This is a superb book. Not only does it give a broad overview of the different Wahhabi or Salafi currents in Saudi Arabia—the official Wahhabi establishment, the reformist Sahwa movement and the jihadists—providing a penetrating analysis of the debates between these currents, but also it withstands the easy condemnation of jihadists as terrorists. By trying to understand jihad as the outcome of the political situation in Saudi Arabia and the logical conclusion of Wahhabism and analyzing it on its own terms, this is also a courageous book.
Al-Rasheed regards “Wahhabiyya in the twenty-first century as a contested intellectual, religious and political field, which is currently appropriated by several actors” (p. 12). Deconstructing Western clichés of Salafism as static and antimodern, Al-Rasheed analyzes it as an ongoing intellectual debate on political and social issues, which during the past few decades has moved on to modern questions such as increasing political participation, social justice, the rights of women and minorities, and freedom of speech.
At the center of this highly dynamic debate is the relationship between politics and religion. In contrast to another cliché that Al-Rasheed demolishes, the two are not unified in Saudi Arabia. Part of the major contradiction Saudi Arabia suffers from is the fact that the state has appropriated the domain of foreign and internal policy and the economy and has thoroughly secularized them. In return for developing a discourse of consent and sanctioning the state's policies, even if they blatantly contradict its professed role as guardian of the Islamic umma, the co-opted and totally controlled official Wahhabi ʿulemaʾ have been assigned the task of Islamizing and subduing society with a nonpolitical ideology. As a result, a political–religious system emerged that “disenfranchised society” and “disenchanted politics” (p. 59).
Al-Rasheed does not mince her words when it comes to laying responsibility for the repression and violence that has been the result of this contradiction. “State control of Wahhabiyya was directly proportionate to the violence that erupted” (p. 25), and “violence in Saudi Arabia in the twenty-first century is the outcome of contradictions in religious discourse” (p. 36). The authority of the Al Saʿud became contested when a better-educated generation became politically aware in the 1980s. “For this generation, the dramatised ritualistic Islam was simply not enough” (p. 65). The main aim of the reformist Sahwa movement, which arose in the 1990s and was led by this generation, was to “re-enchant a politically dis-enchanted world” (p. 66).
Based on the belief that “ordinary man can be at the centre of his destiny” (p. 66), the Sahwa movement tried to mobilize the increasing resistance to the authoritarian state. Al-Rasheed's main focus, however, is on its failure to carry out its program after 9/11 and the bomb attacks of Saudi jihadists on foreign residential compounds in 2003–04. By acting as an intermediary between the state and the jihadists, the Sahwa movement compromised its reformist ideals and succumbed to the enormous pressure by the state to disavow jihad. As a result, it not only toned down its critique of the regime but it also “moved from blaming the regime for the ills of society to blaming society itself, as a way out of the dilemma” (p. 96). Like the establishment ʿulamaʾ, the Sahwa leaders focused their attention on social issues, formulating a conservative program about the rights of women and minorities against foreign interference.
From that moment on, the baton for change was in the hands of the jihadists, who became the only true reformers of Saudi society. According to Al-Rasheed, Salafi jihad is a “logical outcome” of both official Wahhabism, with its intolerance of non-Wahhabi Islam and foreigners, promoting religious war outside Saudi Arabia, and of the failure of the leaders of the Sahwa movement, who shied away from armed resistance against a regime they criticized in religious terms but were afraid to condemn as based on unbelief (kufr). Afghanistan was the catalyst that empowered Salafi jihad and gave its adherents the necessary self-confidence to direct their struggle against the regime. In the end, Saudi Afghans “turned the original Wahhabi discourse against those who initially sponsored and promoted it worldwide” (p. 121).
Al-Rasheed therefore contends that “one cannot argue that Jihadism in Saudi Arabia is an alien intellectual trend imported from other Islamist movements and locations” (p. 136), as the Saudi state does. Rather she analyses jihadist violence as a cultural expression that has indigenous roots and grows in a local context. Above all, Al-Rasheed regards it as a means of self-assertion: it is “a belief in one's ability to change the world by action” (p. 137). In this capacity the “Jihadis began to see themselves as the real heirs of Sahwa, carrying its banner of reform and revolution, while those left behind or who failed to join them, both physically and intellectually, are labelled qaʿidūn” [those who sit and not refuse to participate in activism] (p. 138). Most of the rest of her book is taken up with a fascinating analysis of the works and Internet exchanges of several jihadist intellectuals such as the “takfīrī” thinker Nasir al-Fahad and Lewis Atiyyat Allah. Atiyya, who was well versed in both Western and Salafi traditions, especially gives one a completely different view into jihadist background and highlights its intellectual dimension.
Because of the breadth and depth of this book, the extensive research of Internet sources, its clear organization and sound scholarship, this work is recommended reading for specialists on Saudi Arabia, as well as anyone who is interested in the Salafi movement in general, or even, because of the book's political–philosophical dimension, Islamist movements in broader context. As every rich book does, it offers many strands for further analysis. Al-Rasheed's recurring remark that Wahhabi discourse was “prematurely transnationalised” (p. 258) is intriguing, as well as her designation of the jihadists as revolutionaries. Rare for an academic study, it is also a passionate work, which greatly enhances its readability and impact.
