Jennifer Ebbeler has written an important book on the letters of Augustine of Hippo. It propounds a clear and convincing thesis: Augustine adopted a novel approach to the writing of letters, a form of ‘corrective correspondence’. Ancient letters, as expressions of amicitia, tended to avoid open criticism. Augustine, however, wrote letters which highlighted the error of his addressee in a manner which invited, indeed required a response. E.'s book traces the consequences of this unconventional approach for Augustine's interactions with Christian contemporaries. Unsurprisingly, his correspondents rarely took kindly to it.
After an extended preface (vii–xii), the introduction (3–26) offers a concise summary of this main argument (3–13), the transmission and editions of Augustine's letters (13–20), and the state of research into Latin letters in general and Augustine's in particular (20–5). A final note (25–6) explains the (understandable) decision to use Caecilianist instead of Catholic for Augustine's Christian faction — though to call this replacement ‘neutral’ (26 n. 88) is somewhat misleading. The first chapter, ‘Rebuke, Friendship, and Community’ (27–62), provides the context for Augustine's ideas about communal literary correction. It considers his ideal of lovingly critical Christian friendship (as portrayed in the Confessions) and its scriptural and philosophical influences (most notably, Paul's rebuke of Peter in Galatians 2:11–14). E. notes that previous letter-writers had also delivered literary admonishments. The key difference was that, unlike the authors of those polemical libri, Augustine expected his addressee both to respond and to admit fault (50–6).
Chs 2 and 3 provide close readings of Augustine's first attempts at corrective correspondence (63–75) and of his epistolary relationships with two notable Christian contemporaries, Paulinus of Nola (81–99) and Jerome (75–81, 101–50). Comparison of these varied exchanges highlights the acute specificity of the circumstances required for Augustine to initiate such a correspondence, and for it to be effective. More than any other contemporary Christian, Paulinus was open to epistolary experimentation and Augustine's spiritual guidance. And yet Augustine did not openly correct him; Paulinus’ error did not threaten the community (81–2, 98) and, it is implied, he was too useful a friend to risk alienating (91, 97). Jerome was not so fortunate. E. gives a masterful analysis of this infamously ‘star-crossed’ (113) letter exchange, with all its mishaps, mixed messages and (sometimes wilful) misunderstandings. Prudently trading psychological speculation for literary analysis, she sets out what both of these artful rhetorical operators might have known and sought to achieve at each stage of the correspondence. It ended in something of a stalemate; Augustine then reverted to a more traditional epistolary mode in their dealings (147–50).
Chs 4 and 5 show how Augustine adapted his letter-writing to individuals less straightforwardly part of his Christian community: the Donatists (151–89) and Pelagius (191–225). To deal with the former required considerable creativity on his part. Attempts at corrective exchanges with Donatist laymen (at least in the years preceding Honorius’ anti-Donatist edict of a.d. 405) were complemented by disingenuously epistolary responses to missives by Donatist bishops not addressed to him, and letters cataloguing transgressions of imperial law. These latter laid the groundwork for a more robust form of correction: state coercion. Pelagius posed different problems. E. argues, contrary to general scholarly opinion, that Augustine did not realize that Pelagius supported the doctrines (and had even written some of the treatises) on grace he himself had attacked in the years a.d. 410–416. Once Augustine did realize, Pelagius had already proven himself an unreliable correspondent. He thus skipped straight to more polemical and coercive forms of correction, but had to justify this move by retrojecting a corrective colouring to his earlier, blandly amicable correspondence with Pelagius. E.'s suggestion of post facto rationalization is convincing (211–21); her argument that simple ignorance was the real reason for Augustine's inaction seems more problematic — and unnecessary given the variety of circumstances which led him to avoid epistolary correction of known error.
The conclusion (227–34) recapitulates the overarching argument and sets out its implications for future study. E. restates that Augustine's novel approach to the exchange of letters was an ‘unmitigated failure’ (231). This appears unsurprising given the precise conditions required for success. It might be wondered why Augustine persisted with his experiments — or suggested that his motives were rather less charitable. It is the great merit of this book that its author consistently presents the range of possible goals Augustine could have pursued in each of these literary exchanges. E. rightly gives the bishop the benefit of the doubt: ‘we have no real cause to question the sincerity of Augustine's claims that he cared deeply about … the salvation of his fellow Christians’ (229, cf. 8–9). But she shows how this was not incompatible with polemical strategizing and personal ambition, and wryly arches an eyebrow at some of Augustine's more breathtaking manoeuvres. Fittingly, there is a real sense that E. has herself engaged in an extended dialogue with Augustine and come to know his epistolary eccentricities just as well as a Jerome or Paulinus. She treats these letters and their writer in the spirit of charitable criticism with which they were composed. Her book is an important contribution to the study of Augustine, late antique Christianity and ancient epistolography.
