Maecenas is one figure with whom French scholars seem particularly comfortable. After all, they are familiar with éminences grises and hommes de l'ombre. Clément Chillet's book is the second dedicated monograph to appear in a few years — and the second one in French, following Philippe Le Doze's wonderfully titled Mécène: ombres et flamboyances (2014). Previously, the most substantial study was Jean-Marie André’s Mécène (1967). Both C. and Le Doze take a very different approach from André’s idiosyncratic and subjective psycho-biography, which focused as much on Maecenas as Epicurean literary patron and author in his own right as on Maecenas the statesman. While Le Doze is concerned with the literary and intellectual milieu of Maecenas and the poets he fostered, C.’s adaptation of his Lyon doctoral thesis is densely, meticulously historical. He does not believe in trying to recover Maecenas’ motives or giving too much credence to the literary sources. He sees himself as a craftsman, not a cook who whips a ‘roux’ of knowable facts into some frothy ‘sauce biographique’. His aim is to assess Maecenas’ political performance as prop and enabler of the Augustan regime, ‘un bras droit éfficace de César’ (echoing the phrase attributed to him by the author of the anonymous imperial poem, Elegiae in Maecenatem: ‘Caesaris … dextra’).
C.’s approach is three-pronged: first, to put Maecenas’ Etruscan identity in a broader context; secondly, to assess his active contribution in terms of raising revenue, advising, diplomacy and policing; and finally, to discuss what he calls his ‘sociability’, a critical tool for knitting together networks, not just of poets but also of aristocratic families, freedmen and regional interests. He uses a mixture of literary, epigraphic and archaeological sources, and uses them exhaustively, though, as he admits, there is barely anything new to work with, save a few inscriptions about Maecenas’ freedmen. Maecenas himself may be ‘figé dans l’éternelle froideur d'une image immobile’, but there is plenty of scope to re-evaluate his achievements as a figurehead for the more personalised and pragmatic aspects of Augustan power. C. treads a middle path between various extremes: Syme's assessment of the Augustan era as a radical political break and Mommsen's belief in juridical continuity with the Republic; the ‘potato’ of statistical history and the ‘rose’ of narrative history (Anatole France's metaphors); the history of grand personalities and events and that of social landscape and longue durée. His Maecenas is ‘un sujet globalisant’: outwards from this cohesive figure stretches the entire history of the triumviral revolution and the successful inauguration of the Augustan regime as a world force.
Where Maecenas’ vaunted descent from Etruscan kings is concerned, C. rightly shows how this was more than just some antiquarian fad: like the urn of Volumnius at Perusia and the Corsini throne, it was a timely contribution to the revival of local identity, one that coincided paradoxically with the Princeps’ efforts to absorb Etruria with the rest of tota Italia. Far from cultivating the past for its own sake, Maecenas used Etruscan identity creatively, adapting it in new ways to work with the future dispensation. C. points to the novel position of his garden estate, straddling the city limits, as symbolic of an outsider's integration into Rome, even as it offered a model for retreat from the centre and evoked the withdrawal to the Esquiline of another Etruscan, King Servius Tullius. He rehearses the complicated arguments for Maecenas’ possible maternal relationship with the Cilnii family, arguing that any hybrid blending of these charismatic but insular Etruscan magnates with the upwardly mobile Maecenates, whether by marriage or adoption, would contribute to the harmonisation of regional and metropolitan interests.
Maecenas’ choice to stay in the rank of the equites is also deemed politically sagacious: a conventional senatorial career may have been beneath his status as a ‘king’, while an equestrian one suited his business activities, his other non-senatorial values and his desire to operate in a less constrained fashion. His much-discussed retirement was probably a personal choice, after a job well done, rather than a cover for disgrace. At the same time, it is hard to escape the fact that many of his personal tastes — purple robes, war chariot, sprawling Esquiline palace — smacked of unacceptable adfectatio regni. Virgil helped, C. argues, by separating the Etruscans from the tyrant Mezentius in the Aeneid and re-configuring them as loyal allies to Aeneas, while Servius Tullius’ humble origins and anti-tyrannical stance made him the acceptable, ‘democratic’ face of regnum.
In the central section of the book, C. weighs up, in scrupulous detail, how far Maecenas’ blueprint for the principate in Dio's imaginary speech could be read as a summary of his actual policies and engagement, whether fiscal, diplomatic or security-related. He does some impressive detective work to uncover Maecenas’ links with freedmen in Istria, vineyards in north-east Italy and estates in Egypt, all of which, he argues, can account for Augustus’ success in recruiting troops and seizing and stabilising power. Less positively, Maecenas’ involvement in tax collection can be linked with the beginnings of imperial bureaucracy and his unofficial status as amicus principis with the embryonic kitchen cabinets of the imperial court.
Finally, and perhaps most interestingly, C. addresses Maecenas’ role as the hub of many social networks — of freedmen, aristocrats and poets, alike. He rejects the idea of the self-contained poetic ‘circle’, misleading when its boundaries were so porous and its constituency so fluid. The poets were just one group among many beneficiaries of Maecenas’ unique position as intermediary between Rome and the regions, his own household and the emperor's. After all the heavy investigative work, C. concludes in ‘rosy’ vein with a running narrative of the triumviral years and their aftermath, one that convincingly gives Maecenas a starring role. Throughout, he makes ingenious use of comparative material to plug the gaps in the testimony and is honest about what must remain hypothesis only (his identification of Maecenas’ head-swathing pallium in Seneca's Epistle 114 as some kind of Etruscan hood is not entirely convincing). This is a model of imaginative but judicious reconstruction, in the author's words ‘tissage plus que couture’.
