The past decade has witnessed a dramatic growth in musicological interest in the Cold War, as well as a turn toward cultural history among diplomatic historians. These developments have brought significant scholarly attention to the U.S. government's employment of jazz musicians as Cold War diplomats. Lisa Davenport completed her doctoral dissertation in history on this topic in 2002 (Georgetown University), providing the first examination of government sources concerning the 1956–68 jazz tours. Her 2009 book Jazz Diplomacy is clearly an outgrowth of this project. In the interim, Penny Von Eschen produced her now well-known 2004 study Satchmo Blows up the World: Jazz Ambassadors Play the Cold War, the first book-length history of jazz diplomacy. Ingrid Monson's 2007 Freedom Sounds: Civil Rights Call Out to Jazz and Africa also made an important contribution with its analysis of the relationship of the tours to the Civil Rights movement.Footnote 1 In addition, several significant journal articles on jazz diplomacy have been produced, including Danielle Fosler-Lussier's “Cultural Diplomacy as Cultural Globalization: The University of Michigan Jazz Band in Latin America,” published in this journal in 2010.Footnote 2 Meanwhile, scholars have also begun to consider government-funded promotions of other musical styles during the Cold War and music diplomacy in other countries and time periods.Footnote 3
In contrast to Von Eschen's seminal study, Davenport's Jazz Diplomacy focuses less on the details of the tours themselves and more on the political contexts and subtexts surrounding them. It is this feature of the book that represents its most significant contribution to the literature. Over the course of six chapters, Davenport lays out a chronologically organized overview of the jazz tours, while also explaining relevant aspects of the history of cultural diplomacy in the United States, U.S.-Soviet exchange, the Civil Rights movement, and the evolution of the jazz style.
Davenport's first chapter gives a brief introduction to U.S.-Soviet cultural relations during the early Cold War as a basis for interpreting the political agendas that motivated the jazz tours. She examines several major events—the Geneva Summit, the Bandung Conference, the Soviet invasion of Hungary, and the Communist cultural offensive in Asia—that led the United States government to alter its response to the threat of Soviet expansion. The result of these developments, she says, was the birth of a strategy of “cultural containment,” a coinage that I discuss further below.
Chapter Two looks at the early years of jazz diplomacy, 1954–57, against the background of growing racial turmoil in the United States. After relating evidence of the discrimination faced by jazz musicians in the United States, Davenport analyzes the debates surrounding the first State Department jazz tour by Dizzy Gillespie and his band. Chapter Three continues in this vein by examining the interplay between Civil Rights conflicts such as the Little Rock crisis and the tours of 1957–60. Chapter Four, “The Paradox of Jazz Diplomacy, 1961–66,” examines the tours of the early sixties in relation to an important question: “How could black art embody the soul of American culture and the essence of American civilization when black Americans were an ill-treated people?” (95). In this context, Davenport argues, jazz became a site for political resistance, both at home and abroad.
In Chapters Five and Six Davenport turns her attention to U.S.-Soviet cultural exchange during the 1960s, examining discussions in the United States about jazz deployments beyond the Iron Curtain and Soviet reaction to the art form's proliferation in the Communist bloc. Davenport's narrative makes plain an intriguing fact: that for governing officials in both the United States and the U.S.S.R. jazz was something that had to be kept sanitized and artistically “safe,” albeit for different reasons in each case. In useful detail, Davenport charts the changing status of jazz in the U.S.S.R. and the impact of the Vietnam War upon the United States’ musical promotions. She also examines the ways in which Soviet musicians adapted the style to local ideological conditions, the impact of jazz upon Soviet society more broadly, and the internationalization of jazz brought about by festivals outside the United States.
Davenport's most significant contributions to the literature on jazz diplomacy come in these final chapters and in her conclusion, which offers a nuanced consideration of the positive and negative outcomes of jazz diplomacy. As Davenport reminds us, jazz diplomacy did not always improve the international image of the United States. Furthermore, it sometimes elevated interracial friction at home. Yet at the same time, jazz diplomacy held great symbolic import, making plain the limits of recent progress in U.S. race relations and thus serving, Davenport says, as a “barometer of freedom,” a term she borrows from Cornel West (146). By focusing on these interesting and complex outcomes, her conclusion avoids both definitive claims about jazz diplomacy's success and overblown sermonizing about the power of culture.
When compared with these thoughtful closing ideas, some of the arguments laid out at the opening of Davenport's study seem less carefully articulated. She begins the book with an assertion of jazz diplomacy's significance, claiming that it “dramatically transformed superpower relations in the Cold War era” (4). Unfortunately, her study is unable to prove conclusively that the twenty-eight State Department–funded jazz tours changed the trajectory of the U.S.-Soviet relationship, even as it does show that the tours had political significance at specific moments in specific national contexts. Ultimately, this overstated assertion seems unnecessary, because the remainder of the book demonstrates clearly that the question “did it work?” is not only unanswerable but also perhaps the least interesting question raised by the jazz tours.
Davenport's opening thesis statement also requires some careful consideration. Here she attempts to differentiate her book's argument by contrasting it with Von Eschen's claims.
But unlike Von Eschen, [this book] argues that ultimately the problem of culture and jazz diplomacy in American foreign policy had to be addressed apart from worldwide economic and military exigencies that had arisen during this era. Even in the midst of critical Cold War disputes, jazz diplomacy existed in a realm that often transcended economic and strategic priorities. Jazz often became the subject of heated debates about aesthetic agency and cultural property. Moreover, the goal of containing Communism remained paramount in shaping the course of jazz diplomacy (4).
This statement is most perplexing. First the author asserts that jazz diplomacy was pursued quite separately from considerations of Cold War strategy. Then in the final sentence she follows the word “moreover” with what is effectively a contradiction of this claim. Indeed, the book as a whole contradicts the first idea, making clear through its emphasis on context that Davenport believes that jazz diplomacy cannot be fully understood without examining contemporary political realities. In overtly marking this problematic idea as her book's original contribution, Davenport significantly weakens her argumentative framing.
I also take issue with Davenport's coinage of the term, “cultural containment,” which is used throughout the book. Whereas Davenport employs the term to denote a strategy in which culture served the United States’ containment policy (15), others have used it to describe Cold War efforts to contain culture (where culture refers to gender roles, sexual license, and artistic expression, for example).Footnote 4 Davenport seeks to understand jazz diplomacy as an element of the United States’ containment strategy: that is, the effort to limit Soviet expansion, whether economic, political, ideological, or cultural. Yet as Davenport herself observes, the stated goal of the Cultural Presentations Program (through which the jazz tours were organized) was to “counteract Russian propaganda,” which depicted the United States as both uncultured and fraught with social and racial inequalities (39). “Counteract” is a much more active verb than “contain” and indeed it was almost impossible for the United States to “contain” the spread of Soviet culture. Instead, the jazz tours represented one among many American efforts to use the arts to wage an ideological war with the Soviet Union. The cultural Cold War was thus one conflict the United States intended to win, not contain.
Although some of these issues may raise concern, this study's fully contextualized history of the tours brings much to the literature. Certainly by the end of the book the reader has a well-balanced picture of the moral, social, and political complexity of these tours—musical events that revealed both the best and the worst of the United States at mid-century.
