Paulo Fontes' study, originally submitted as a doctoral dissertation at the Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP), focuses on the history of São Miguel Paulista, a working-class district in the municipality of São Paulo. Fontes covers the years of the post-war republic, when São Paulo turned into an industrial metropolis and surpassed Rio de Janeiro in population. He tells the story of that process through the lens of São Miguel Paulista, which went from a physically separate town on the periphery of the big city to an urban space fully integrated into the metropolitan economy. In contrast to adjacent districts, primarily home to commuters, São Miguel Paulista had a strong industrial base. The rayon manufacturer Cia Nitro Química Brasileira opened its plant in 1937 and remained the dominant employer throughout the post-war republic. Fontes estimates that 25 per cent of the local population worked for Nitra Química in 1950 (p. 99). São Miguel Paulista was thus more of a company town than a commuter town.
Fontes tells his story in five chapters, one each on labour migration, urbanisation, community, local politics and social movements. Put slightly differently, they cover the workers' journey, the place they found, the community they built, and the community's political struggles with itself and for itself. The book is not a chronologically ordered narrative, however. Each chapter incorporates material from the entire post-war republic, which at times leads to overlap and also spreads information on specific issues across several chapters. The reader interested in Nitro Química's labour policies, for example, or in the place of north-eastern migrants in the community, will find the relevant pieces of information scattered throughout the text.
The book's great strength lies in its extensive use of oral history. Fontes interviewed 42 inhabitants of São Miguel Paulista, and he consulted the transcripts of another 54 interviews conducted as part of an oral history project by students at the Universidade Cruzeiro do Sul. He uses these sources to craft a fluid narrative that illuminates the everyday lives of the people of São Miguel Paulista. The first three chapters, in particular, demonstrate how oral history can help us study aspects of working-class lives that have eluded historical reconstruction for lack of written sources. Most importantly, Fontes' work sheds light on the human story behind Brazil's great migration, which brought many millions of rural dwellers, mostly from the north-east, to the industrial cities of the south-east in search of employment. The underlying social networks, the hardship of the trip and the formation of migrant communities come to life through the interviews with former migrants.
The book makes an important contribution to the historiography on São Paulo in the last two chapters, where Fontes places the story of the district in the broader context of the social and political struggles of the 1950s and early 1960s. We learn how local political leaders aligned with the dominant players of paulista politics, Jânio Quadros and Ademar de Barros, and how that affected specific political campaigns in São Miguel Paulista. Most fascinating is the story of the movement to gain independence from São Paulo and to turn São Miguel Paulista into a self-governed municipality. The movement lasted more than a decade in its various incarnations, but in plebiscites it never mustered the votes to defeat the established interests: the city of São Paulo wanted to retain the tax base, Nitro Química feared that a future municipal government may be controlled by the union, and Jânio Quadros did not want to lose one of his electoral strongholds in the municipality. Based on a particularly rich array of sources, including the records of São Paulo's political police, these chapters provide an intriguing account of the limits of localised working-class politics in the context of an industrial metropolis.
Oral histories merely complement the written record in the last two chapters, but they drive Fontes' narrative and analysis in the first three. That raises serious methodological questions beyond the obvious concern with faulty memories. Interviews represent personal and often deeply skewed perceptions of the past, which puts strict limits on their use as evidence. Fontes on occasion oversteps these limits – it is not sufficient, for example, to back up an assertion about Nitro Química's ‘power’ with interviews (pp. 101–2), as power is not just a matter of perception. Similarly, an interview cannot sustain a quantitative claim such as the one that Nitro Química was among the companies with the greatest share of workers from the north-east in the entire city of São Paulo (p. 109). Fontes tries to work around the problem, for example by stating that ‘many’ interviewees ‘explained the great number of dances and parties’ in São Miguel Paulista by citing ‘the strong presence of nordestinos’ (p. 155), but we never learn who the ‘many’ are or what share of the whole they represent. Such overreach casts unnecessary doubt on the enterprise of oral history.
On the other hand, Fontes fails to pursue some interesting leads that his interviews provide on local social relations. He highlights the importance of ‘sociability’ based on regional origin and argues that it contributed to building solidarity and constructing a class identity (p. 126), but he also discusses the paulistas' deep distrust towards nordestinos and mentions long-running conflicts between migrants from Bahia and Piaui, which strongly suggests that sociabilities based on regional identities did not provide a solid foundation for labour solidarity. A strong union depends on bonds of solidarity that transcend sociabilities based on regional origin, but Fontes does not explore how union leaders in São Miguel Paulista went about creating them. One reason he does not want to discuss the tension between sociability and solidarity, I suspect, is that he conceives of his book as an argument against a (now old) branch of Brazilian sociology that conceptualised industrial workers and urban dwellers as theoretically distinct subjects. Fontes considers that distinction to be artificial and worries that drawing a sharp line between sociability and solidarity may appear to reinforce the divide. The irony, of course, is that such a discussion would get him exactly where he wants to go, namely to conclude that we cannot understand the union member without understanding the urban dweller and his migrant background. It is time to stop beating the dead horse that is old-school sociology and instead delve deeper into the original historical questions posed by Fontes' truly innovative research.
