No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Apostasy (ridda), meaning renunciation of Islam and adoption of another faith system, is one of the most contentious issues across the Muslim world today. Abdullah Saeed and Hassan Saeed join the fray from a strongly held and variously expressed secular and liberal perspective in that religion is unequivocally regarded as a “covenant between an individual and God” (p. 172). Fully conscious of the tensions and sharp contradictions that exist between this modern Western perspective and the Islamic worldview in accordance with which all schools of Muslim thought and jurisprudence—whether Sunni, Shi

i, or Ibadi—have traditionally seen and experienced their faith as a sociopolitical bond as well as a system of ethical and spiritual teachings and beliefs, Saeed and Saeed nevertheless try to build a case for a radical rethinking of the apostasy laws whereby Muslims have traditionally endeavored to defend the security and political integrity of their community (umma) as well as its ethical values and spiritual beliefs.
The two authors divide their subject into three parts. The first consists of eight chapters briefly surveying the historical context of the apostasy debate, the development of apostasy laws as part of Islamic law and jurisprudence, and the views of some contemporary Muslim thinkers on the subject. The second part, consisting of four chapters, reviews Malaysia's experience as a case study. Chapter 13, which constitutes the third part of the book, summarizes the authors' case for the need to rethink apostasy laws with a view to bringing them in line with secular liberal values and principles.
As has often been observed in this drawn-out debate, opinions are frequently polarized between two sharply opposed and staunchly held points of view. Instead of patiently and systematically building a factually accurate and logically consistent argument, Saeed and Saeed exaggerate—sometimes even caricature—what seem to them to be weaknesses of their adversaries' case while ignoring facts and evidence that do not fit theirs. One example of this is Saeed and Saeed's consistently dismissing the sunna as a source of legislation in Islam, another point on which all Muslim schools of thought—whether Sunni, Shi

i, or Ibadi—have been in full and well-founded agreement. Not only does the Qur

an itself repeatedly call on Muslims to obey the Prophet and follow his example and directives, but some of the most basic duties of Muslims—including prayers, fasting, haj, and zakat—are inconceivable without the sunna and Prophetic directives. What the Prophet says about other aspects of Islam—including the treatment of apostates and prisoners of war, for example—cannot therefore be simply ignored or wished away.
Another point on which the two authors base their argument is that almost all Muslim countries today are multireligious societies, whereas Muslims, Saeed and Saeed allege, evidently believe that all Muslims must reside in a dār al-islām that accommodates only Muslims (p. 170). It is hardly necessary to point out that Muslim states and societies—beginning with the very first one established by Prophet Muhammad in Medina—have almost always been multireligious and multiethnic. As Adam Mez stated many years ago, the first and most striking feature that distinguished traditional Muslim societies from Christian medieval Europe is that within the borders of the former lived people of many faiths, and all these peoples, as Mez put it, lived “side by side in an atmosphere of tolerance absolutely unknown to Medieval Europe.” Writing some two centuries earlier than Mez, John Locke not only pointed out the same fact in his classic Letter Concerning Toleration, but he held it up as an example for his contemporaries to emulate.
Saeed and Saeed, citing writings and utterances of modern Muslims from Muhammad Abduh to Shaykh Yusuf al-Qaradawi to Rashid al-Ghannushi, try to give the impression that all these thinkers are more or less in full agreement with the two authors' point of view. In a similar vein, Saeed and Saeed discuss nominal or “cultural” Muslims who have only a minimal affiliation with Islam and jump to the conclusion on the next page that they are akin to apostates “if not actually apostates” (p. 172).
The book also contains a number of factual errors, such as the statement that the Kharijites and Shi

is were intent on reviling leading figures of the early Muslim community, “including the first four caliphs” (p. 39). It can generally be concluded that the book—far from providing a coherent and convincing argument for the two authors' point of view—can at best be regarded as yet another example of the contentious and not altogether accurate debate for and against apostasy laws that goes on in many parts of the world today.