Largely a work of synthesis, Eugene Rogan's The Fall of the Ottomans offers an accessible and comprehensive account of the complex history of World War I in the Middle East. Given the range of topics one must cover in such a history, this is a major accomplishment, even if the book does not reveal significant new knowledge for specialists on the Ottoman experience of the war. In more than 400 pages of text divided into thirteen chapters, Rogan covers the period from the Young Turk revolution in 1908 to the postwar settlements and developments in the early 1920s.
His engaging narrative emphasizes the political and military aspects without ignoring the social and human face of the war. Rather than being a “side show,” as some Europeans claimed it to be, the war waged in the Ottoman territories was much more. The Allied prediction of a speedy victory over the Ottomans did not materialize. Instead, long campaigns in Sinai, Iraq, Palestine, and Syria diverted many hundreds of thousands of Allied soldiers from the “primary theaters” of the western and eastern fronts, and lengthened the war (pp. 403–4). Rogan writes that it was really the Ottoman entry into the war that turned Europe's conflict into a world war; often the Middle Eastern battlefields were the most international of the whole war. French and British imperial, dominion, and colonial soldiers from around the world came to clash with the many ethnic groups represented in the Ottoman armies (p. xvii). In this context, in a chapter called “A Global Call to Arms,” Rogan examines both the Allied recruitment of dominion and colonial troops and the German efforts to turn North African Muslim soldiers they had captured against their former comrades in arms. Placed in Halbmondlager (Crescent Moon Camp), a special camp outside of Berlin, they were given many comforts, dietary considerations beyond what was generally afforded to other prisoners of war, and a number of lectures on jihad by visiting Muslim activists (pp. 73–74, 270). Approximately 3,000 of these Muslim prisoners of Germany eventually contributed to the Ottoman war effort. Even if only briefly examined, the inclusion of their experience adds an interesting layer to the history of the war in the Middle East.
Another appealing quality of The Fall of the Ottomans is the way the author gives a human face to the politico-military story. By providing vignettes from diaries and memoirs of Turks, Armenians, Arabs, and others, Rogan gives the reader a sense of the experience and suffering of Ottoman soldiers and citizens alike. Two good examples of these from the Ottoman side are the personal narratives of medical corporal Ali Rıza, who fought on the Caucasus front, and the Armenian priest Grigoris Balakian, who was arrested on 24 April 1914 in Istanbul along with other Armenian intellectuals and political leaders. The former wrote of his experiences of war on the Caucasus front and how he wanted to poison the Armenians in the hospital where he worked. Eventually deported from Çankırı prison to Dayr al-Zur in February 1916, the latter recorded the experiences of his arrest, deportation, encountering the evidence of destroyed Armenian lives by the roadside on his long trek, miraculous survival, and impressions of occupied Istanbul after the armistice (p. 387).
Similarly, but from a significantly larger source base, Rogan also uses diaries or letters of the Allied soldiers—Britons, ANZACs, and Indians—to give us a sense of their experiences. More frequent inclusion of these vignettes from the “other” side makes the text more interesting to read, but in most chapters we hear as much, if not more, from the Allied side than from that of the Ottomans. Thus, the book's aim of telling the story of World War I through “Turkish and Arab experiences” is undermined to some extent. Likewise, the narrative in some chapters focuses more on the British military–political decision making and war experience than those of the Ottomans. Chapters about the Gallipoli, Mesopotamia, and Sinai-Palestine fronts (6, 8, 9, 10, and 12) stand out more in this regard. When the Ottomans are the focus of the narrative, every so often the sources still remain British. For example, reading about Halil (Kut) Pasha's statements and thoughts through British memoirs rather than through his own memoirs is an indirect way of providing an image of the man who accepted the surrender of General Charles Townshend at Kut al-Amara, and was also accused of and arrested for ordering the killing of Armenians. Rather heavy reliance on Western sources about the Mesopotamia front is perhaps more understandable because comparatively fewer primary and secondary sources are readily accessible for this theatre of war—despite the noticeable uptick in the number of recently published Ottoman war memoirs about Iraq. However, there is a significant amount of both older and recent Turkish-language scholarship and personal narratives about Gallipoli and the Sinai-Palestine fronts, which would have been helpful in providing more on the “Turkish and Arab experiences.”
Exploring British motivations and planning on the Ottoman front, Rogan writes that London feared looking vulnerable, especially after the loss at Gallipoli and the humiliating surrender in Kut of General Townshend and his 13,000 men in April 1916, because it might possibly prompt revolt in India (p. 404). In other words, the British did not fear Ottoman or German jihad propaganda as much as they dreaded seeming unable to defeat the seemingly feeble Ottoman Empire. Given the circumstances, Rogan suggests, in the early summer of 1916 the British needed the Hashamites, much more than they did in early 1915, to weaken the Ottomans by forcing them to divert troops and resources in case of an Arab revolt (p. 297). Thus, in order to score some victories after the two major defeats, negotiations with Sharif Husayn were put on a fast track to declare the Arab revolt as soon as possible during the summer of 1916.
Rogan consulted private papers, diplomatic, and military documents located in the New Zealand Archives, Australian War Memorial, US National Archives, Imperial War Museum, Cambridge University Library, and St Anthony's College, Oxford. These rich sources allow the author to add descriptive depth to the narrative. Some of Rogan's assertions, such as Mustafa Kemal being a “committed Ottomanist” at the time of the National Pact, are open to question (p. 394). Describing the nation as “Turkish” only would not have been the savviest thing to do since he was trying to appeal to Kurds, Arabs, and other ethnic groups as well. The declaration of mobilization, which Rogan notes as 1 August 1914 (p. 54–55), was actually on 2 August. Some issues also remain un- or underexplored. For instance, significant Ottoman military commitments to its allies in Galicia and Romania, which diverted the most experienced troops away from the Caucasus, Palestine, and Mesopotamian fronts where they were needed urgently, are not covered at all. Similarly, some elaboration on the overall ethnic makeup of the Ottoman soldiery, which the British and the French, as Rogan notes, simply referred to as “Turks”—much like Turkish nationalists do now—would have been helpful to show the ethnoreligious diversity of the Ottoman army. But this is perhaps too much to ask of a book that already pushes page limits and covers other issues in great detail.
An important strength of this book is the author's skill in presenting the complex history of World War I in the Middle East in a most accessible way. Rogan brings together the many aspects of the war into a single engaging volume. With his Middle Eastern or specialist readers probably already on his side in this respect, he deserves significant credit for reminding everyone that World War I in the Middle East was no mere “side show.” The Fall of the Ottomans is an important contribution to the rapidly growing body of scholarship on the Ottoman experience of World War I.
