The challenge: to obtain and maintain humanitarian access
Humanitarian accessFootnote 1 to populations in need in conflict zones has become more difficult and complex in many cases in recent years and is viewed by many humanitarian agencies as the most significant current challenge for humanitarian action to overcome in the future. Why is that so?
On the one hand, many of today's armed conflicts have become fragmented and complex, with many different groups fighting each other.Footnote 2 Complexity also arises when protracted crises overlap with conflicts and/or when a natural disaster strikes a country that already suffers from conflict. Most of today's armed conflicts are non-international, and humanitarian activities are sometimes denied because they are perceived as a threat to state sovereignty.
On the other hand, the number of humanitarian organizations has increased greatly. This means that more co-ordination and negotiation of humanitarian access is needed. In addition, the lines between military, political, and humanitarian operations have gradually been blurred. If one or more parties to a conflict, or parts of the population, start to perceive humanitarian actors as instruments of a political agenda, access to those in need can become difficult or impossible. Humanitarian workers are even at an increased risk of becoming an object of attack themselves because of these blurred lines.Footnote 3
The difficulties that these constraints present to humanitarians are frequently compounded by a lack of familiarity – on the part of states, non-state armed groups, and humanitarian relief organizations – with the legal framework. The main purpose of this article is therefore to lay out the existing international legal framework regulating humanitarian access in situations of armed conflict, even though access constraints are rarely the result of purely legal obstacles.Footnote 4
Reference sources: the Handbook and the Field Manual on Humanitarian Access in Situations of Armed Conflict
What reference sources on humanitarian access exist? The Swiss Federal Department of Foreign Affairs (FDFA), together with partners, has created two reference documents on humanitarian access in situations of armed conflict: the Handbook on the Normative Framework of Humanitarian Access in Situations of Armed Conflict and the Field Manual of Humanitarian Access in Situations of Armed Conflict.Footnote 5
The protection of civilians in armed conflict is a central component of Switzerland's foreign policy. The FDFA has therefore recently developed a strategy in this field.Footnote 6 One objective of this strategy is that humanitarian access to populations in need is guaranteed.Footnote 7 As early as August 2006, during the Stockholm Conference for Lebanon's Early Recovery, Switzerland announced its commitment to develop further the subject of humanitarian access. Later, the FDFA convened an expert meeting in Montreux from 30 June to 1 July 2008, to which governmental and military experts, academics, and humanitarian actors were invited, with the objective to identify the main constraints on access, and to think about means to overcome these difficulties at legal, political, and operational levels.Footnote 8 Among the constraints on humanitarian access identified by participants were the lack of clarity regarding the existing legal obligations on access for humanitarian actors and the need to create a practical tool on humanitarian access.
Based on the conclusions of the meeting in Montreux, a consultation group with representatives of the FDFA, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), and Conflict Dynamics International was established in order to give advice on the elaboration of a Handbook on the normative framework of humanitarian access in situations of armed conflict and a Field Manual with a structured approach and practical guidance for humanitarian practitioners. The legal analysis of humanitarian access in this article is based on material in this Handbook.
The international legal framework: why it matters
It is important to be familiar with the international legal framework (i.e. general international law, international humanitarian law, international human rights law, and international criminal law) because access is blocked in many crisis situations. The international legal framework is a tool to ensure humanitarian access,Footnote 9 and for humanitarian negotiators it is an important basis for seeking agreement on access.Footnote 10 The legal framework specifies the obligations and rights of parties to armed conflict, for states not participating in the conflict, and for humanitarian actors. It also identifies conditions under which humanitarian actors may or may not gain access to people in need of assistance. It provides an objective set of rules, to which different actors can each or jointly refer in securing and sustaining access.
The international legal framework is described below, a section at a time, in order to give answers to the following questions:
1 Who is primarily responsible for ensuring the basic needs of affected populations?
2 If populations remain in need, what can humanitarian actors do?
3 To what extent must relief actions be consented to, and what are the conditions under which relief actions must be conducted under international humanitarian law?
4 What human rights obligations exist with regard to humanitarian access?
5 What are the consequences of violations?
The article finishes by reflecting on whether the current legal framework is an adequate tool to ensure humanitarian access. Finally, the legal framework on humanitarian access is summarized in a separate box.
Who is primarily responsible for ensuring the basic needs of affected populations?
Under international law, states bear the primary responsibility for ensuring the basic needs of affected populations. This is a consequence of the principle of sovereigntyFootnote 11 and has been confirmed in international practice.Footnote 12 For example, the UN General Assembly Resolution 46/182 (1991) (Guiding Principles on Humanitarian Assistance) confirms that:
Each State has the responsibility first and foremost to take care of the victims of natural disasters and other emergencies occurring on its territory. Hence, the affected State has the primary role in the initiation, organization, coordination, and implementation of humanitarian assistance within its territory.Footnote 13
If populations remain in need, what can humanitarian actors do?
The issue of access for humanitarian actors becomes acute when the state is unwilling or unable to live up fully to its legal responsibility to ensure the basic needs of affected populations in times of armed conflict. The question then is of what humanitarian actors can do to satisfy those needs. The answer is that they can offer their services according to international humanitarian law, which contains rules on humanitarian assistance and access to civilian populations affected by armed conflicts.Footnote 14
Offers of relief action cannot be considered as foreign intervention in the receiving state's internal affairs insofar as the principles of humanity,Footnote 15 impartiality,Footnote 16 and non-discriminationFootnote 17 are respected.Footnote 18 The International Court of Justice (ICJ) noted that:
There can be no doubt that the provision of strictly humanitarian aid to persons or forces in another country, whatever their political affiliations or objectives, cannot be regarded as unlawful intervention, or as in any other way contrary to international law.Footnote 19
Humanitarian actors can therefore offer their services but do not have an obligation to do so.Footnote 20 To avoid being considered an unlawful interference in a state's internal affairs, humanitarian assistance must be provided in accordance with humanitarian principles.
To what extent must relief actions be consented to, and what are the conditions under which relief actions must be conducted under international humanitarian law?
The extent to which relief actions must be consented to and the conditions under which relief actions must be conducted will be outlined according to the three situations that international humanitarian law regulates: international armed conflict (other than occupation), non-international armed conflict, and occupation. Although military occupation is a form of international armed conflict, this part will be analysed at the end because humanitarian access is regulated quite differently in this situation.
Consent and conditions in international armed conflict (other than occupation)
In territories other than occupied territories, humanitarian operations are subject to the consent of the parties concerned according to Article 70(1) of Additional Protocol I of 1977. This precondition balances the interests of the civilian population and the interests of the receiving state.Footnote 21 The draft versions of the Additional Protocols of 1973 contained an obligation to accept relief, if the relief met certain requirements, such as impartiality and humanity.Footnote 22 However, in order to protect the sovereignty of the state accepting relief, the requirement of consent was added during the diplomatic conference of 1974–1977.Footnote 23 State representatives nonetheless clearly stated that this condition did not imply that the affected parties had absolute and unlimited freedom to refuse their agreement to relief actions.Footnote 24
To what extent is a state obliged to accept relief? As a minimum, consent cannot be refused on arbitrary grounds.Footnote 25 A refusal must be based on valid reasons.Footnote 26 Whether a decision not to accept assistance is arbitrary depends on the circumstances and should be determined on a case-by-case basis.Footnote 27 In extreme situations, where the lack of relief would amount to starvation, no valid reasons can be invoked to justify the refusal.Footnote 28 Article 54(1) of Additional Protocol I provides that ‘starvation of civilians as a method of warfare is prohibited’.Footnote 29
What are the conditions under which relief actions must be conducted? According to Article 70(2) of Additional Protocol I, all states must ‘facilitate rapid and unimpeded passage of all relief consignments, equipment and personnel, … even if such assistance is destined for the civilian population of the adverse Party’. This provision applies to the whole civilian population (not only to vulnerable groups), and relief consignments include all supplies essential to the survival of the population (not only to specific categories of goods).Footnote 30 Additional Protocol I further prohibits states from delaying the forwarding of relief consignments and from diverting them from the purpose for which they are intended. Exceptions are permitted only in cases of urgent necessity and if this is in the interest of the population concerned.Footnote 31 This means that the delay can only be justified if it is impossible for reasons of security to enter the territory where the receiving population is situated, or to cross some part of the territory of the party allowing the transit, particularly if this is a party to the conflict. According to the Commentary on the Additional Protocols, diverting relief consignments could be allowed particularly:
when there is a delay in the transport of perishable foodstuffs, always provided that they are replaced by fresh provisions as soon as normal conditions are restored. It might also be justifiable in the case that a natural disaster … affected the Party through whose territory the relief consignment was passing, so that the provisions were even more necessary for the victims of this disaster than for those for whom they had initially been intended. However, in this case the consignment should only be diverted with the agreement of the donor.Footnote 32
Parties to the conflict have an obligation to take positive action to protect relief consignments and to facilitate their rapid distribution, as well as a duty to encourage and facilitate effective international co-ordination of the relief actions.Footnote 33 However, the parties to the conflict and other States Parties to Additional Protocol I have the right to prescribe technical arrangements, such as pre-determined times and routes.Footnote 34 They are also allowed to control the consignments or to ask for the local supervision of the relief action by a Protecting Power or an impartial humanitarian organization.Footnote 35
Relief personnel must be respected, protected, and assisted, to the fullest extent practicable, in carrying out their mission.Footnote 36 But relief personnel may not exceed the terms of their mission under any circumstances, and must respect security requirements imposed by the states in whose territory they are working. The mission of those who do not respect these conditions may be terminated.Footnote 37
Consent and conditions in non-international armed conflict
The issue of humanitarian assistance and access is not expressly addressed in Article 3 common to the four Geneva Conventions. However, article 18(2) of Additional Protocol II provides that relief actions shall be undertaken subject to the consent of the affected state.Footnote 38 As in international armed conflicts, where the lack of relief would lead to starvation, no valid reason can be invoked to justify a refusal. Article 14 of Additional Protocol II prohibits starvation of civilians as a method of warfare.
From a practical point of view, the consent of relevant non-state armed groups controlling or operating in the territory in question is necessary for relief actions to be carried out.Footnote 39 Nevertheless, to ask a non-state armed group for its consent to humanitarian operations does not constitute recognition, nor does it confer any legal status upon that actor.Footnote 40 The African Union Convention for the Protection and Assistance of Internally Displaced Persons in Africa (Kampala Convention) is innovative in that it refers specifically to armed groups.Footnote 41 The treaty states that members of armed groups are prohibited from impeding humanitarian assistance and passage of all relief consignments, equipment, and personnel to internally displaced persons.Footnote 42
According to a customary rule, parties to non-international armed conflicts must facilitate rapid and unimpeded passage of humanitarian relief for civilians in need.Footnote 43 In addition, humanitarian relief personnel and objects must be respected and protected, and the freedom of movement of authorized humanitarian relief personnel must be ensured. Their movements may only be temporarily restricted in case of imperative military necessity.Footnote 44
Consent and conditions during occupation
Under the law of occupation, there is a clear obligation for the Occupying Power to ensure that the basic needs of the population under its control are fulfilled. This mainly results from Article 55(1) of the Fourth Geneva Convention, which provides that the Occupying Power has the duty to ensure the provision of food and medical supplies for the civilian population. Article 69(1) of Additional Protocol I further stipulates that the Occupying Power must ensure without adverse distinction the provision of clothing, bedding, means of shelter, and other supplies essential to the survival of the civilian population, as well as objects necessary for religious worship.Footnote 45 While imposing clear obligations in this regard, the Fourth Geneva Convention and Additional Protocol I do not ignore the material difficulties that the Occupying Power may face in practice. These instruments provide that the Occupying Power is bound to meet these needs ‘[t]o the fullest extent of the means available to it’.Footnote 46 Financial constraints or transport problems, for instance, may seriously affect the concerned authorities' capabilities to meet their obligations.Footnote 47
However, if the Occupying Power is not in a position to fulfil its duty to provide the civilian population under its control with essential supplies, it must agree to relief schemes on behalf of this population.Footnote 48 This obligation is unconditional.Footnote 49 The Occupying Power must either ensure that the civilian population receives essential supplies or agree to relief actions.
The Occupying Power has the obligation to facilitate relief actions by all the means at its disposal.Footnote 50 Occupying Powers must also facilitate the rapid distribution of relief consignments, which must be exempt from all charges, taxes, or customs duties except if they are necessary for the economy of the occupied territory.Footnote 51 Relief consignments must not be diverted from the purpose for which they are intended. Exceptions to this rule are allowed in cases of urgent necessity only and if this is in the interest of the occupied population and with the consent of the Protecting Power.Footnote 52 The rights and duties of relief personnel also apply in times of occupation.Footnote 53
In addition, the Fourth Geneva Convention sets out obligations for third states, including, most notably, those through whose territory relief consignments must pass. Parties to the Convention must permit the free passage of such consignments and guarantee their protection.Footnote 54 However, authorities granting the authorization are allowed to check the consignments to satisfy themselves that the operation is strictly humanitarian, and may regulate their passage according to prescribed times and routes.Footnote 55
What human rights obligations exist with regard to humanitarian access?
International human rights law continues to apply, alongside international humanitarian law, in times of armed conflict, whether of an international or of a non-international character. The two are complementary and not mutually exclusive.Footnote 56 The major human rights law instruments do not refer explicitly to humanitarian assistance and access. However, some references are found in the Convention on the Rights of the Child,Footnote 57 the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child,Footnote 58 and the Kampala Convention.Footnote 59
Generally, states have an obligation to ensure the minimum essential levels of all economic, social, and cultural rights at all times.Footnote 60 In determining the contents of those obligations, the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) has referred to essential food, primary health care, and basic shelter and housing.Footnote 61 States must respect, protect, and fulfil these rights.Footnote 62 The right to food and the right to health are described as examples.
Regarding the right to food,Footnote 63 CESCR has stated that the
obligation to respect existing access to adequate food requires States parties not to take any measures that result in preventing such access. The obligation to protect requires measures by the State to ensure that enterprises or individuals do not deprive individuals of their access to adequate food. The obligation to fulfil (facilitate) means the State must pro-actively engage in activities intended to strengthen people's access to and utilization of resources and means to ensure their livelihood, including food security. Finally, whenever an individual or group is unable, for reasons beyond their control, to enjoy the right to adequate food by the means at their disposal, States have the obligation to fulfil (provide) that right directly.Footnote 64
The minimum core obligations inherent to the right to healthFootnote 65 require states at least
to ensure the right of access to health facilities, goods and services on a non-discriminatory basis, especially for vulnerable or marginalized groups; to ensure access to the minimum essential food which is nutritionally adequate and safe, to ensure freedom from hunger to everyone; to ensure access to basic shelter, housing and sanitation, and an adequate supply of safe and potable water.Footnote 66
It can be argued that international human rights law, and particularly the protections enshrined in the International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), provides a more substantive protection of humanitarian assistance than does international humanitarian law in situations where the restrictions to humanitarian assistance are attributable to State Parties to the ICESCR.Footnote 67
States must seek international assistance indispensable for the survival and the fulfilment of a population's essential needs.Footnote 68 A state that claims that it is unable to fulfil its legal obligations for reasons beyond its control must show that it has made ‘every effort to use all resources that are at its disposition in an effort to satisfy, as a matter of priority, those minimum obligations’.Footnote 69 In determining whether a state is truly unable to fulfil its obligations under human rights law, it is necessary to consider both the resources existing within a state and those available from the international community.Footnote 70
What are the consequences of violations?
A state is responsible for violations of international law regarding humanitarian access in situations of armed conflict where the violations are attributable to the state.Footnote 71 The UN Security Council has addressed violations of international law by non-state armed groups on numerous occasions.Footnote 72 Moreover, international criminal law prohibits certain conduct and holds individual perpetrators accountable for violations of these rules.
War crimes
The denial of humanitarian assistance and access to civilians may under certain conditions constitute the war crime of starvation. International humanitarian law prohibits the starvation of civilians as a method of warfare in both international and non-international armed conflict.Footnote 73 The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court draws a distinction between international and non-international armed conflict as regards the starvation of civilians. In international armed conflict, the intentional starvation of civilians as a method of warfare through deprivation of objects indispensable to their survival is prohibited, ‘including wilfully impeding relief supplies as provided for under the Geneva Conventions’.Footnote 74 In non-international armed conflict, starvation as a method of warfare does not constitute a war crime under the Statute. However, starvation of civilians as a method of warfare constitutes a war crime under several national legislations, and states have denounced alleged instances of the use of starvation in non-international armed conflicts.Footnote 75
Attacking persons or objects involved in the provision of humanitarian assistance – provided that they are not directly participating in hostilities – is a war crime according to the Rome Statute, if such attacks take place during, and in connection with, an international or non-international armed conflict.Footnote 76 States have committed themselves to ensure that perpetrators of attacks against humanitarian personnel are held accountable, by encouraging disciplinary measures and criminal prosecutions.Footnote 77
Crimes against humanity
Acts constituting crimes against humanity could include the denial of humanitarian assistance and access when committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against any civilian population, with knowledge of the attack.Footnote 78 They include murder, extermination, torture, persecution, and other inhumane acts.Footnote 79 The Rome Statute defines the crime against humanity of ‘extermination’ as including ‘the deprivation of access to food and medicine, calculated to bring about the destruction of part of a population’.Footnote 80 The individuals responsible can be prosecuted in national and international courts.
Conclusion: is the current legal framework an adequate tool to ensure humanitarian access?
The tension between the needs of victims to receive humanitarian assistance, the interests of the international community in providing relief, and the right of the state to decide who and what can enter its territory is obvious.Footnote 81 Generally, international humanitarian law demands that a balance be struck between military necessities and the requirements of humanity.Footnote 82 The difficult questions with regard to humanitarian access are: how exactly is that balance to be struck and what are possible areas of further clarifications?
The extent to which parties to both international and non-international armed conflicts are bound to accept relief actions could be clarified. It could be defined on which grounds – besides starvation – consent cannot be refused.Footnote 83 Or, positively, an obligation to accept relief could be determined.Footnote 84 Clarifications on the scope and limitations of the right of control that the parties are allowed to exercise on relief operations would also be helpful. For instance, the extent to which humanitarian organizations are entitled to enjoy freedom of movement in their activities and the correlative right of the parties to armed conflicts to restrict their freedom for reasons of imperative military necessity could be defined more precisely.
Overall, the current legal framework is an adequate tool to ensure humanitarian access but the abovementioned areas could be clarified. This said, it needs to be pointed out that nothing prevents humanitarian actors from seeking to obtain greater access than that specified in international law. International law only represents the limits or minimum standards of humanitarian access. The key is to use the most persuasive arguments that allow the provisions of international law on humanitarian access to be implemented and the well-being of civilian populations secured.Footnote 85 Even though access constraints are rarely the result of purely legal obstacles (humanitarian access is often complicated by administrative restrictions, such as difficulties in obtaining visas, import authorizations for relief supplies, or repeated controls), the legal framework is a useful tool to obtain and secure access to affected populations. This implies that this legal framework must be widely known and disseminated,Footnote 86 and both humanitarian actors and those who can prevent access need to be trained in this legal framework.Footnote 87
Summary
The following points summarize the international legal framework on humanitarian access in armed conflict as discussed in this article:
– States bear the primary responsibility for ensuring the basic needs of affected populations.
– Humanitarian actors can offer their services but do not have an obligation to do so. To avoid being considered unlawful interference in a state's internal affairs, humanitarian assistance must be provided in accordance with humanitarian principles.
– In territories other than occupied territories, humanitarian operations are subject to the consent of the parties concerned. The legal challenge is to determine in each specific case whether concerned states may invoke valid reasons to refuse relief actions on their territories. It must be established under which criteria the refusal may be considered as arbitrary, and therefore contrary to relevant provisions of international humanitarian law. In extreme situations, where the lack of relief would amount to starvation, there is no valid reason justifying a refusal.
– To ask a non-state armed group for its consent to the provision of humanitarian assistance does not constitute recognition of, nor does it confer any legal status upon, that actor.
– In occupied territories, there is a clear obligation for the Occupying Power either to ensure adequate supplies to the population or to agree to and facilitate relief actions, if all or part of the population is inadequately supplied.
– Humanitarian relief personnel and objects must be respected and protected, and the freedom of movement of authorized humanitarian relief personnel must be ensured. Parties to the conflict have the right to prescribe technical arrangements, such as pre-determined times and routes. Relief personnel must respect security requirements imposed by the states in whose territory they are working.
– States have an obligation to ensure the satisfaction of the minimum essential levels of all economic, social, and cultural rights and to take the necessary action even in situations of armed conflict. A state that claims that it is unable to fulfil its legal obligations for reasons beyond its control must show that it has made every effort to use all resources that are at its disposition in an effort to satisfy, as a matter of priority, those minimum obligations.
– A state is responsible for violations of international law regarding humanitarian access where the violations are attributable to the state.
– The denial of humanitarian assistance and access may constitute a crime under international criminal law. Relevant examples include the war crimes of starvation and of launching attacks against persons involved in humanitarian assistance. The individuals responsible can be prosecuted in national and international courts.
– The current legal framework – which should be widely known and disseminated – is an adequate tool to ensure humanitarian access but could be clarified further.
