Peace be with you. An anodyne greeting to fellow congregants at Mass. Yet, according to Jehangir Yezdi Malegam, the concept of peace within the medieval church was crucial; peace was the central goal, indeed the raison d'être of the medieval church. The Sleep of Behemoth is a densely argued polemic that seeks to reexamine the intellectual and political history of the medieval church as a search for peace. Malegam sets out to prove that the peacemaking efforts of medieval churchmen laid the foundation for the modern state, as secular monarchs co-opted the tools of the church to secure the loyalty of subjects either by devotion or force—all in the name of peace.
With a hat tip to Augustine, Malegam sees peace everywhere and nowhere: it might be distorted, disguised, challenged, but broadly defined, so broadly as to encompass nearly every form of Christian practice or belief, peace was the endgame. True peace is in heaven, thus never on Earth, yet the search for peace is all consuming. Thus peace had “shadows and mirror images, some of them faithful approximations, but many, seditious distortions of the original” (12). So, a communion of disobedient priests might offer an illusive peace, a mimicry of an ideal that was, in reality, “violence in its extreme form, imperceptible, and therefore most coercive and manipulative” (12). Obviously heresy and schism come to mind, but this definition also included lay investiture and the urban communes of the twelfth century in which “chains of carnal affection and mercenary friendship replaced the bonds of peace” (12). What was the true Christian to do? Fight, naturally. Thus war and conflict are given new scrutiny by Malegam. Rather than the opposite of peace, they are complementary, often necessary, tools to restore peace. Violence is a distortion of peace that necessitates coercion, indeed, sometimes warfare, to contain it. Violence is understood not as the simple use of armed force but, instead, as a refutation of the “viability of the patron-client relationship and the validity of a would-be patron's claim of advocacy” (39–40). “Peace was not the absence or future abatement of conflict but rather the fighting itself” (6).
Malegam's method refocuses crucial events and texts in medieval church history through the lens of peace and peacemaking, so that rather than the popular view of the medieval period as one of unremitting violence, he sees peace as the underlying purpose of the fighting. The title of the book derives from a twelfth-century text by Rufinus of Sorrento in which he terms a complacent lassitude in the church the “sleep of Behemoth” (3). According to Rufinus, tranquility was no substitute for harmony, nor should subjugation be confused with justice. Rufinus's definition sets up a paradigm for Malegam in which he sees a “medieval discourse around peace” framing the great dualities of the medieval period: empire and church, communes and church, and, perhaps, most fundamentally, spirit versus flesh.
Chapter 1 examines reform movements and the appearance around 1000 of the Peace of God assemblies, seeing them broadly as ambitious attempts to extend clerical responsibilities, protections, and prerogatives, all within the wider purpose of peacemaking.
Papal Reform is the subject of chapter 2. Focusing on Popes Leo IX and Gregory VII, Malegam argues that papal emphasis on a rigid concept of a true peace resulted in “unprecedented radicalism in the tenor of church reform” (56). If Leo was careful to maintain a generally cooperative relationship with the empire, Gregory held out for perfect peace no matter the cost. Gregory's insistence that ecclesiastical and nonecclesiastical sacraments were mutually incompatible set the stage for confrontations regarding lay investiture—and worse. At one point Gregory absolved all Christians from obedience to Henry IV and denied the king any right to govern the empire. Even before becoming pope, Hildebrand-Gregory openly encouraged violent insurrection in northern Italy. For Gregory, according to Malegam, “only the sword would make visible a constant but hidden war between the church and diabolical forces” (73). Malegam's portrayal of the extreme radicalism of the Gregorian reform is significant. Beyond its “well-known attention to sacramental integrity . . . the reformers were targeting not only unlawful celebrants and tainted ceremonies but all sociopolitical bonds that could be a threat to ecclesial liberty” (75). This could not end well for the church in the secular world.
Chapter 3 looks at the lay reform movement in Milan known as the Pataria as a prelude for the Investiture Controversy. While the conflict took place between 1075 and 1110, Malegam traces Gregory's radical resistance to imperial privilege to the writings of St. Cyprian, the hero of the Donatist movement in the early church, which necessitates a lengthy discussion of the often antagonistic relations between the earliest Christians and the Roman Empire. This long digression has the earnest feel of a dissertation chapter. While undoubtedly interesting, the centuries' long chronological distance from the Investiture Controversy renders the discussion more distracting than enlightening. The Pataria focused its efforts against simony and clerical concubinage, the latter an unintended consequence of the prohibition of clerical marriage. The Milanese clergy sought assistance from the emperor, who blundered into the Investiture Controversy by naming a friend of his, rather than a Milanese cleric, archbishop of Milan. Ratcheting up his engagement with opponents of his zealous defense of papal primacy, Gregory seemed to welcome warfare: “Crystallized in the crucible of the Pataria, the Gregorian notion of militant peacemaking matches our normative understanding of ‘violence’” (112).
Chapter 4 examines the communion of Judas Iscariot as an emblem of a false peace. Judas had traded God's body for money and had taken communion, while planning the betrayal of Christ. This duplicity led to earnest debates in the High Middle Ages regarding what Judas had taken at the Last Supper. While a seemingly narrow subject, this debate about the Eucharist was enlarged into discussions of true and false peace. In a nutshell, “If it had granted peace to a traitor, was the Last Supper still a valid sacrament? If it had failed to convey true peace, did that make the communion invalid?” (117–18). Such debates also had a very contemporary and very relevant counterpart. In their meeting at Canossa in 1077, Henry IV walked barefoot in the snow before Gregory and their truce pointed to a papal victory: Henry agreed that the pope had the right to excommunicate the king as well as the power to rescind that excommunication, and he recognized Gregory as rightful pope. They sealed the deal with a Mass and sacrament. Yet, a few years later, Henry declared war on the papacy and drove Gregory into exile. Did Henry's participation in the communion pollute the entire Mass, or did he receive an empty sacrament? This led to an even broader discussion regarding the response of the Host to evil within the spirited debate regarding Judas at the Last Supper. Malegam rightly terms the details of these arguments, which he recounts in great detail, “theological and historical gymnastics,” but he believes that such arcane disputes were really about who could be members of the community of the church. Communion was the “proving ground for an individual's commitment to true peace” (149).
Chapter 5 explores the personal conflict between spirit and flesh as explained by twelfth-century “protoscholastics.” Malegam asserts that for these thinkers, the very process of exegesis transformed its practitioners through a disciplining process in which reason resisted carnality and asserted domination over the soul. The struggle, indeed war, to resist the body was, according to Malegam, “the closest approximation of true peace on earth” (155). A lengthy discussion of Augustine's views regarding reason and appetite follows. Here, again, we feel the discursive hand of the doctoral dissertation. More productively, Malegam then examines roughly contemporaneous exegetical readings of Genesis, beginning with the writings of Peter Damian and Bruno of Segni, and offers a solid discussion of the importance of the high medieval gloss in this debate regarding body and soul.
Chapter 6 examines the role of the vita activa in the lives of twelfth-century monks and canons. How could the religious simultaneously be apart from the world and a part of it? Malegam rightly finds the solution in the very act of evangelism. The religious are the peacemakers, who “brought peace to the individual, between individuals in society, and into the relationship between humanity and God” (202). Personal discipline or inner peace was the necessary precondition of such leaders. It was the inner struggle that made possible the external one. The role of peacemaker could and did lead to “a policy of disruptive and coercive conversion” (215) and such activities as Crusades, or as Malegam succinctly explains, “The aim of twelfth-century evangelists was to bring peace by means of the sword—disturbance as a means to tranquility” (216). Inevitably, Gregory the Great's observation that peacemakers might find it necessary to destroy peace in the process of making a more lasting one gave license to “turbulent peacemaking” (229) in the service of an aggressive church focused on growth and expanded earthly power.
The rise of communes in the twelfth century radically tested churchmen's conceptions of peace and who might be responsible for its imposition. Chapter 7 examines the frictions between communal oaths of mutual protection and self-regulation and the conceptions of peacemaking held by clerical observers. Communal oaths of peace could be viewed as seditious and temporal, while ecclesiastical oaths were bound and protected by the sacraments. Paranoia regarding false sacraments, a betrayal of divine will (not to mention concern over the very real loss of political power), drove the clergy to condemn communes and other localized mutual welfare organizations as diabolical inversions of true peace. Using the example of Le Mans, Malegam cites the twelfth-century Deeds of the Bishop of Le Mans as paradigmatic of the clerical criticism of communes—the commune was part of an inverted world in which the very norms of Christian community were challenged by social leveling, excessive cruelty, and conspiratorial oaths.
Yet, by the thirteenth century, the stories regarding communal origins of cities took on the aura of foundation myths—they were founded not in discord, but in internal harmony and peace. A well-ordered civic government was the “only feasible peace on earth” (263). The matter of this secular peace occupies chapter 8. Coming to terms with the reality of municipal governance, some clerics such as Rufinus of Sorrento posited the possibility of a good enough human peace, the Peace of Babylon. Malegam asserts (but does not prove) that by the thirteenth century, communes supported rather than challenged princely power and thus they became part of this workable, if imperfect, peace. Communal support of the papacy in the face of the invasions of Frederick Barbarossa enhanced the stature of communes as keepers of Christian peace. Malegam rightly examines the “terrifying peace” (268) of Barbarossa as a watershed moment for communal power. In the face of Barbarossa's appropriation of the vocabulary of Christian peace, coupled with his violent assaults on the papacy, the communes had become the true defenders of the church's peace. Malegam suggests that the compromise offered by Rufinus, that of a collaboration between clergy and communes, would provide the foundation for later theorists to deny the church any role in earthly government, or “defense of peace on earth” (265).
Malegam distills his thesis regarding the political impact of these theological arguments regarding peace in chapter 8. Here it is possible to trace the lines of his compelling yet complicated thesis: From a refusal to accept mere political tranquility in the late eleventh century, church reformers staked out a position of insurrection. The Investiture Controversy saw popes granting permission to monks and lay people to disobey ruling bishops in the name of refusing “false peace.” Later clerics turned their fire on the rising communes, which they saw as challenging royal and ecclesiastical authorities. Yet the communes, with judicious alliances with various levels of political elites, gained theological validity and, in fact, “civic peace became the standard for universal peace” (266), setting the stage for the potential replacement of the role of the church.
An epilogue brings the discussion into the fourteenth century with a discussion of Dante's Monarchia and Marsilius's Defender of Peace, both of which argue, with increasing vehemence, for the necessity of secular government to maintain peace on earth. Marsilius, of course, argued that the papacy offered only a false peace and was the greatest danger to worldly peace—and thus we have come full circle.
The theses of The Sleep of Behemoth are fresh and provocative. The book offers a startling new window on medieval theology. Within the limits of the treatises discussed, it is both well argued and persuasive. Whether the argument can be sustained across the larger landscape of medieval political theology and political history is a larger question that remains unanswered and perhaps is unknowable. Nonetheless, this is an important and admirable book.
