Much has been written on the scientific revolution, but little on the import of commerce for the new natural philosophy. Hal Cook, in his immensely rich Matters of Exchange, attempts to fill the gap. Although it is not entirely new to argue that commerce was decisive for the outlook of Dutch early modern society, Cook's concentration on science and medicine has given the argument a new dimension. His focus on what he calls the ‘shared values’ of trade and enquiry shows convincingly how merchants as well as natural philosophers, academic and private, owed their wealth and knowledge to Dutch sea-bound trade and discovery.
According to Cook, objectivity, accuracy and care in the accumulation, description and translation of objects and knowledge were values that stood at the heart of Dutch thinking about commerce and also – and not at all coincidentally – stimulated the rise of science and medicine in the early modern Dutch Republic. Especially important in Cook's view was the urge for objectivity, which he understands as the ambition to acquire ‘the knowledge of objects without reference to intuition or innate knowledge, the corporeal knowledge of things that can be experienced by the bodily senses, information from which can be exchanged’ (p. 19). Cook takes the Dutch concern with objectivity to explain the preoccupation with meticulous natural description and the connected refusal to speculate about causes. He notes too that commerce and science alike depended on ‘credibility’, and placed a premium on such values as modesty, honesty and the use of plain and precise language. In both domains, furthermore, the latest technologies of production led to better tools of analysis which allowed even more precise descriptive methods – as when, for instance, better methods of preparing specimens advanced anatomical knowledge, the single-lens microscope made a new world of life and form visible, and chemical colour indicators were applied to the analysis of tea.
Cook points to the medical marketplace as the exemplary site where the ‘objective’ knowledge of ‘matters of fact’ and commercial interests went hand in hand. Not only did the influential materialist philosophy of Descartes and the Cartesians owe much to the Dutch preoccupation with natural objects and their description, but medics – academic physicians as well as commercially interested apothecaries and others – profited from the exotic plants and rarities, and knowledge about them, brought home from the East and West Indies. In order to transform local knowledge into universal (and thus exchangeable) truths, natural philosophers were continuously engaged in translational practices whereby, in most cases, they extracted the indigenous and ‘speculative’ ideas of the locals, by a process reminiscent of that by which merchants destroyed the inhabitants of Banda along with their relatively egalitarian culture in order to ‘Dutchize’ the production of nutmeg. Fascinatingly, Cook relates how Asian medical practices and instruments were tried, adopted and described, but only in terms of the vocabulary of Dutch materialistic language. He stresses that we need to take into account how far the accumulation and exchange of knowledge ‘changed the kind of knowledge produced’ (p. 411).
The major strength of Matters of Exchange – its demonstration of strong links between simultaneously rising commerce and science – is at the same time, however, a source of weakness. Cook leaves little room for other explanations of science's development in the time and place that concern him. He is particularly keen to downplay any role for religion. In order to suggest that Holland was full of the spirit of commerce rather than of religion, he describes a country of opportunists, trimming their sails according to the (trade) wind. He ascribes values hitherto recognized as Calvinist, such as sobriety, honesty, domesticity and so on, to the commercial need to be trustworthy and reliable, and maintains that the religious views of many natural philosophers did not matter or remained private. But this is surely too simple. A multifaceted view of the factors that stimulated the Dutch scientific revolution is called for, one that would focus on the manifold ways in which commerce, religion and science were inextricably interwoven. Such an approach would acknowledge the indisputable religious diversity in the Dutch Republic, in contrast with Cook's understanding of ‘religious’ as, it often seems, synonymous with ‘strict Calvinist’. In line with that understanding, he dwells on Leiden University, where strict Calvinist theologians never really got the upper hand in university management, and where – to his mind, as a consequence of this – science flourished. He similarly argues that the most successful ‘scientists’ were not very religious, meaning that they were not strict Calvinists. But, again, such emphases leave unexamined the possible influence of more moderate strands of Calvinism and other theological doctrines – for instance Arminian, Roman Catholic or Mennonite – on the business of science.
Notwithstanding this limitation, Matters of Exchange is an impressive study that decidedly broadens our understanding of early modern Dutch science and medicine. It will no doubt prove very important and influential, not least thanks to Cook's remarkable talent for telling stories – a talent that makes this book a tremendously entertaining read.
