Ascribing to the discipline of political science a disengagement from “sustained reflection on teaching and learning” (1), William W. Sokoloff sets out to “place contention and controversy at the center of political science through critical reflection on the politics of pedagogy” (3). Specifically, he argues that critical theory has been invisible in the pedagogical literature in the discipline and thus he seeks to create a pedagogy he deems “critical, radical, and utopian” in nature. For Sokoloff, to be critical is to challenge the status quo, “expose the limits of the practices we take as given and natural” (14); to be radical is to “expand our political horizons beyond the parameters of the status quo” (17); and to be utopian is not to search for perfection but “to experiment and innovate beyond the current horizons of cruelty intrinsic to neoliberal authoritarian politics, socialism for the non-working rich and transfer of wealth upward via theft of public funds and taxbreaks for billionaires” (19).
Sokoloff argues that his book challenges political science through the lens of political theory to evaluate our blinders and consider how our pedagogical assumptions are inherently conservative, upholding the political status quo; instead, he encourages the discipline to advance a radical pedagogy that upends the “authority, hierarchy, and knowledge nexus” it currently endorses. To do this, the book links together six chapters that address a wide variety of topics and critical theorists.
The chapters seem to have been written at different times and for different purposes, but the author attempts to weave them together as a call for action—political scientists “working for radical democratic ends and [to] shatter the authority, hierarchy and knowledge nexus” (128). Chapter 2 discusses Sheldon S. Wolin and Leo Strauss not only in terms of their distinct perspectives but in their shared flawed view of the political theorist who interprets theory as authority and then as transmitting that knowledge to the next generation as pedagogy. Chapter 3 critiques the Socratic method as abusive, authoritarian, and antidemocratic. Chapter 4 embraces experiential learning—although Sokoloff does not label it such or connect to this deep strand of literature in the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL)—by recalling a field trip he took his students to visit a local prison. Chapter 5 examines the “subversive pedagogy” of Frantz Fanon, connecting his anticolonialism resistance to the NFL protests of 2016–2017. Chapter 6 discusses the value of online education for Hispanic-Serving Institutions, such as Sokoloff's university, and shows how he adapted an introduction to political theory to an online format. The penultimate chapter explores the pedagogy of Paulo Friere and his contributions to the ideal of critical pedagogy where students are central and develop their own political awareness. Finally, chapter 8 engages the nature of silence in the classroom and the difficulty of engaging students in discussion, especially those for whom intersectional oppression has conveyed a message that their views are less significant.
The challenge that Sokoloff brings to the discipline could have been powerful. It is easy in any discipline to comfortably replicate the values and context of a past age without questioning the limitations of a constructed body of knowledge and set of skills. However, the tone of this book and Sokoloff's editorial choices undermine this laudable goal and instead indicate that the author is writing for those who agree with him and wish to celebrate their own pedagogical priorities. The political scientists to whom he reacts are unnamed colleagues who seem to represent a caricature of the arrogant professor of the not-so-distant past, caring more for their own prestige than student learning. Instead of engaging with the contemporary SoTL literature both within and outside of the discipline, he references his past attendance at the American Political Science Association Teaching and Learning conference and an undated search on “radical pedagogy” in the two disciplinary journals that have a focus on teaching as evidence of disciplinary disengagement. He ignores the established disciplinary dives into civic engagement (McCartney, Bennion, and Simpson, eds., Teaching Civic Engagement: From Student to Active Citizen [American Political Science Association, 2013]) and assessment of learning (Deardorff, Ishiyama, and Hamann, eds., Assessment in Political Science [American Political Science Association, 2007]), instead relying on decade-old surveys of US government textbooks demonstrating their lack of diversity. Finally, rather than challenging his colleagues to think more critically of their pedagogy and classroom choices, he ridicules them. To take only one instance, “I would bet that if you asked a random political scientist at the APSA annual meeting if they read Freire's work on the political significance of pedagogy and practiced it, you would observe a blank stare” (149). The tone is unfortunate. As someone who generally agrees with his pedagogical priorities and who could pass this litmus test prior to reading his book, I found his dismissive tone so undermining of his stated objectives that I fear this work will not have the impact it should have on the discipline.
Sokoloff's emphasis on Freirean praxis, or the application of knowledge to what is personally known, is undermined also by his dated examples and assumptions. Many of his examples are from the Obama administration, the most recent being from 2016. This is problematic, because Sokoloff battles old demons and does not engage in current, more subtle challenges. He assumes a “post-racial” world where “the dialogue around race seems stuck and going nowhere” (83); this national dialogue changed dramatically during the Trump administration. Another chapter reflects an assumption, namely, that there is an immense resistance to the value of online education, but this debate and SoTL scholarship (including in political science) has been shifting over the last decade, with certifications like Quality Matters and extensive research undermining the claim that online education is inherently less effective, none of which is referenced. Feminist pedagogy does not exist in this book—with its similar reliance on critical theory—nor does recent research on decolonializing the curriculum. Sokoloff faces backwards instead of engaging current trends and persuading the oblivious along.
Finally, the author builds straw arguments that he ably dismisses. A more exciting version of this volume would engage in ongoing debates around experiential learning, pedagogy, and critical theory. In this text, the high-impact practices of George Kuh (High-Impact Educational Practices: What They Are, Who Has Access to Them, and Why They Matter [Association of American Colleges and Universities, 2008]) do not exist nor does the explosive SoTL literature that preceded and followed it. Sokoloff assumes that all political scientists are still the “sage on the stage,” and he is the “guide on the side” to show the way. In the chapter on the Socratic method, he uses the original Socrates humiliating his victims in The Apology as the model of this ancient pedagogical approach—assuming a Professor Kingsfield from 1973's The Paper Chase as indicative of its contemporary use. This ignores the rich literature on this pedagogical approach as a means of critically engaging students—including in political science (Trepanier, ed., The Socratic Method Today: Student-Centered and Transformative Teaching in Political Science [Routledge, 2007]).
Mostly, I deeply needed to see Sokoloff wrestle with the difference between authority and expertise. Considering the loss of shared reality so aptly demonstrated during the pandemic and the Trump administration, and the loss of trust in science and expertise reflected in the ongoing COVID pandemic, how does a critical pedagogy that engages in “shattering the authority, hierarchy, and knowledge nexus” (172) respond to these new and very different challenges?
