In The One and the Many, contemporary art historian Grant H. Kester argues that the growing interest in collaborative work represents a paradigm shift in the theory and practice of contemporary art. This shift has ontological, epistemological, and hermeneutic implications for art historiography. First, given the apparent permeability between art production and activism, what is art at this historical moment? Second, what forms of knowledge do such practices generate? With this question Kester attempts to overcome what he perceives as a problem of current art criticism that depicts the destabilization of the viewer as inherently valuable. Third, when dialogical processes are part and parcel of the work of art, the critic must “employ techniques (field research, participant-observation, interviews, etc.) more typically associated with the social sciences” (10). Kester deploys all of these methods to demonstrate convincingly how recent collaborative art practices test the hegemony of both an aesthetics of disruption and the poststructuralist theory undergirding it.
In the book's first chapter, “Autonomy, Antagonism, and the Aesthetic,” Kester identifies a common thread between German Romantic aesthetic philosophy (particularly Schiller's 1794 On the Aesthetic Education of Man) and a persistent tenet of poststructuralist thought: a retreat from the transformation of existing political institutions to a transformation of the self. Following the terrors of the French Revolution and the perceived failure of May 1968, respectively, aesthetic autonomy guaranteed insulation from “irredeemably compromised” (46) systems of power and resistance. Of course, “this tradition has foreclosed the possibility that social interaction or political engagement itself might transform subjectivity or produce its own forms of insight. Instead, we must endlessly prepare our subjectivities for political action through a deferred aesthetic reeducation” (59). Such a theoretical framework favors what Kester calls a “‘textual’ mode” of artistic production (7–8) in which an artist conceives of a work of art, be it object or event, which then supposedly activates, destabilizes, and/or distances the viewer. Kester rightly notes that this ubiquitous aesthetic stance ascribes all creative insight to the artist and scripts the viewer's response in advance. He contrasts textual art production with recent collaborative work in which artists surrender some of their autonomy.
In Chapter 2, “The Genius of the Place,” Kester argues that recent collaborative art projects in rural areas of the Global South propose alternatives to the generalization of bourgeois subjectivity represented by prevailing development discourse. Bourgeois subjectivity depends on the individual's ability to manipulate the external world for personal gain. Thus the bourgeois subject is not autonomous but depends on the labor of others and the supply of raw materials. Development discourse “entails the anthropomorphic projection of . . . bourgeois subjectivity onto entire cultures and countries. Thus, the ‘undeveloped’ nation or culture, like the poor or working-class subject, has failed the test of modernity” (117–18). NGOs that would see entire nations lift themselves out of poverty through plucky entrepreneurship demonstrate a terror of dependency stemming from the inherent heteronomy of bourgeois subjectivity. For Kester, it is not sufficient to reveal or deconstruct our relational identity. Following this revelation we must then work to “mitigate violence and objectification in our ongoing encounters with difference” (111). As one example, the Dialogue collective conducted workshops with Adivasi tribal communities in central India to design and construct enclosures for village water pumps. These enclosures ease the labor of village women and afford them a place to gather, shielded from men's surveillance. Kester argues that the goal of this kind of art practice is not to produce “some ideal and unconstrained model of community, but rather to make the negotiation and the ‘working through’ of difference an explicit part” of the work (95). Crucially, the artists did not arrive in central India planning to build water pump enclosures; this idea emerged from the series of local workshops. In Kester's estimation the sequential unfolding of the work gestures toward a relational and site-specific mode of knowing that challenges the mastery imposed on the external world by the bourgeois subject.
The book's third and final chapter, “Eminent Domain: Art and Urban Space,” turns—as its title suggests—from rural to urban space, examining the messy work of generating alternatives to gentrification schemes. In Houston's Third Ward, for instance, Project Row Houses transformed a block of houses slated for demolition into artists' residences that became the site of a mentoring program for local children. Urban regeneration relies on the rhetoric of urban blight, a discursive process “that allows developers to create an implicit linkage between the physical or material decline of a given community . . . and the character of its inhabitants, whose removal or displacement is thereby rendered less objectionable” (218). Project Row Houses sought to help the Third Ward overcome this discursive rescripting by linking the Third Ward to its cultural and architectural history and its traditions of mutual assistance. Kester sees in this and similar projects an attempt to define community diachronically as “a series of relational encounters that require the ongoing negotiation of difference as well as identity” (222). This is the book's Deleuzian remainder; Kester criticizes (rightly) the language of flows as an extension of neoliberalism, but he is indebted to Deleuze in his understanding of identity as an open-ended process of becoming. I do not see this as contradictory. Throughout the book, Kester acknowledges the value of poststructuralist criticism while ensuring that it, too, is subjected to the destabilization it would see inflicted on a viewer of contemporary art. Kester denaturalizes poststructuralism without dismissing it wholesale.
Ultimately, though the book suffers from some problems of organization (Chapter 2 stretches to nearly 90 pages) and style (the word “symptomatic” becomes worn from overuse), The One and the Many is an important contribution to scholarly dialogue on the political efficacy of collaborative art. Astutely historicized and deftly theorized, it makes an excellent companion to recent work by Shannon Jackson and others who inhabit the fruitful border regions between art history and performance scholarship.
