At first glance the title of this volume might suggest that it is yet another book about Juan Domingo Perón and Peronism in Argentina, but The Politics of National Capitalism encompasses a broad range of provincial and national political actors, groups and movements that fed the phenomena known as Peronism. In this work, despite it bearing his name, Perón plays a secondary role and is no longer the ‘leading man’ of the movement but is viewed as part of a larger system. We learn how Peronism was nourished by many accidental and intentional incidents. The authors analyse its complexities, contradictions and conflicts, demonstrating how Peronism became a process and a well-oiled political machine that sustained itself on the goodwill, fear, stubbornness and anxiety of supporting and opposing political groups. Such groups recognised as the Argentine bourgeoisie in this work include business organisations, labour, government officials, provincial industrial groups, and many confederations and associations in Argentina. The two most important groups analysed are the Cámara Argentina de Industrias Metalúrgicas (Argentine Chamber of Metalwork Industries, CAIM) and the Confederación General Económica (General Economic Confederation, CGE).
The Politics of Nationalism Capitalism is a well-researched, well-written and thoughtfully analysed book. It identifies and clarifies the politics, economic policies and ironies of national capitalism and Peronism, and answers many of the questions that weren't already answered in Brennan's edited work Peronism and Argentina (1998). Over a decade ago, we needed to be satisfied with the answer that Peronism's breadth permitted it to be manipulated by many different politicians over time – it became many things to diverse groups of people. In The Politics of National Capitalism, the authors again emphasise Peronism's central ideas of social justice and economic independence, but this time they explain and analyse the diverse and small variations of Peronism and the conflicts among the myriad of political and economic groups that often resulted in political stalemates and in the implementation of policies that were short-sighted, limited, and accomplished very little. Previous works, such as Stephen Haber's chapter ‘The Political Economy of Industrialization’ in The Cambridge Economic History of Latin America (2006), have argued that Latin American governments' industrial policies failed to implement long-term goals, leading to the failure of post-war import substitution industrialisation. Argentina also fell into this pattern, but The Politics of National Capitalism outlines for us how this happened. Brennan and Rougier go further to state how ‘often incompatible demands did not necessarily have as their ultimate objective economic development’ (p. 202).
It is important to our understanding of the interaction between groups and the state to distinguish between Peronism, economic development and national capitalism. Peronism was not economic nationalism, though it included the concept of economic nationalism. Economic development under Peronism could be sacrificed if it undermined national capitalism and social justice goals. Since 2006, new works have researched the history of economic nationalism in Argentina, finding its roots in the 1920s with Alejandro Bunge and his group that called for ‘industrialization, expanding domestic markets, and greater state intervention’. Over the course of the twentieth century, two other important groups, the national-conservative intellectuals and the army, were most influenced by nationalist thought, contributing to the ‘core of ideas that coalesced around the development of a national capitalism and of industrialization’ (pp. xix–xxi).
Brennan and Rougier accurately depict the dearth of Peronist studies that juggle the concept of economic nationalism and the evolving roles of numerous politicised groups. To fill the lacunae, the authors combine their research specialism and divide the writing of the chapters to examine business organisations, the metalworking industry, public policy, the financial system, and specific firms and organisations. The reader should appreciate the details and clarification of the political contradictions in play and the numerous associations that appeared and disappeared between 1943 and 1976.
One of the most interesting aspects of the book is its analysis of the complicated and tenuous connection between the state and two groups, the CGE and CAIM. Perón and his administrations initially hoped to fulfil the dream of the national capitalist project, but such dreams were thwarted from the beginning as the relationships between the Peronist government, CGE and CAIM evolved into codependency. In other words, the state sought support from these groups to stay in power and keep its agenda, while the groups knew their importance within the government and over time increasingly sought government support to help sustain inefficient sectors of manufacturing and industry. Most requests, such as those for higher tariffs and/or subsidies, were made in the name of economic nationalism and national self-sufficiency (for instance, CAIM was important because the government needed a self-sufficient metallurgical sector to produce for war and domestic purposes). The outcome was a de facto codependent relationship: the government and groups developed and repeated patterns that were not conducive to promoting long-term productivity and economic development.
A key issue that comes to light as one progresses through the chapters is that of the frequent stalemates and paralyses that emerged in the negotiations between the state and different groups. The authors reflect that Argentina's failure to modernise its industrial economy ‘seems more the result of the failure to create an appropriate institutional environment and inconsistency and unpredictability of economy policies’ (p. 201). New laws were passed, but they seemed to shadow previous legislation that focused on short-term objectives.
This is a seminal work that should be read by current and future researchers of Peronism and of post-war Argentine economic and political history. The authors have left areas to be examined further, however – for instance, the work does not elaborate on the agricultural economy, and the reader should note that this work largely examines economic nationalism and the industrial economy in the post-war period. As the authors highlight, the unstable environment of post-war Argentine politics and economy cannot be easily categorised, thus opening a door for future researchers.
