For more than two decades, Israeli youth in the immediate aftermath of their mandatory army service have been backpacking through the so-called Third World in large numbers. The practice began in earnest in the late 1970s or early 1980s (accounts differ). By the mid-1990s, such treks had acquired the status of a national rite of passage among secular, middle, and upper middle class Jews, particularly those of European origin (Ashkenazim). This collection is the first to chronicle this national pastime and to situate it within the broader context of global travel on the one hand and Israeli society on the other.
As an Israeli phenomenon, backpacking has a particular historical genesis. The authors trace its emergence to the national crisis that followed the 1973 war (also known as the Yom Kippur War), with the profound insecurity it generated. It gathered strength over the course of the next generation after the Israeli invasion of Lebanon (1982) and outbreak of the first Palestinian intifada (1987)—events that, taken together, catalyzed a new culture of protest and critique within Israel and encouraged a breaking with canonical Zionist practices and mythos. When coupled with the influence of 1960s countercultures, which very selectively and belatedly made their mark on Israel, one saw a new generation of Israeli youth turning to the Third World (and particularly to India) as a means of distancing themselves from canonical nationalist practices and seeking spiritual alternatives in an era of political disillusion.
Interestingly, as the essays in this collection chronicle, the backpacker's putative desire to distance oneself from the nation-state has had, perhaps, paradoxical effects. As the authors describe in wonderful detail, Israeli backpackers abroad actively work to recreate Israeli forms and circuits in the midst of their travels (described here as an “enclave” phenomenon). Most live almost exclusively in Israeli worlds, following tourist routes and modes of interaction proscribed by other Israeli travelers and interacting primarily with their compatriots. Travel, it seems, becomes a way to reconstitute the nation-state at precisely the moment in the lifecycle of Jewish–Israeli youth (post-army) when fatigue with the nation state sets in most profoundly.
In addition to a comprehensive introduction, the book's most important contribution lies in its detailed ethnographic work, which carefully substantiates the quotidian forms that backpacking takes. Essays describe the now habitual Israeli routes and modes of travel, the norms of behavior that dominate in backpacking circles, and the stories told by travelers about their voyages that work to define the backpacking experience and secure its status as a national ritual. Together, these essays illustrate a cultural form that has acquired enormous import within mainstream Israeli society.
More than traveling practices are at issue. Rather, what is being described here is a backpacking culture, replete with its own language, sartorial norms, popular music, and modes of socialization. As some have argued elsewhere (Mevorah, 1997), the post-army trek as a nationalist rite of passage has lately upstaged even the army in terms of its nationalist function, that is, its role in facilitating integration into the nation state. In an era of dwindling Israeli commitment to the mythic nationalist project, these treks play an increasingly important role in the life cycle of the middle class, secular Israeli Jew, working to secure the transition into adulthood from army to civilian life. The backpacking trip is normative in terms of its popularity and works to generate “normative-ness” itself—constructing the terms of dominant Israeli culture, particularly among Israel's young generation.
Most of the essays in this volume explore Israeli backpacking to sites in Asia, particularly South and Southeast Asia, as they constitute the most popular backpacking destinations. India is the most celebrated among them, attracting some 20,000 Israelis annually. Sites in Central and South America lure only half as many Israeli visitors. Although relatively homogenous in terms of their class and ethnoracial demographics, Israelis travel to India with multiple agendas. Some seek spiritual alternatives and turn to Eastern religious traditions. Others seek release in drug experimentation. Most seem to traffic in a form of Ashkenazi Orientalism that has, since the 1960s, configured India as an alluring but nonthreatening “Other.” There, one can enjoy the East (often referred to as the “Far East” in the Israeli lexicon) without partaking of the Occidental terror that threatens closer to home. Note that, save the Sinai Peninsula, most Arab sites available to Israeli passport holders have not attained an analogous appeal.
The political valences of the travel experience are not ignored by Israeli travelers. Several authors discuss the rhetorics of conquest by which the travel experience is popularly coded in the Hebrew vernacular, by which—borrowing from a lexicon used to talk about the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza—some Israeli travelers are cast as “conquerors” and others as “settlers.” As the authors of the introduction astutely suggest, the ease of this rhetoric in the Indian context is a parodic means of negotiating uncomfortable politics at home.
Indeed, militarism looms in many forms. Although of parenthetical concern in this volume, some authors begin to suggest ways in which backpacking practices explicitly mimic those of soldiers. It should be noted that, whereas backpacking is the book's central focus, one chapter diverges from this paradigm to consider Israeli youth travel to concentration camps in Poland. Like the post-army ritual, this is a national rite of passage among high-school students, which effectively readies Israeli youth to defend their country by replaying the tragic history of European Jewish victimhood (of which Auschwitz is cast as paradigmatic instance) and the heroic history of martyrdom (anchored by the history of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, which is made to play an exemplary role in the Israeli version of Holocaust history).
In addition to its wealth of cultural detail, which should interest any scholar concerned with popular culture in the Middle East, the volume raises several important questions. What kinds of Israeli nationalisms and national identities are being generated in the backpacking context? The longing for India within post-1973 Israel emerges from a countercultural longing—a largely imported one. However, are the nationalist forms that are generated in Israeli backpacking spaces and societies in any way counternational—or, even more pointedly, counterhegemonic, as is tentatively proposed in the conclusion?
One wonders if the very question does not obscure the primary structural and temporal anchor of the backpacking experience—its status as a post-army institution. This reader would have liked a bit more reflection on the ramifications of this relationship and on the complicated interplay between violence (a word that is missing from this account) and travel. In its most popular and prevalent form, backpacking is practiced not merely as the sanctioned companion to army service but as a kind of cleansing ritual that makes the former possible and palatable. Thus, in addition to querying its counterhegemonic elements, is it not appropriate to consider the extent to which backpacking effectively functions to reproduce hegemonic Israeli institutions, albeit through the props and rhetoric of a (seemingly) countercultural practice?
