Adam Ferguson was a figure of considerable influence during his long lifetime (1723–1816)—chair of moral philosophy at the University of Edinburgh, author of the widely read Essay on the History of Civil Society, and, perhaps most prominently, friend to Hume, Smith, and Sir Walter Scott, who penned his epitaph. After his death, however, his intellectual legacy was neglected, if not forgotten, until the recent renaissance in Ferguson studies that began in earnest with the 1996 republication of the Essay. Ferguson revivalists have been particularly keen on his reputation as the Scottish Cato—the patriotic theorist of civic republicanism who might serve as the public-spirited rejoinder to the Scottish embrace of the civilizing forces of commercial liberalism.
Now joining this budding current of scholarship is Iain McDaniel's Adam Ferguson in the Scottish Enlightenment, a careful and precise study that contributes substantially to our understanding of Ferguson's thought and its trajectory over the course of his long intellectual career. By situating Ferguson's critiques of British commercial and imperial culture within the context of a far broader political project—assessing through philosophical history “Britain's prospects as an extensive commercial state”—McDaniel goes some way in disentangling Ferguson's idiosyncratic sort of civic humanism from the liberal-republican paradigm in which it has been ensnared.
McDaniel's treatment of Ferguson begins with an encounter with Montesquieu. As early as the 1750s, when he began work on the now-lost “Treatise of Refinement,” Ferguson followed “President Montesquieu” in using the lens of history to assess the prospects of large commercial republics. In particular, Ferguson finds inspiration in three thematic elements of Montesquieu's thought: first, Montesquieu's worries over the potential in modern European states for the emergence of military government; second, his unfavorable account of large republics, which, in his view, tended to collapse into despotism; third, his historical account of Rome, which provided the empirical background against which modern government could be assessed.
As McDaniel demonstrates, however, Ferguson was no slavish follower. He rejected Montesquieu's view—shared by Hume and other contemporaries—that the lessons of the Roman republic were increasingly irrelevant for modern, “neo-German” nations, and that the perfection of the English constitution was sufficient protection against arbitrary power. Indeed, Ferguson held the very perfection of the English system to be the root of the problem—by relieving its citizens of the need for vigilance with regards to their rights, it engendered political and military complacency. Ferguson feared that this civic relaxation—a “dangerous form of moral, political, and military complacency” (58)—would further expose the vulnerabilities of the British system, and in particular, its susceptibility to populist pressures. As elites abandoned military service for political and commercial pursuits, thereby filling the army's ranks with the cruder sort, an arrangement arose in which “those who had an ‘interest’ in the maintenance of the established order no longer had ‘power’ on their side, whereas those with ‘power’ . . . had neither ‘the inclination or the interest’” (59). The great danger here was the emergence of a leader who, enabled by Britain's whetted imperial appetite, ennobled by populist sentiment, and backed by an opportunistic military, would overturn the constitution and reduce Britain—and potentially Europe—to despotism. More remarkable is the fact that Ferguson offered this analysis a quarter-century before the rise of Napoleon.
This analysis of the direction and impetus of Ferguson's work constitutes the first two chapters of McDaniel's book, and much of the rest of the work examines various threads of Ferguson's vision for constitutional decline: the enticements of commercial imperialism, which would lure the British into military adventurism and the subject of national goals to commercial interests (chap. 4); the late-century wave of revolutionary and republican sentiment, which threatened to reshape the contours of power in the West and upset the constitutional balance that had moderated monarchical power in Britain (chap. 7); and, in a particularly illuminating discussion of Ferguson's neglected 1783 tome History of the Progress and Termination of the Roman Republic, the importance of revisiting the causes of the Roman collapse (chap. 5). Indeed, tracing with McDaniel the roots of Ferguson's worries over Britain's prospects, the reader is frequently struck with the remarkable aptness of the Roman analogy—to see in the rapacious and lucrative character of English imperialism the spoils-driven expansionism of the late republic, and, in the populist fervor of the Wilkes Affair, the demagoguery of the Gracchi (60–62).
It is in reorienting our understanding of Ferguson around this enduring political anxiety that McDaniel makes his principal—and substantial—contribution. The positive theoretical payoff is McDaniel's discussion, found predominantly in chapter 6, of Ferguson's political “project,” which was “grounded upon the ideal of a voluntary civic militia and, even more centrally, the reestablishment of the connection between the civil and military departments of the state” (155). The driving idea behind the revived militia, which Ferguson advocated as early as his 1756 pamphlet Reflections Previous to the Establishment of a Militia, was the creation of a new, civic-minded, meritocratic elite that would act as a stabilizing force in British politics. These new ranks would address British decline in at least two ways: first, by establishing a civic-oriented source of social and political honors to counteract the effects of markets and luxury on social standards of excellence; and second, by populating the higher ranks of the military with a patriotic elite that might serve as a mediating force between an increasingly populist British politics and the command of the military. McDaniel's arguments here are particularly valuable—they retrieve Ferguson's militia project from its status as a curiosity, a nostalgic rejoinder to commercial advances, or a prefiguring of twentieth-century preoccupations with civil society and social capital; instead, we find a Ferguson preoccupied with reestablishing rank and nobility at the outset of the age of revolutions. Here, his politics are grounded on stability, not participation; more Montesquieu than Cato, more Burke than Arendt.
McDaniel's style is austere and concise; there is little consideration of Ferguson's fascinating biography, and even less consideration of the consequences of his thought for current debate over globalized commerce or the near-complete abandonment of the military vocation in developed economies. This is fine, of course, and the work stands on its own as a sharp and focused piece of intellectual history. The work's weaknesses are two—one more weighty than the other. The first and weightier problem is that the author's intellectual contextualization too frequently feels incomplete: interesting discussions of contemporaries like Hume, Millar, and Dalrymple, as well as French figures like Mably and Raynal, are sprinkled throughout the manuscript without a sense of their significance. These figures speak around Ferguson without really speaking with him. Secondly, and less importantly, there is the curious matter of the title. “Adam Ferguson in the Scottish Enlightenment” strikes the reader as both flavorless and inaccurate—indeed, as I've argued here, one of the volume's virtues is the way it invites us to stop interpreting Ferguson through his more illustrious friends, and the encounter with Montesquieu provides its theoretical backbone.
These relatively minor quibbles aside, McDaniel has provided us with a new and better way of thinking about Adam Ferguson. Scholars of the Scottish Enlightenment and eighteenth-century political thought more broadly will find plenty of interest here, particularly with regard to Montesquieu's legacy and the debates over the status and governance of the military in the modern nation state; as such, it fits nicely beside John Robertson's The Scottish Enlightenment and the Militia Issue (John Donald, 1985).
