In this new book, J. Ricardo Tranjan advances a more nuanced, historically attuned understanding of the conditions that accompanied the rise of participatory innovations in Brazil in the 1990s, including Porto Alegre's iconic participatory budgeting process. Rather than trace back such innovations to the ‘defiant’ (p. 223) activities of civil society groups and the then emergent Workers’ Party, following Brazil's democratic transition in the mid-1980s, the book draws a much longer historical arc to account for their origins. Brazil's contemporary participatory innovations, according to the author, are much better understood as constituting the latter phase of a series of political changes since the 1930s, whereby the country's excluded classes sought greater political inclusion amid growing cleavages in Brazil's ruling political elite. In the 1980s, such radical political ideas had to adapt to the return of representative institutions, leading to the moderation of efforts to realise participatory democracy.
To support his argument, Tranjan weaves together an innovative analytical framework that combines structuralist and institutional accounts of democratisation, highlighting the salient socio-economic and institutional changes at the national level that triggered the reconfiguration of Brazilian politics. Drawing on a long line of scholars working in this tradition, the author highlights the pivotal role of industrialisation and urbanisation in undermining the hegemony of Brazil's traditional politico-economic elites, leading to the growth of other social forces that increasingly challenged existing political arrangements. Beginning in the Vargas era of the 1930s up to mid-60s, such dynamics gradually nudged Brazil's political arrangements towards what Tranjan, drawing on the work of Douglass North and his co-authors, calls an ‘open access order’ (Douglass North, John Wallis and Barry Weingast, Violence and Social Orders: A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Recorded Human History, Cambridge University Press, 2009), as sections of the working classes obtained limited social and political rights under populist regimes. To further illustrate the democratising impact of socio-economic changes, Tranjan zeroes in on three relatively little-known municipalities in Brazil where local participatory administrations gained power as early as the 1970s and early 1980s. These are Lages in the state of Santa Catarina; Boa Esperança in the state of Espírito Santo; and Diadema in the state of São Paulo.
The author's claim that socio-economic changes were critical to ushering in political transformations is an important one, given that these factors have received relatively little attention in accounting for participatory democracy in Brazil. By examining how they generated new social forces supportive of broader political participation in the three municipalities, the study carves out a novel theoretical path. The book, however, elaborates this core argument somewhat unevenly. Of the three cases, the discussion on Lages provides the more convincing illustration of the impact of changing socio-economic conditions on the reconfiguration of local politics. In this case, the author insightfully explores how the emergence of a thriving logging and lumber economy weakened the old landed and ranch-owning elite, increasing the ranks of waged workers who, unlike the peons and tenants of earlier times, were ‘relatively independent from patrons’ (p. 101). Amid this weakening of the old elite and heightened competition for the support of subordinate but less captive classes, a political and ideological space conducive to the elaboration of more progressive visions opened up. In this context, Dirceu Carneiro, a long-time activist of the Movimento Democrático Brasileiro (Brazilian Democratic Movement, MDB), the mainstream opposition party under the military regime, contested and won the mayorship in 1976. The Carneiro administration in Lages pursued some of the earliest participatory governance initiatives in Brazil.
In the case of Boa Esperança and Diadema, however, the mechanisms that linked the changing socio-economic conditions to the emergence of participatory local governments are not as fleshed out. For instance, while the author shows how the military regime's industrialisation policies further marginalised small agriculture in Boa Esperança, it is less clear as to how this may have contributed to the election as mayor of Amaro Covre, who first led the participatory administration in 1971, and then again in 1978–82, the period under study. While the book explores how the Covre administration successfully tapped into the existing network of Christian Base Communities to implement innovative programmes, it does not explain how Covre won power in the first place, in a rural town that was ‘decaying’ due to increased out-migration. Perhaps the plight of small farmers generated a constituency for non-elite municipal politicians like Covre who promised greater socio-economic inclusion; the victory of coalitions supporting small farmers in previous state-level elections, as narrated in the book, suggests this picture. But if this were the case, elaborating such connections could have strengthened the book's claims.
The same is true with the case of Diadema, where Gilson Menezes of the Workers’ Party won the mayorship in 1982. Although the book underscores the exponential growth of an impoverished working class in Diadema due to the military regime's national industrialisation policies, how such changes contributed to the victory of an emergent party that articulated a participatory vision is, again, less clearly elaborated. The suggested link, as discussed partly in Chapters 2 and 7, is the ‘new unionism movement’ which emerged in Diadema and other burgeoning working-class communities in São Paulo, and whose activists eventually constituted the core of the Workers’ Party. In this context of authoritarian-led industrialisation, carefully unpacking the connections between the ‘new unionism movement’ and the rise of Menezes’ participatory administration could have better demonstrated how socio-economic changes stirred up political transformations.
Despite these caveats, the book contributes much to our understanding of the dynamics of political change in Brazil. The historical discussion of how interlocking, often family-based elites sustained themselves in power in Santa Catarina, Espírito Santo and São Paulo is rich, and sheds much-needed light on the regional and local dynamics of political and social exclusion in the country. Although other analysts have previously highlighted the limited political inclusion that occurred under Brazil's populist regimes, the book insightfully recasts its historical significance, underscoring it as a nodal point in the rise of decidedly more radical claims for democratic participation. The book is also impressive in piecing together little-known details of the civil society networks and local participatory administrations of the 1970s and early 1980s, unearthing their efforts to push the limits of authoritarian politics via their embryonic participatory initiatives. For all this and more, Participatory Democracy in Brazil deserves to be widely read.
