The time has passed when most people saw war as a romantic quest, or even a patriotic duty. Wars are brutal, often vicious, affairs. With the centenary observance of World War I – arguably the most hellish of all wars – well under way, we will likely be reminded of this stark truth frequently and graphically over the next four years.
In that respect, the American Civil War, often pointed to as a precursor of “modern” warfare, cannot hold a candle to the Great War. Yet, as Michael C. C. Adams, a retired professor of history at the University of Northern Kentucky, reminds us, the American conflict had its “dark side,” too. Acknowledging that other authors have already explored most of the frayed threads of that “bleak war” – the shock of combat, the agonies of the wounded, the terrors of the home front – Adams wants to pull together “all the strands into one large tapestry” (5). In a narrative that alternates between past and present tense when describing events of the 1860s, he invites readers to explore with him “the pains, the fears, and the blighted lives” of the war's victims (4). He offers no revelations or new discoveries, a point underscored by his exclusive reliance on published sources, but then Adams has fashioned this work for a general audience, rather than a scholarly one.
He writes mostly about the soldiers, and as we follow them down the “dirty, dusty road of war” (12) it becomes clear how an inadequate diet, widespread sickness and disease, harsh discipline, the experience of combat, post-traumatic stress, and the loneliness of men far from home could have bred hardships and despondency. Civilians – mostly southerners, black and white – enter the story primarily through their interaction with the armies. The darkness of their war included shortages of food, destruction of property, breakdown of societal order, rituals of mourning, sexual assault, and homeless wandering as refugees.
By rights, this catalogue of grief should shock and dismay us, so it is rather disconcerting to think that many readers will be little moved by it all. Much of what Adams describes has become so commonplace in modern wars, and is portrayed so vividly and with such immediacy on television and social media, that our response to the brooding darkness that enveloped people's lives in the 1860s has become more one of curiosity than of empathy. It is also hard to consider some of the topics examined by Adams as “dark,” even in the context of the 1860s. For instance, military conscription and resistance to it may have aroused public ire and sharpened political debate, but they do not qualify as part of a “living hell.” Likewise, desertion may have been caused by the conditions of service, but those conditions were not necessarily dire or unrelentingly bleak.
Then, too, Adams might have pulled us more deeply into the hellish darkness. He does his best, as when describing the corpse of a sixteen-year-old soldier so riddled by bullets that it looked “as red as if he had been dipped in a barrel of blood” (66). Yet such passages are mere snapshots of horror. One never quite feels the agony of it all; we are not sufficiently submersed in human suffering to experience the savagery of war. Sometimes Adams simply misses a good opportunity. His section on prisoners of war, for instance, which one would think ripe with possibilities, is only four pages long. And returning to the notion of snapshots, the book lacks illustrations of any kind.
Interestingly, Adams's two concluding chapters, on the legacy of the war, show how relatively soon participants forgot this dark side. Of course, some veterans carried physical and emotional scars for years, even decades, after the conflict, another dimension of war known all too well in the twenty-first century. Yet the nation as a whole soon rebounded from the economic destruction of the 1860s, and as political reconciliation allowed northerners and southerners to join forces in the next war, against Spain in 1898, the battles of 1861–65 acquired a nostalgic glow.
Adams starts to meander at this point, with an eclectic narrative that includes the battle of the Little Bighorn and the election of Barack Obama as President. The diversions reinforce the feeling that, while he has written a useful summary of the perils of war, Adams has also shown the difficulties of capturing its grisly nature.
