Given the relative shortage of primary source materials stemming from medieval or premodern histories, in addition to the mere investigation into written documents, a little bit more imagination is usually required for a medieval or premodern historian. In this book, Don J. Wyatt admirably demonstrates a capability to present the previously untold story of the earliest Chinese encounters with black people, with a combination of both historical imagination and consultation of a comparatively limited body of Chinese primary source materials. The first part of the book aims at answering the key question of when a Chinese consciousness of ‘black peoples’ (kunlun) first arose. The answer to this question is crucial, as, according to Wyatt, the making of such a consciousness elucidates the incremental emergence of the traditional Chinese construction of ‘otherness’, including the much lesser known ‘blackness’. Wyatt argues convincingly that a distinguishing feature of Chinese civilisation is that the place of origin or habitat has consistently predominated over skin colour as a marker of foreignness and hence otherness. Historically, much as is still the case, distinguishing the ‘other’ was a process marked first by construing that the ‘other’ in question necessarily hailed, at least originally, from a different place. By sifting through ancient Chinese classics and documentations, the author clearly demonstrates that, at least in prehistoric and earliest historical times, the skin colours of the different peoples with which the Chinese interacted only varied within a fairly narrow range. In other words, limited in their contacts largely by geographical constraints and barriers, the ancient Chinese tended to meet others who were not that dramatically different, in terms of the physical feature of skin pigmentation, from themselves. Relative geographical isolation as well as other constrictive factors in comparison to other major world civilisations would not change this situation for China and its inhabitants for a substantial length of time. As such, the exposure of Chinese from earliest historical times only to peoples not drastically differing from themselves, in terms of skin colour, stands as one of the very few myths of an ‘unchanging China’ that evinces any credibility.
In the second part of the book, the focus is on a seemingly trivial incident happening in the southern port city of Guangzhou in 684 A.D. A Tang Dynasty civilian official named Lu Yuanrui was killed by a black in Guangzhou, when the former tried to cheat a group of black merchants out of their goods. Lu's murder, as Wyatt depicts, comprises the earliest and least equivocal historical documentation of the undercurrents, tensions and occasional outright enmity that had evolved to become a fixture of Chinese-kunlun relations. Using this episode as a starting point, the author starts constructing his arguments, providing us with three interesting historical factors that deserve our careful reconsideration. The first factor is the localisation, or even confinement, of this particular set of blacks exclusively to the southeast coastal city of Guangzhou. The second factor is their invariant status as slaves. And the third is the stunning revelation of the ethnogenesis (the formation as an ethnic group) of these slaves as having derived from their original homeland in Africa. These discoveries apprise us of yet another aspect of the dark and tragic intersections between early-world interstate-commerce and the social construction of enslavement. Consequently, the historian in each of us compels and obligates us to uncover as much about the black slaves of Guangzhou as we can. However, as the author argues, not even the compulsions of the historian can diminish the fact that much mystery will always continue to attend the Guangzhou black slaves.
In the final part of the book, Wyatt directs us to what is probably the most expected, and yet least explored, venue for premodern China's blacks, who, as historical evidence now suggests, were originally from East Africa. This occasion for Africa as venue for the consequential interaction between Chinese and Africans was afforded entirely by the unprecedented voyage embarked on to this and other Indian Ocean lands under Chinese imperial commission between the year 1405 and 1433. However the voyages themselves have commanded greater sway over the attention of scholars than any encounter between the Chinese and a single people or collection of peoples resulting from them. The author endeavours to rectify this received knowledge by focusing exclusively on the encounter between the Chinese and the Africans. One important fresh argument raised here is that the visitation of African lands by the prominent Ming Dynasty eunuch Zheng He's celestial fleet in the early fifteenth century represents merely one relatively minor installment among the major milestones that the audacious venture achieved, and it is therefore fitting that we should view it proportionally within the enormous scope of the expeditionary enterprise taken as a whole. We cannot know today with certainty whether Zheng He's landing in East Africa was a planned or unintentional undertaking. Nevertheless, following that fateful landfall, with respect to the blacks among them, the Chinese at the close of the Ming Dynasty in the mid-seventeenth century had become irrevocably robbed of their former comfort zone of ignorance. By the time the Portuguese, the Spanish and the Italians arrived in China, the presence of the black slaves of these Europeans became known to the Chinese only through sketchy mentions of black bondservants. In succession, the author argues, the Chinese people's literal and figurative collision with Africa had changed everything, as they were forcefully stripped of an ancient archetype and diverted from being able to refer either to the quasi-bestial kunlun or their once-mythogeographical habitat of Kunlun Mountain in Central Asia with the same safe insularity of the knowledge of past times. This was despite the fact that the story of these late premodern blacks, labouring anonymously in China under their new European masters, is but a more familiar extension of the previously unknown story of their ancestors who toiled in Chinese servitude perhaps more than a millennium earlier.
The Blacks of Premodern China is a fair and fine work, and doubtlessly a welcome addition to the existing literature on premodern China and the world history. Despite the fragmentary, impressionistic and inconclusive nature of historical evidence that the author claims to have struggled to piece together, the findings are remarkable. He should be thanked for making a great effort and providing us with a hitherto unexamined story of the unusual encounters between premodern China and African blacks.
