For a process with such an extensive impact on the history of Latin America, exile has not received the attention it deserves. In this formidably learned, widely researched book, the authors clearly demonstrate the central importance of exile to the history of Latin America from the struggles for independence to the present day. It is difficult to imagine any book that could surpass it as the definitive study of the process. The authors present their argument in the following terms: ‘Exile has been a regulatory mechanism for political systems unable to create pluralistic and inclusive models of participation’. Although initially an elite phenomenon, ‘it became a massive trend in the 20th century as mobilizations and more inclusive participation led to authoritarian rule’ (p. 1). A central theme is that the lack of democratic institutionalisation of both state and parties created a system of political polarisation which pushed both right and left to extremes – and both extremes used exile to rid the country of troublesome adversaries.
The early chapters offer a definition of what the authors call the ‘exilic condition’ and explore what this meant in the early years of the republics, at a time when notions of nationhood and of citizenship were far from defined or settled. Indeed, their argument is that exiles were important formative influences in the consolidation of the nation-state in Latin America. Of course, as the authors point out, it is not always easy to separate the categories of refugees, expatriates, exiles and émigrés. Exile is defined as the institutional exclusion of individuals from the nation and from participation in national politics.
It would be possible to spend a whole review discussing the elaborate and nuanced theories that the authors offer to explain why exile was so widespread, what the political consequences of exile were both for the countries from which the exiles were expelled and for the exiles themselves, as they sought to recreate their view of their nation while distant from it, and the way in which exiles influenced the politics of their new host countries. Such analysis is only a part of this long book, however. No less informative is the extended discussion of the fate of notable individuals, of their effect on both the country they had left and the one in which they now lived, and of their struggle to create notions of nationhood and citizenship that they wished to apply on their return. The book examines the way in which the exile community sought to keep alive the ideas – what the authors call ‘collective imageries’ – for which they had been expelled. Chile, infamous in the Pinochet period for the way in which it forced so many into exile, was in the nineteenth century a major recipient of exiles and influenced the views of many of them in their views of nation and state building. Many Latin American exiles came to Europe, above all to France and Spain, and the book provides an exploration of the ways in which residence in those countries influenced the views of those exiled there.
Later chapters move the study to the late twentieth century, when the international human rights movement and the effects of the internationalisation of exile added extra dimensions to the already complex story. Especially during the period of military dictatorships from the 1970s onwards, exile became a massive phenomenon. One chapter examines the contrasting experiences of Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and Chile: preferential treatment was offered to exiles from Chile partly because of the closer approximation of the Chilean political system to those of democracies in other parts of the world. The authors are careful to point out that, for all the cruelty of the process, exile could provide benefits for some individuals in terms of wider experiences of different political systems, better education and training, and integration into international networks – indeed, those who remained sometimes came to resent what they saw as privileged treatment for exiles. But many others in exile suffered the traumas of isolation, difficulties in finding rewarding work, and marital breakdowns. Exiles struggled to make sense of their political experience, and divisions between parties and ideologies sometimes remained sharper in exile than they did in the exiles' original countries. The authors' account cleverly blends theory with moving accounts of the experience of individuals forced into exile. They draw attention to the role played by some diplomats, notably of Sweden, who, often ignoring cautious governments at home, played a crucial role in opening their embassies to scores and sometimes hundreds of men and women escaping political persecution.
A separate chapter discusses in detail the story of presidents who suffered exile, and it comes as something of a surprise, to this reviewer at least, to learn that in the course of Latin American history since independence, 254 presidents, or politicians who later became presidents, have been sent into exile – making a total of 339 periods of presidential exile, as some were exiled more than once. Furthermore, exile was used not only by authoritarian governments but also by democratic ones.
This is an impressive book. It is formidably detailed and very long, but the arguments are so well sustained and the style so clear that it becomes a compelling read. It represents an invitation to scholars to take up this theme for individual countries.
