Aristotle taught that virtue is its own reward, but centuries later Machiavelli demanded that virtue justify itself at the court of necessity. For Machiavelli, the virtuous man is he who best discerns and does whatever will be most profitable in his particular time and place. A similar change is underway in American higher education. While knowledge was once considered its own reward, it now must justify itself. Changes in our economy and culture are working their way into American universities where a new class of university administrators is demanding that knowledge be profitable. In Wannabe U, sociologist Gaye Tuchman examines how this transformation is playing out at one American university.
Professors often assume that universities exist for no other reason than to give professors a place to do their work. While the knowledge professors discover or produce might occasionally possess some ancillary social benefits, they understand their work to be of inherent, self-justifying value, regardless of what anyone outside the university thinks of it. And since it is impossible to predict in advance where the search for knowledge will lead, they are highly resistant to the university administration's attempts to evaluate their work or otherwise rationalize the structure and management of it. American universities have thus developed as institutions with highly decentralized power structures, dominated by cultures averse to institutional change. Beginning in the late twentieth century, this led to a number of crises in American higher education as universities had difficulty responding to new challenges. The declining birthrate in the last quarter of the century meant that many schools saw their enrollments and tuition revenues decrease. At the same time, changes in the political and economic atmosphere often led state legislatures to reduce the financial support they provided to public universities in their states. Since even universities must balance their budgets, either costs had to be reduced or new sources of revenue found.
Tuchman's book presents an ethnographic case study of one university that has been going through a period of “transformation” as it responds to these challenges. The author disguises the identity of this school by referring to it simply as Wannabe U or Wan U and reveals only that it is a second-tier, flagship public, research university in the Northeast. (With the information Tuchman provides, a reader willing to do just a little legwork can identify the school easily enough.) To Wan U's leadership, “transformation” has meant improving the university's perception as a prestigious research university and increasing its revenues by attracting more tuition-paying students, professionalizing the management of endowments and enrollments, and investing only in academic programs that hold the greatest potential for profit.
Perhaps the most important development at Wan U, as at American universities in general, has been the emergence of a new class of administrators dedicated to changing the cultures of their institutions. In the past, most university administrators were selected from the faculty ranks. They generally shared the faculty's attitudes and were tied to them by close professional and personal ties. Additionally, faculty members who stayed on the academic track shared in the governance of their institutions through the influence of faculty senates and university councils. Today, it is more common for key administration positions to be filled by applicants from outside the university who have no such connections to the faculty. In fact, many move from school to school without expectation of staying at any one institution for very long. Imbued with a corporate ethic of efficiency and profit, they find ways to shift control over key university functions from academic departments and faculty senates to staff offices that they create outside the traditional system of shared governance. When these administrators are successful, faculty lose influence over matters such as curriculum and promotions and find themselves subject to an increasingly invasive “audit regime” in which quantifiable measures (metrics) are used to evaluate their performance in teaching, publishing, grant acquisition, and service.
This change of culture has a profound impact on how faculty members do their jobs. In order to increase the university's prestige, administrators might transfer resources away from departments and faculty members who are doing work that is considered marginal in their disciplines. Additionally, departments that are most likely to produce profitable patents or attract corporate investment are more likely to receive new funding.
Teaching has changed as well, in terms of both quantity and substance. As administrators increase the size of their student bodies in order to keep tuition dollars rolling in, the faculty must teach larger classes or more classes each semester to accommodate a larger student body. And since adding new faculty is expensive and likely to create yet another difficult-to-control tenured professor who is more interested in research than teaching, new courses created for these students are often staffed with adjunct faculty or professional staff. At public universities, where administrators must justify their budgets to members of the legislature and the business interests they represent, new initiatives in teaching are likely to emphasize how they will prepare students to be useful employees in the state's dominant industries (41, 194–95).
Tuchman's study does a number of things very well. Almost anyone who works in a university will find much of what she describes very familiar. While obviously sympathetic to the faculty perspective, Tuchman does more than simply repeat the criticisms that faculty members frequently make of these changes. This volume reveals the assumptions and logic behind the new administrative agenda, and Tuchman highlights the key points of conflict between the assumptions of administrators and those of faculty members.
Additionally, there are times when the book is just plain fun to read. There is a reason that academic parody novels are so common; it's because people who work in academia are so easy to make fun of. Tuchman lets the egos, petty rivalries, and occasional paranoias at Wan U shine through, much to her readers' delight.
The book's limitations are perhaps inevitable in any in-depth, ethnographic study. Wan U is a research university, and a state-supported university, and a second-tier university. It is one kind of institution with a culture, challenges, and opportunities different from those at other schools. There are times when Tuchman's book seems so concerned with explaining the intricacies of particular controversies at Wan U that the forest is missed for the trees. Chapter 6, on teaching, is a case in point. Tuchman describes the tension between the administration, which wanted to improve the “undergraduate learning experience” and devised new means to evaluate teaching, and the faculty, almost all of whom considered teaching peripheral to their careers and rejected the idea that the administration could evaluate teaching anyway. This tension is nothing new in American universities. From a broader view, it becomes apparent that there is more at stake than simply how much attention professors give to teaching. Even for professors who consider teaching central to their vocations, teaching is changing in sometimes disturbing ways. The consumeristic orientation of university administrators—even at so-called teaching schools—creates constant pressure to commoditize educational experiences so that they become more accessible to students and more profitable to universities. This pressure takes many forms, including sacrificing the classroom experience for online education, the proliferation of “service learning” experiences as replacements for formal instruction, or even reducing academic standards to please paying customers. These kinds of changes are described only in passing, if at all, in this study.
This is simply to say that the book completes its chosen task well but leaves many questions unanswered. Wannabe U is about the transformation of one school. While Tuchman at least acknowledges that the changes at Wan U are related to broader social trends, this study sometimes seems less concerned with the broader context of American higher education or the question of where these trends might be leading us.
The fact of the matter is that even universities must pay their bills, and, as a classic New Yorker cartoon once pointed out, “on the other hand, the examined life doesn't seem to produce much income.” Many universities have responded slowly, if at all, to dramatic change in the surrounding culture. It should then come as no surprise that administrators with a more corporate ethic have stepped into the leadership vacuum. While faculty members resent these changes, many also recognize that the ethos of knowledge for its own sake won't carry you far when your employer can't pay your salary.
Universities will have to change; that much seems certain. What is unknown is whether this new class of administrators simply will change the way business is done or whether they will transform American higher education in more fundamental and troubling ways. Can some form of shared governance survive, even as administrators increase their power? Will faculty members maintain their freedom to explore even the most controversial ideas? Or will they end up, as Tuchman seems to fear, like “the proverbial frog in the pot. If you drop the sucker in boiling water, he will jump out; but if you increase the heat slowly enough, he eventually finds himself boiled” (202). It could be that we're all bound to be boiled alive. But higher education has adjusted before, and it might yet survive this transformation with its sense of mission intact. And mid-tier, public universities like Wan U are only one kind of school. Perhaps the faculty and administration at other schools—perhaps private schools, church-affiliated schools, or those where teaching remains a more central concern—will prove more adept at balancing our culture's obsession with financial profit and instant gratification with an enduring confidence that knowledge really is its own reward.
