Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 May 2004
Attempting to balance the needs and interests of minors with the obligation to protect them from their own potentially harmful decisions poses an ethical challenge for the physician. This problem is further exacerbated when the context is not medical treatment but organ donation. That is, medical treatment scenarios generally involve decisions likely to result in objective improvements to the minor's health status. Consent to organ donation, however, raises several vexing problems. First, how should the provider measure both the cognitive ability and competence to consent of the minor to ensure that the minor comprehends the risks and benefits of donation and that no coercion is involved? Second, given that improvement of one's health is an unlikely scenario, is there a way to measure subjective determinations of satisfaction and altruism enjoyed by a minor following organ donation? If so, should the physician regard these values in a manner analogous to physical improvement? Finally, are parents the appropriate decisionmakers for their children when a sibling-to-sibling donation occurs? Is it possible for parents to always act in the best interests of both children in this event?
Attempting to balance the needs and interests of minors with the obligation to protect them from their own potentially harmful decisions poses an ethical challenge for the physician. This problem is further exacerbated when the context is not medical treatment but organ donation. That is, medical treatment scenarios generally involve decisions likely to result in objective improvements to the minor's health status. Consent to organ donation, however, raises several vexing problems. First, how should the provider measure both the cognitive ability and competence to consent of the minor to ensure that the minor comprehends the risks and benefits of donation and that no coercion is involved? Second, given that improvement of one's health is an unlikely scenario, is there a way to measure subjective determinations of satisfaction and altruism enjoyed by a minor following organ donation? If so, should the physician regard these values in a manner analogous to physical improvement? Finally, are parents the appropriate decisionmakers for their children when a sibling-to-sibling donation occurs? Is it possible for parents to always act in the best interests of both children in this event?
The American Medical Association (AMA) has established the best-interest approach to guide physicians working with children and adolescents considering organ donation. The AMA Code of Ethics report notes that:
The merits of a best-interest standard include its ability to incorporate the preferences of children as evidence of what is in their best interests without relying solely on a fictional determination of what they would want were their values more mature. Best interest also allows for the consideration of potential psychological benefits, when they exist, and weighs the medical risks of transplantation, rejecting transplantations which pose an unacceptably high risk to the minor source … [E]vidence of future benefit to the minor source should be clear and convincing. Possible benefits to a child include the following: Continued emotional bonds between the minor and the recipient; increased self-esteem; and prevention of adverse reaction to the death of a sibling. Whether a child will capture these benefits depends on the child's separate circumstances.1
American Medical Association, Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. Code of Medical Ethics, Report 56: the use of minors as organ and tissue donors, January 1994, cited in: Williams RW. Consent for children as organ donors. Hawaii Medical Journal 1995;54:499.
Similarly, a number of state courts have justified sibling-to-sibling organ donation based on a determination that donation results in a number of benefits to the donor child.2
See, e.g.: Strunk v. Strunk, 445 S. W. 2d. 145 (Ky. 1969); Hart v. Brown, 29 Conn. Supp. 368, 289 A. 2d. 386 (1972); and Little v. Little, 576 S. W. 2d. 493 (Tex. Civ. App. 1979), cited in: Rozovsky FA. Consent to Treatment: A Practical Guide, 2nd ed. Boston: Little, Brown; 1990:621–2.
See note 2, Rozovsky 1990:622, citing Little v. Little.
They are saying that it is in the child's best interests to: (1) be exposed to the unfamiliar and frightening environment of a hospital; (2) be exposed to the risks attending the use of general anaesthetics; (3) be exposed to the potentially serious peri- and post-operative risks associated with surgical removal of a healthy kidney; (4) be exposed to the potentially serious long-term risks associated with extended hyperperfusion of the remaining kidney, including known risks; (5) potentially experience the psychological trauma following a failed transplantation attempt; and finally, (6) potentially experience the “psychological benefits” following a successful transplantation attempt.4
Crouch RA, Elliott C. Moral agency and the family: the case of living related organ transplantation. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 1999;8(3):280.
Rozovsky notes that the Kentucky and Connecticut courts appear to rely on the substituted judgment theory as well.5
See note 2, Rozovsky 1990:618–20.
See note 2, Rozovsky 1990:618.
The first issue to explore is that of the cognitive abilities and limitations of the child and ensuring that the child is providing an acceptable consent or assent to the procedure. As Crouch and Elliott note,
one of the necessary preconditions of receiving what the court calls psychological benefits is that the donor have sufficient cognitive development to recognize the social aspect of donation; that is, the donor must be aware not merely that his or her kidney has been removed, but rather that he or she has helped the sibling by donating in a way that few (perhaps no) others could ever do.7
See note 4, Crouch, Elliott 1999:282.
The crucial question, then, becomes whether the child has the cognitive capacity to appreciate the quality of his or her action and the fact that this act is likely to result in a positive self-image. Given that younger children tend to be self-focused, this capacity is likely to be present primarily in older children and adolescents.
Classic Piagetian theory of child cognitive development holds that children ages 2–6 years old are in the preoperational stage and tend to be unable to generalize, lack the ability to think into the future, and need concrete examples.8
Broome ME, Stieglitz KA. The consent process and children. Research in Nursing and Health 1992;15:150.
See note 8, Broome, Stieglitz 1992:150.
See note 8, Broome, Stieglitz 1992:150.
Weithorn LA. Children's capacities to decide about participation in research. IRB: A Review of Human Subjects Research 1983;5(2):2.
See note 2, Rozovsky 1990:626.
See note 2, Rozovsky 1990:626.
See note 8, Broome, Stieglitz 1992:151.
Interestingly, the question of whether a child possesses the necessary skills to render such a decision has been explored most often in the context of research. Research, especially research with no possibility of providing a direct benefit to the minor subject, closely mirrors issues involved in organ donation, where direct benefit is unlikely. Both provide the minor with the opportunity to demonstrate affection (for a sibling in the context of organ donation, and for future unknown children in the context of research) and are likely to result in enhanced self-image as a result of this altruistic gift.
Federal regulations governing the use of children in research have established some important criteria that may be analogous to organ-donation situations. Previous federal policies used a proxy consent model where parents or guardians made all decisions concerning their child's participation in research.15
Koocher GP, Keith-Spiegel PC. Children, Ethics, and the Law: Professional Issues and Cases. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press; 1990:105.
See note 15, Koocher, Keith-Speigel 1990:105.
See note 15, Koocher, Keith-Speigel 1990:105.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Committee on Bioethics addressed the issue of assent in pediatric medical treatment.18
AAP Committee on Bioethics. Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Pediatrics 1995:95(2):314–7.
See note 18, AAP Committee on Bioethics 1995:315–6.
In her classic study designed to explore when children are able to make adultlike medical treatment decisions, Weithorn found that subjects as young as 9 years did not differ significantly from subjects ages 14, 18, and 21 when presented with complex scenarios.20
See note 11, Weithorn 1983:3.
See note 11, Weithorn 1983:3.
Developing cognitive skills and associated limitations may affect the informational component of the system but not the value system enunciated.22
Spike J. What's love got to do with it? the altruistic giving of organs. Journal of Clinical Ethics 1997;8(2):169.
Dickenson D. Children's informed consent to treatment: is the law an ass? Journal of Medical Ethics 1994;20:206.
See note 23, Dickenson 1994:206.
In the case of organ donation, minors deemed capable of providing consent and adults must be able to demonstrate sophisticated weighing of information prior to making a decision to donate. Information generally provided to potential organ donors includes:
Merion RM. How informed is informed consent? Transplantation Proceedings 1996;28(1):24.
Research indicates that even some adults have difficulty demonstrating knowledge sufficient to provide informed consent.26
See, e.g.: Howard JM, DeMets D, BHAT Research Group. How informed is informed consent? the BHAT experience. Controlled Clinical Trials 1981;2:187–303, where 8% of the sample questioned appeared to believe that they were receiving therapeutic care instead of participating in research.
The issue of parental coercion is more likely at the preoperational stage for minors 7–12 years old. This becomes less of an issue as the child matures. Indeed, one of the qualities of the formal operations stage is that adolescents are able to judge the merits of an act such as donation on its ability to help others and can make decisions about research not designed to have any direct, therapeutic benefit.27
See note 8, Broome, Stieglitz 1992:151.
In response to the question of how the provider may ensure that the child's interests are being protected prior to organ donation and that no coercion is involved, physicians should use adult standards of competence when older adolescents are involved. If a minor of 13 or 14 years or older wishes to donate an organ to a sibling, providers should ascertain the maturity level of the minor. Many minors may be capable of providing an effective informed consent, especially in states recognizing the mature minor legal exception. Alderson cited attorney Sheila McLean, who affirmed this notion that “the competence of the decision made should be the issue rather than the age of the person making that decision. This would mean that the onus would be on the adults to justify non-involvement of the child in consent and decision making.”28
Alderson P. Choosing for Children. New York: Oxford University Press; 1990, cited in: Purssell E. Listening to children: medical treatment and consent. Journal of Advanced Nursing 1995;21(4):623.
The second issue to examine is how to measure the likelihood of emotional satisfaction resulting from organ donation to an ill sibling. Further, are these inherently subjective emotions sufficient justification for donation when no direct benefit will result? This issue is closely related to the previous question, as only a truly informed consent will indicate whether altruistic feelings and self-esteem are likely to be high following donation.
One of the relevant ethical principles is that of respect for the child's limited autonomy. There is no moral duty to donate even when the anticipated benefits to the sibling are high.29
Tomlinson T. Infants and others who cannot consent to donation. Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine 1993;60(1):42.
See note 29, Tomlinson 1993:42.
Jeffrey Spike addressed the issue of accrual of benefit to the donor when he asked, “But should we set the standard higher for altruistic gifts, in order to protect patients from harming themselves without a full understanding of the consequences?”31
See note 22, Spike 1997:168.
In determining the benefits likely to accrue to the donor child, both long-term and short-term benefits should be considered. Sells has found that adult donors seldom regret the donation and score higher in self-esteem and lower in depression, regardless of the success of the transplantation 5–9 years later.32
Sells RA. Consent for organ donation: what are the ethical principles? Transplantation Proceedings 1993;25(1):39.
See note 4, Crouch, Elliott 1999:282.
Present and future benefits, including the improved health of a sibling, increased feelings of self-esteem and self-worth, the concept of oneself as altruistic giver, and enhanced feelings of autonomy and control may encourage us to allow providers and parents to allow a child to donate to a sibling regardless of lack of direct benefit. Although subjective, these psychological benefits may be just as valuable to mental health as therapeutic benefits are to physical health. Also, as noted previously, experience making these weighty decisions allows adolescents to exercise and develop decisionmaking skills. As Purssell noted,
We need to learn to respect children just as we do adults, both in regard to medical care and generally. Crompton (1992) suggests that we need to consider children as complete entities rather than simply immature adults. She also advocates a movement for “childism,” just as some people advocate feminism, so that we can learn to value children for what they are and not just what they will become.34
See note 28, Purssell 1995:624.
Finally, the third issue to explore is whether parents are the appropriate decisionmakers for both the donor child and the child who will receive the organ. Is it possible for parents to act in the interests of both children in this case? How can we resolve the conflicts of interest inherent in these situations? If we accept the dubious premise that parents are not the best surrogates in these instances, who should make these decisions?
The primary objection of allowing parents to make decisions for their child in these circumstances occurs “when the recipient is another family member [and] parents are in a conflict of interest as protectors of their infant's welfare. Their love and desperate hope for their other child might blind them to the real magnitude of harms their donor child would suffer.”35
See note 29, Tomlinson 1993:43.
Further complicating this issue is the problem of using the best-interest standard within a family.
The interests of more than one person are at stake. To attempt to cram a formal relation into an intimate context does violence to the morally significant aspects of the family relationship…. What is morally important and problematic about organ transplantation is precisely that it may not be in the best interests of the donor.36
See note 4, Crouch, Elliott 1999:285.
The best-interest framework is most effective, the authors suggest, in situations where competing values are not involved, and families simply do not fall into that category. Individual interests are intertwined with family interests,37
See note 4, Crouch, Elliott 1999:285.
We assume that parents are the best decisionmakers not only because they generally act in their children's best interests but also because they are in the best position to know the values and goals of both the organ donor and organ recipient. As Tomlinson notes, “consent for treatment of a never-competent child is loyal to them only when it is based on reasonable presumptions about what the child's values and goals would be relative to the risks of harm and promises of benefit of the treatment.”38
See note 29, Tomlinson 1993:42.
Kazdin A, French, N, Sherick R. Acceptability of alternative treatments for children: evaluations by inpatient children, parents, and staff. Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1981;49:900–7, cited in: Kent G. Volunteering children for bone marrow donation. BMJ 1996;313(7048):49.
Manne S, Jacobsen P, Redd W. Assessment of acute pediatric pain: do child self-report, parent ratings, and nurse ratings measure the same phenomenon? Pain 1992;48:45–52, cited in: Kent G. Volunteering children for bone marrow donation. BMJ 1996;313(7048):49.
Although not conclusive, these findings raise the issue of how well parents know the values espoused by the potential donor and recipient and, in turn, how well parental decisions reflect the interests of both children. Confirming this notion is research indicating that proxy decisions for (incompetent adult) patients tend to reflect the choice the proxy would make and not the choice that is in the best interest of the patient.41
Sachs GA, Stocking CB, Stern R, Cox DM, Hougham G, Sachs, RS. Ethical aspects of dementia research: informed consent and proxy consent. Clinical Research 1994;42(3):403–12.
Given that the possibility of parental coercion exists, should the provider seek input from others? For example, the provider may seek input from an independent individual or group, such as the hospital ethics committee.42
See note 1, Williams 1995:499–500.
Burgio GR, Nespoli L, Varrasi G, Buzzi F. Bone marrow transplantation in children: between therapeutic and medico-legal problems. Bone Marrow Transplantation 1989;4(Sl4):36.
Friedman Ross, among others, has argued strongly that parents remain the best decisionmaker in these cases: “parents are the better judge as they have a more vested interest in their child's well-being and are responsible for the day-to-day decisions of child-rearing.”44
Friedman Ross L. Health care decisionmaking by children: is it in their best interest? Hastings Center Report 1997;27(6):44.
Kuczewski MG. Reconceiving the family: the process of consent in medical decision making. Hastings Center Report 1996;26(2):34.
Parents are often the best decisionmakers for their children because they are generally in the best position to know the unique values and goals of both children in a sibling-to-sibling donation. Participation in these decisions by independent third parties such as ethics committees or consultants may be advisable, however, in situations involving disagreement between parents or other family members and the potential donor child.
Once these hurdles are surmounted, sibling-to-sibling organ donation offers the opportunity of continued good health and a longer life for the organ recipient. Subtle pressure (such as newspaper articles referring to donation as “the gift of life”) and not-so-subtle pressure (from parents or providers) should not transform what must remain a freely given gift into a mandated donation.
In conclusion, many adolescents of 13 or 14 years or older are able to make their own decisions. If a minor can clearly enunciate his or her values, wishes for donation, and appears to comprehend the attendant risks and benefits, a rebuttable presumption of competence may be appropriate. Similarly, the satisfaction that a minor feels from donation may be just as valuable as physical improvement following medical treatment. Finally, the presence of an independent third party may occasionally be necessary to protect the interests of the donor child.