English translation, under review here, appeared three years later. In that short interim, two prominent Amistad-focused studies and a documentary have appeared.Footnote 11 What does this study contribute to the conversation?
At the book's core is a series of overlapping arguments about the relationship between the Amistad and wider changes in the Atlantic system that shaped the world in which the infamous schooner operated. As scholars have clearly documented, the growth of the British campaign to suppress the transatlantic slave trade drastically transformed the organization of the traffic. Zeuske describes in detail the strategies that Cuban slave traders used to bypass legal restrictions that international treaties imposed on the commerce. The clandestine nature of nineteenth-century slaving required a degree of silence among those who participated in it. This created a ‘hidden’ system in which explicit references to slaves all but disappeared from written records, and slave vessels obscured their itineraries and intentions. Despite pressure from the British navy, the slave trade to Cuba grew and persisted through much of the nineteenth century, which calls into question what Zeuske argues is a prevailing view of nineteenth-century abolitionist triumph. Another dimension of Zeuske's argument is less rigorously developed, namely that of the intricate link between slave trade and capitalism in Cuba. The brief treatment of this complex issue tends to distract from the more illuminating focus on the Amistad itself.
Indeed, the greatest strength of this book is its author's unrivaled knowledge of previously unmined Cuban archival records, which help shine bright new light on underappreciated aspects of the Amistad story. Although it provides new information about investors in the slave trade, colonial officials, and enslaved people, the book's most unique contribution is its extensive profiling of the activities of captains and subordinate personnel onboard slaving vessels, whose activities were so central to the system's operation. Evidence suggests, for example, that Ramón Ferrer, the captain of the Amistad, was hardly a ‘small-time ship captain’, as he often represented himself. Instead, Ferrer was intimately connected to slave commerce. He provided support to Cuban slave dealers, captained several slavers, and may even have voyaged to Africa. Zeuske also offers a provocative explanation for the absence in the historical record of the Teçora, the vessel that carried the Amistad captives across the Atlantic. An exhaustive examination of harbor tax lists revealed the arrival to Havana in June 1839 of a single slave vessel, the Hugh Boyle, which matched the profile of the Teçora. Is it possible that this notorious Portuguese slaver assumed an American identity prior to its arrival in Cuba? Zeuske believes so, but while the connection is plausible, the silences that surround and distort nineteenth-century data should give us pause.
Framed as something of a micro-history meant to reveal broader patterns of the hidden Atlantic, this book frequently becomes tangled in global issues that seem poorly connected to the Amistad story. The chapters are themselves quite uneven in length and depth of treatment, and their titles often bear little resemblance to their contents. Five chapters are less than 15 pages long; one chapter, ‘Africa’, is 69 pages. Roughly half of Chapter Three, ‘The Prisoners of the Amistad’, is devoted to Ferrer, the captain. Such problems may be at least in part a natural consequence of translating a book from one language to another. But they should also force us to consider what we might lose when we load so much historical baggage onto one important revolt.
