In recent years, the literature on the global aspects of material exchanges has increased significantly. From the earliest treatments of the subject in the 1990s, which focused on trade and consumption (Consumption and the World of Goods, Reference Brewer and Porter1993) to more recent surveys of the circulation of one material (The Pilgrim Art, Reference Finlay2010), many attempts have been made to form a universal picture of the global movement of things and the impact of encounters with them. Perhaps the most ambitious approach is that taken in a new book by Teresa Canepa, Silk, Porcelain and Lacquer (2016) which attempts to provide a universal narrative of the trade and circulation of Asian goods in the West during the eventful period 1500–1644, which coincides with the later part of the Ming dynasty in China (1368-1644).
Canepa's book is very extensive and wide ranging yet it situates mercantile connections, cultural exchanges and artistic ‘influences’ (the author's term) in a single history which has not been attempted successfully before. Through separate chapters on three types of goods: silk, porcelain and lacquer, the first two from China and the latter from Japan, a story emerges of a singular motivation on behalf of European traders and consumers: distinction, in both the Bourdieu sense and a material one. These goods brought profits to Europeans as well as new materials and with these, tangible links to Asian producers. Much of what is addressed and presented here has been published before, but separately in individual accounts of localised activity or products. As Canepa states in her introduction, her aim was to use “past and current academic studies and publications, combining them with new research, to provide an overview” and in doing so to “explore new perspectives on the complex and fascinating trade encounters that occurred between East and West in the early Modern period”. (p. 13)
Canepa's text is based on a PhD dissertation and is structured accordingly. Divided into three main chapters covering separately silk, porcelain and lacquer, the stories are nonetheless interlinked and cross referenced through several introductions and concluding discussions within the chapters. The general introduction to the book and the conclusion also help to introduce and defend the approach and topic, highlighting the several new insights and interpretations which have arisen from this wide-ranging study. The resulting book is very comprehensive, extremely detailed and notably well illustrated. It is at once academic and visually enticing, a rare combination in publishing today. The vast amount of data can at times seem overwhelming but here the book's origins as a dissertation have proved useful because each section in each chapter is concluded with a summing up, that also notes the new material or interpretations that were posited. The book would therefore be very useful in teaching but is also manageable for more casual readers who can focus on the summaries.
In the first chapter on silk, this structure helps to reinforce Canepa's assertion that the wide ranging data needs to be assessed from both a local and a global perspective as well as a material one in the time period concerned. With silk, for example, the trade was international, moving from China to various European bases in Asia and across to the New World as it is defined here, and then back to Europe. Yet consumption was often very much localised both geographically and socially. For example, in Spain sumptuary laws and trade restrictions limited the consumption of Chinese silks but in the Spanish empire, the New World, Chinese silk was traded and used much more extensively. The use of silk by European clergy, both within Asia and back in Europe was also more extensive and more visible than is generally noted, with the Jesuits taking an active role in its circulation, design and display.
The role of the clergy is a consistent theme in this book and one which deserves emphasis, as the next chapter on porcelain indicates. The Jesuits participated in the porcelain trade and much of the relevant archaeological data has been discovered at religious sites such as nunneries and monasteries. In this chapter, it is Canepa's reading of material on the Iberian trade and consumption of Chinese porcelain that has led to two important new discoveries: firstly that the panelled style of so-called ‘kraak’ porcelain appears on wares exported from China before the ‘kraak’ style was developed and secondly that the display and storage of Chinese porcelain in dedicated rooms began in Portugal in the 1560s. The porcelain chapter is by far the longest in this book, primarily because so much work has been done on this subject already but it is to Canepa's credit that seemingly every primary and secondary source (apart from some in Chinese and Japanese) has been viewed and assessed, leading to such new insights. This includes even very recently published sources such as Krahe Reference Krahe2016 on Habsburg Spain and Chinese porcelain.
The final chapter on Japanese lacquer for the European market is shorter, but in the context of an integrated history, no less illuminating. Unlike silk and porcelain, most of this lacquer was made to order, with European shapes and designs, albeit sometimes filtered through a Portuguese colonial lens. The Jesuit role once again is demonstrated to be instrumental. As Canepa noted, the Jesuits played “a very important role in the cultural and artistic exchanges . . .between Japan, Western Europe and the New World in the late sixteenth to early seventeenth centuries”.(p. 353) It was their isolation and consequent need for religious objects that led to their commissioning of local craftsmen and the production of a new style of lacquer for export, namban.
While this book is not perfect and somewhat difficult to read as a whole, owing to its dense and slightly repetitive dissertation style, it demonstrates the benefits of wide-ranging histories set in a limited time frame. The micro-histories within the macro narrative can be read independently in addition to the first chapter of the book which provides an up to date survey history of the trade. There are countless fascinating images, a seemingly limitless bibliography (including my own work which has now been proved out of date) as well as useful appendices on shipwrecks and currency conversions, ensuring that this book has immense value for a wide range of readers and specialists alike.
