There's not much pleasing Andrew Delbanco. Having criticized us in previous books for not being understanding of the Puritans and then for losing our sense of evil, the real American dream, and higher education's true virtues, he now goes after some of the few heroes left: the abolitionists. It seems that they were more Puritan than the Puritans, and lacked the liberal imagination that his predecessor at Columbia University, Lionel Trilling, celebrated.
Delbanco provides a stimulating rehearsal of the ups and downs of the abolitionists in the American imagination, and then a tantalizingly brief account of Hawthorne and Melville's ambivalence about them, where we see him at his best: performing a historically informed literary criticism. But this is really only a (fifty-five-page) essay, he reminds us in an aside no doubt added after the four responses were collected for the book. All he can do is state that simple answers to the question what the abolitionists should mean to us ought to be avoided. They had tremendous impact, they shook the culture from its complacency, but they raise the question “how much blood for how much good?”
Why Delbanco thinks that the often peace-loving abolitionists, only a few of whom called for a civil war at any point, ought to be blamed for the events of 1861–65 is unclear; he seems disturbingly unaware of who pioneered the notion that abolitionist demands for an end to slavery would lead to violence (that is, slaveholders), or even the debate among abolitionists about violent means, a main theme of their literature and still a present one in the historical scholarship. Perhaps he has noticed the recent tendency to equate abolition with the Civil War, for which he rightly wags a finger at James McPherson and the dominance in the field of McPherson's synthesis, Battle Cry of Freedom (1988). Or perhaps he is looking for an unpredictable way to criticize American arrogance and interventionism abroad, as some asides suggest. In any case, as John Stauffer and Manisha Sinha make clear in their hard-hitting responses, Delbanco hasn't done his homework in the recent historiography on the abolitionists and on anti-slavery and pro-slavery politics.
In other words, this book shouldn't exist as a book; it should have been a journal roundtable at best (and I certainly would not have published it in the journal I edit). Particularly disturbing is the comparison of the abolitionists to contemporary evangelical activists without grappling with James Brewer Stewart's important essay on the topic in the Journal of the Early Republic (Spring 2006), reprinted in his obviously relevant but uncited collection of essays, Abolitionist Politics and the Coming of the Civil War (2008). Sinha and Stauffer's essays are really what is worth the price of admission here, for they make it clear what is at stake in re-creating the mid-twentieth-century (if not nineteenth-century) blaming of the critics (if not the victims). Even the higher-law thinking that Delbanco critiques was arguably first, or at least simultaneously, adumbrated by pro-slavery types. Abolitionists were circumspect, tactically speaking, and have been criticized often for being so – though such relative moderation and patience may have been a source of their ultimate success.
Novelist and critic Darryl Pinckney offers an intriguing response that basically riffs on Benjamin Quarles's Black Abolitionists (1969), making it clear that Delbanco never consulted this or any of Quarles's other work that laid the foundation for considering the centrality of African Americans and their desires and actions to the history and the culture. By contrast, intellectual historian Wilfrid McClay is quite taken with Delbanco's abstraction of “abolitionism as a master concept,” a figure for a certain way of thinking, because it seems to serve his agenda of giving evangelical religion credit for anti-slavery. “No religion, no abolitionism: it is that simple.” Really? How about “no religion, no pro-slavery argument,” as a range of southern historians from Drew Faust to Eugene Genovese to Stephanie McCurry have made clear?
The value of this volume is in its provocation to thought, and its confirmation of abolition's relevance to big questions about American culture and politics. But there is too much unrigorous equation of art and politics and religion. Invoking “style,” as Delbanco does in his conclusion, is not sufficient to get out of the problems of lumping, and evasion of political and social context, that occur here, and which Sinha and Stauffer can only do so much to address.
